Why would an economic historian who is not a Canada specialist want to read a book about tenants in Cramahe Township in Ontario during the first two-thirds of the nineteenth century? Because by her analysis of the region's tenants and landlords, Catharine Wilson helps us to understand tenancy, especially its operation in a developing or frontier location. She extends to Canadian tenants recent scholarship on topics such as the role of risk, agricultural ladders, and tenancy as a learning mechanism. Her discussion of legal issues incorporates an analysis of how custom and law affected landlord-tenant relations. The book emphasizes the prevalence and virtues of tenancy, contrasting those conclusions to what she sees as liberal bias, which has led to ignorance of tenants' existence and prejudice against the form of tenure.
Wilson's painstaking research provides a nuanced account of the strategies used by tenants to create a place in the growing Canadian economy. She connects 1842 census information for owners and tenants in Cramahe to other kinds of evidence and can thus determine the characteristics of individual tenants and landlords and their progress over time. Joining this micro-history to concepts from economics and law, Wilson writes a book that has the understanding of time and place that are hallmarks of good history and the conceptual rigor that comes from social science.
Wilson's conclusion is that tenants benefited from the system. In the first half of the nineteenth century, they represented about one-half to one-fourth of the farming population, though their proportion then declined. They tended to be newcomers, especially immigrants, and learned about farming though their experiences. They took advantage of not having to buy a farm and invested in equipment and animals.
Wilson distinguishes several types of tenants, though the differences among them and between them and owners were not large. Share tenants—conceding one-third to two-thirds of their crop to their landlords—were younger and subject to more control than cash renters. They often lacked tools, which the system allowed them to receive from the owners. Share tenancy was not oppressive, but a short-term arrangement that “could provide families with a place to live and an income until such time as they moved on or inherited” (p. 181).
Cash tenants paying a fixed amount preferred their arrangement to renting on shares because they were subject to fewer restrictions and received higher earnings. Particularly favored were those with long leases, such as the ones for ten to twelve years on Canada Company land and twenty-one years on Crown and clergy reserves. They were secure and differed little from owners with mortgages—both could keep their land as long as they made regular payments. An indication of tenants' security was that they could sell and bequeath their leases and transfer improvements to an incoming tenant. Though these practices did not have legal force, landlords accepted them because they encouraged improvements.
Landlords of all of the four categories that Wilson divides them into treated their tenants well. The “Old World landlords” (p. 71) wanted to recreate British estates in Canada and to be regarded as benevolent lessors. Rents for government lands were low because the state's main goal was to develop the new territories with a satisfied, stable population. Speculators and developers, on the other hand, were interested in profiting from land sales, so they wanted short-term leases, but did not anticipate big profits from rents. Finally, ordinary farmer landlords often rented to relatives and did not seek maximum returns. Thus tenants received good terms from all types of owners, and their relationship did not produce the kind of open hostility and tenant movements found in Ireland and New York. The reason why landlordism was weak and tenancy strong, as Wilson puts it, (p. 215) was the large supply of land. To keep tenants from moving elsewhere in Canada or to the United States, landlords had to treat them well.
The tenants in the community studied were successful. About a third climbed the “agricultural ladder” to become owners of farms. Another third remained tenants, but that was not necessarily a sign of failure since the long leases on reserve land provided many advantages. Another third left the township, but that could mean either success or failure.
Wilson repeatedly contrasts the successful and contented Cramahe tenants with their oppressed and sometimes rebellious counterparts elsewhere. Yet not all nineteenth-century tenants were oppressed. Her analysis would tell us more about the liberal understanding of tenants if she took into account liberals' favorable views of the operators of large farms in England and on the plains of northern France who were, if anything, more prosperous than the Ontario tenants. Overall, however, this is a minor omission and does not detract from Wilson's success in demonstrating that tenancy could be a strategy for success in a frontier environment.
