Few institutions influence the lives of American actors more than the Actors' Equity Association. AEA, also known as Equity, determines the conditions under which actors audition, rehearse, and perform. It even polices actors' stage names. The union, in short, sets the terms of the American stage acting profession, and, in turn, the American theatre. To theatre studies' shame, AEA has received hitherto but scant critical attention. Fortunately, Sean P. Holmes has given us a thoughtful, lively, clearly written, and cogently argued book about AEA's early years.
Weavers of Dreams, Unite! explains why AEA came into existence, depicts its landmark strike in 1919, and interrogates how the union, in its first decade, established its relationship both to theatre producers and to its members, onstage and, unsuccessfully, in Hollywood. Along the way, the book critiques the union's reluctant attention to female performers, its racism, and its ambivalent relationship to the wider labor movement. Holmes depicts unionization as a process not only of organizing individuals, but also of “defin[ing] what it meant to earn a living on the stage” (2) in the 1920s and 1930s.
The first two chapters explore AEA's evolution from a voluntary association critiquing the theatre's artistic decline to a trade union that challenged intransigent producers with a crippling strike. Though founded in protest against theatre's industrial commercialization, AEA was practically minded from the first, seeking a standard acting contract that would protect actors from autocratic managers, unpaid rehearsals, and frequent strandings when touring productions suddenly closed. Early negotiations with producers' organizations were cordial, if not productive. As the years dragged on, however, the organization inched slowly toward unionism as AEA leaders struggled for the respect both of increasingly recalcitrant producers and of their own members, some of whom argued “that art was in some sense incompatible with labor and that actors could not make common cause with other groups of industrial workers” (46). Nevertheless, by 1919 AEA's members resoundingly chose unionization and the union's greatest weapon: the strike.
The third chapter focuses on the remarkable thirty-day strike in 1919, which established the standard contract between actors and employers, and confirmed AEA's right to bargain collectively with theatrical producers. Holmes depicts richly the strike's theatricality, including a melodramatic confrontation between a sobbing chorus girl (“I don't want to work—I'm out on strike!!” [73]) and her suggestively named manager, Henry Savage. Even as the AEA won support from Times Square businesses and other trade unions, difficult questions arose in its own ranks about the status of chorus members and how to handle the sizable body of antistrike performers. Despite such problems, the strike's conclusion marked a clear victory for actors' unionism, though not yet for AEA as a dominant force in the acting profession.
The organization's consolidation after the strike depended on adopting what Holmes calls a “contractualist vision [. . .] of labor–management relations” (107) in which both union members and employers played a part. In practice, this meant that AEA worried about its members' legitimacy and respectability. AEA policed legitimacy in the 1910s when it excluded female choristers from formal membership, resisted merging with vaudevillians, and worried over an affiliation with the blue-collar unions in the American Federation of Labor. After the strike, AEA insisted not only on actors' rights, but also on their responsibilities, including adherence to the standard contract and the maintenance of social respectability in a dimly regarded profession. Even as AEA rescued performers stranded by shuttered tours, they also enforced order for producers, responding harshly to reports of drunkenness or female promiscuity and keeping well clear of associations between theatre and homosexuality.
Holmes's core argument about AEA and professionalization is convincing, illustrated with engrossing tales from AEA's archives, all well-documented in the footnotes. His exposition, however, is less reliably complete. (The final chapter, documenting AEA's dismal efforts to become the union for screen actors, has the clearest narrative line.) Such narrative thinness reflects in part the book's dialogue with fields other than theatre studies, particularly labor history and film studies. In Holmes's reading AEA's modified closed shop policy is thus less significant for its effects on theatrical production than for its divergence from other models of trade unionism. Holmes always returns to what AEA meant to and for actors, but the book's occasional inattentiveness to theatre history means that we must continue relying on a few, old AEA histories, particularly Alfred Harding's The Revolt of the Actors (New York: William Morrow, 1929), for information about the who, what, where, when, and how of AEA's formative years. Nowhere, for instance, does Holmes mention the actual start date of the 1919 strike, 7 August. The details of AEA's standard contract receive but a passing discussion. And the union's leaders remain mere names on a page, epithetically reduced to one or two famous roles from their performing careers. The result is a book about labor oddly removed from the tremendous effort required to build and sustain a union. Although Holmes's light narrative touch keeps the book moving quickly through a rich and complex history, that delicacy fails to convey the momentousness of AEA's establishment and consolidation. This admirable book begins to fill a vacuum in scholarship on the AEA and should inspire more work that accounts for what AEA meant—and means—to the American stage.
