Himadeep Muppidi has written a short, sophisticated, and provocative book that pushes its readers to think hard about global politics. His main hypothesis is that a thorough analysis of the “contestations over the social meaning of the global” (p. xvii) allows us to explore new “spaces and strategies for resisting the colonialization of the global” (p. xviii). In the end, however, the reader feels a little puzzled regarding the fruits of the exercise, including whether we have really gained a better understanding of global politics or whether we have been offered new possible ways for doing politics globally.
This book is part of a growing international relations literature that has its origins in critical theory; in particular, in postcolonial studies (Edward Said and Gayatri Spivak are two of the references often quoted). This new theorizing is no longer content to challenge the epistemological foundations of classical IR thinking, but it is also much more politicized. It is therefore no surprise that Muppidi starts with a critique of traditional theorizing and how rationalist or weak constructivist thinking reproduces colonial conceptions of politics, instead of providing a new and more inclusive global focus. His “critical constructivism” (title of Chapter 2) is thus also a political statement that is supposed to offer new perspectives for how the global can be perceived in a world of multiple interpretations through the use of the concept of “social claim.” According to the author, a social claim is always articulated against somebody and thus takes into account the intersubjective construction of the world. Taken further, social claims constitute actors but are also shaped by them and thus can tell us something about the production of a global order. In his own words: “The production of the global is a systemic phenomenon that necessarily has a mutually constitutive relationship with the situated practices of societal actors…. Any empirical analysis of globalization must therefore examine the embedded practices of specifically situated social actors to see how their actions are either productive or transformative of this systemic phenomenon” (p. 28).
Muppidi provides two short case studies—one of India and one of the United States—in which he shows how social claims toward the global are articulated and how they generally reproduce a colonial practice. He does this either by situating India within the Western liberal economic system or by taking the United States as an implicit role model that should be copied. The “productions of the global” (title of Chapter 5) are further analyzed by showing the interconnectedness between the U.S. political and the Indian political space and how social claims in one can have major repercussions in the other. Such “global conversations” (p. 79) are illustrated using the American Competitiveness Bill, as well as the discussion surrounding the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty.
The author concludes by discussing possible means of “resistance and rearticulation” (title of Chapter 6). This discussion constitutes the book's most interesting part, as two alternatives of how one can approach global politics critically are closely scrutinized. The first is a series of ads in the New York Times that were published by various Western nongovernmental organizations, which are supposed to demonstrate that differences in the world are being lost, in short that McDonaldization is taking place everywhere. Muppidi convincingly criticizes such a view as not allowing a real alternative to the neoliberal mainstream but as assuming a priori that everybody else simply wants to stay different and that we in the West have a right to such a difference. He sharply shows us that global politics should not hypocritically perceive that the colonized simply like to keep up their traditions and that we think we know that this is best for them. In short, the voices of the colonized have to be taken seriously, even if their utterances are unpleasant for us.
The second political statement Muppidi discusses and contrasts with the ads of the NGOs in the New York Times is the articulation of the Indian intellectual Arundhati Roy, who proclaims herself to be in exile after the Indian government tested its nuclear bomb capacity. Muppidi has lots of sympathy for Roy's proclamation because he sees this as a step whereby a broader, nonnational political community is taken into account, and thus the voices of the colonized are also heard and understood. In short, such political acts lead “to other valuable forms of political association, possibly to an alternative understanding of the global” (p. 101).
Overall, the book has one significant strength and two major weaknesses. Its major strength is Muppidi's unorthodox reading of the global and the challenge he puts not only to mainstream rationalist thinking about IR but also to many constructivist understandings of the global. Scholarship like Muppidi's can thus make an impact, as we are pushed to think much harder about the political meaning of the “global” than if we only stay in our mainstream camps. From a reading of this book, it is obvious that it does not suffice to identify ideas as another important independent variable. The author's “bringing in” of the colonial and the postcolonial identities shows that political actors have to be contextualized within broad political structures in order to understand their actions. It is therefore not enough to discuss liberal economic policy as an idea, or even as an ideology, in order to understand the revolutionary impact liberalism has in India. However, a history of the colonial past of India—that portrays it as striving for Western modernity while trying to stay independent at the same time—allows us much better to see the revolutionary potential once the colonized is part of the global (that lies in the once-colonized becoming part of the global).
Unfortunately, there are also two weaknesses. The first is conceptual: Muppidi aims to enlighten us about the politics of the global, but he primarily speaks about the repercussions of social claims made in India and the United States. The “Other” is thus almost always perceived as a nonnational, and only at the end of Chapter 3 (p. 56) is the role of expatriate Indians and of the diaspora as postcolonial agents acknowledged. Here, Muppidi could have made an even stronger case and argued for it theoretically as, especially in the U.S.-Indian case, new transnational and maybe even transcolonial spaces and identities develop. The second weakness concerns coherence; the book leaves the reader unsatisfied overall because the final conclusion—building up a new and nonnational identity against the establishment—is neither worked out enough nor anticipated in the preceding pages. We can easily share his assessment that Arundhati Roy's imagined exile “transcends the limits of the national” (p. 100) and successfully strives for a new form of political association. However, the four chapters before did not prepare the ground for judging whether Roy's action is a generally recommendable one. In other words, should we all go into exile—even so it is only imagined—whenever the government does something to which we object? This can hardly be the Politics of the Global we all strive for.
In conclusion, there are thus many well-written and interesting sections that give readers pause for thought, but they do not speak to one another enough. In the end, we get wonderful pictures of the trees; we, however, are left alone to find the theory or the practice of the global forest by ourselves.
