Michael Ziser's Environmental Practice and Early American Literature may not conform to the expected conventions of ecocritism, yet his book is remarkable in that it is one of the first monographs of ecocriticism's fourth wave, or “material turn.” Further, it is notable in that among ecocritics participating in the fourth wave, Ziser is one of only a few studying early American literature, and, as such, his book distinguishes itself as a welcome addition to an emerging movement within the field.
Ostensibly a literary study but broadly researched and interdisciplinary in scope, Ziser examines how tobacco, potatoes, apples, and the art and practice of beekeeping figure among the nation's first literary tropes. By focussing on cultivated crops, he embarks on a truly complex refiguring of ecocritical and environmental perspectives. Drawing on concepts of “more-than-human” “quasi-agents” (3–4) – in this case agricultural products – he inquires after the manner in which material agents inform, if they do not outright contribute to, literary production. His inquiry attempts to uncover the deeply embedded entanglements of human and nonhuman actors as they transcend traditional subject–object boundaries predicated purely on human use and consumption. In his own words, Environmental Practice is his attempt to move beyond a way of thinking about the environment in which “nonhuman things … are simply inert materials indifferently available for human social shaping” (2). Put another way, in collapsing the distance between human and nonhuman, Ziser seeks to suspend the orthodox history of Nature with a capital N, in which Nature is so often portrayed as a stable, sublime, transcendent other. He crafts what he calls “ecocultural histories” (13) of the crops listed above, related to but distinguished conceptually from extant “environmental histories” and, it would seem, “bioregional histories,” both of which maintain the usual human–non-human subject–object positions. The difference, for Ziser, is that these earlier modes are less committed to presenting humans and things as mutually formed and interacting, especially when it comes to literary production. Likewise, he is careful to distinguish his project from commodity histories that chronicle a thing without fully depicting its interwoven human–thing connectivity (59). In this regard, for its dedication to an intricate, increasingly relevant theoretical apparatus, and for its appeal to food studies, place studies, and postmodern ecocriticism, to name but a few, Ziser's introduction especially should become necessary reading in the coming years for scholars across the humanities, whether they study the early American period or not.
Throughout, Ziser's close readings of texts and images stand out as exceptional. However, the most successful chapters are those dealing with tobacco and with apples. Depicting what he calls “a serious crisis of confidence in cultural authority” (28) wrought by the spread of tobacco use in the Old World after contact, he asserts that tobacco became “a force and an agent of culture rather than its mere conductor” (32), “interrupt[ing] and displac[ing] culture's ability to discriminate between opposites” (33). Language such as this promotes an uncanny sense underlying human motivation – and literary production – as the result of its more-than-human contacts, suggesting that such interactions are both immediate and far-reaching. This breakdown in the ability to discriminate between opposites becomes, perhaps, the common theme of the book. In the apple chapter, too, in close readings of Melville, Bradstreet, Thoreau, and others, Ziser points to the difficulties of the fixed positions of “cultivated” and “wild” working themselves out in allegories relating to apples and apple trees, specifically as they pertain to imperial control, both literal and figurative, of the American landscape.
Less effective are the chapters on potatoes and bees, for the simple fact that, frustratingly, despite their stated intentions, neither potatoes nor bees figure very prominently in either chapter. Still, despite oblique treatment, the former chapter is most relevant to food studies, providing a philosophical foundation for understanding how staple crops imply “a widening circle of ecological relationships” (67), while the bee chapter, although a significant addition to Cooper scholarship, may overreach claims that Cooper's novels can support.
Ziser's provocative conclusion brings together his ideas of distributed agency by redirecting entrenched ecocritical attention away from a problematic “pastoral isolation” and toward “georgic collectivities” instead (159). Though nuanced, this crucial change in perspective from pastoral to georgic invites us to radically reconceptualize even “complex pastoral” texts like Walden, the working landscapes of which, he explains, resist dividing the natural and social, material and symbolic worlds (177). Sometimes dense, sometimes digressive, Environmental Practice is well worth our critical attention.
