No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 July 2005
This short history of Turkey, from Oneworld's series of introductions to countries from Argentina to Japan, chronicles several centuries of Turkey's political development with concision and authoritative detail. Beyond politics, however, the reader is left with only a scattered introduction to the building blocks of Turkey's identity—be it Islam, Turkish nationalism, economic and social development, alliance with the United States, or convergence with Europe.
The first third of the book briskly outlines the main historical events after the Turks' arrival in Anatolia in the 11th century, consisting mainly of the achievements of the early Ottoman conquerors, the politics of pashas during the Ottoman heyday, and the machinations of the Great Powers during the Ottoman decline. A solid chapter on republican founder Mustafa Kemal Atatürk argues that, far from being an expansionist dictator in the mold of contemporaries such as Mussolini and Hitler, Atatürk was a pragmatist who implemented a genuinely revolutionary program that set the Turks on the road toward their modern democracy. Ahmad shows how this helped Atatürk's republic become the only major Third World country to retain its independence throughout the 20th century.
The strongest section of the book deals with the often neglected years that followed Atatürk's death until the most recent military coup in 1980. Details reveal eternal elements of Turkey's political identity: the early reformers' elitist slogan “For the People, despite the People”; the way Turkish deputies are chosen by party leaders to represent the nation, not by constituencies to further local interests; the people's faith in the ballot box, coupled with their view of elections as an opportunity for taking revenge on the ruling party; the charm and folly of 1950s Prime Minister Adnan Menderes; and the idea that the army executed Menderes after its 1960 coup in an attempt to break the charismatic hold the former prime minister had on the popular imagination.
The last section of the book, about events after 1980, is less convincing. Ahmad relates the many spasms of political turmoil and fiscal crisis but tells little of Turkey's extraordinary progress in other domains. While hearing of continued deprivation among the poor, corruption, and a tragic suicide by one impoverished woman, we hear nothing of the great strides forward by Turkey's major companies, the greening and cleaning of Turkey's big cities, or a media revolution over the past decade that has spawned two dozen national television channels. At a time that just one of several airports on Turkey's southern coast welcomes 250 flights a day bringing in tourists, it seems unfair to dismiss the government's bet on the travel industry as chasing something “fickle” (p. 160).
Such formal discussion of Turkey's identity as there is concentrates on the great change from the Ottoman Empire to the republican nation-state. A well-rehearsed list includes moving the capital from cosmopolitan Istanbul to deep inside Anatolia, the early emancipation of Turkish women, and the change from an autocratic court rooted in Islam to an explicitly secular Parliament and executive working with European-based laws. But this book does not dwell on changes in culture or society. Three sentences deal with the 1928 change from the Arabic to the Latin alphabet, for instance, but no mention is made of the equally traumatic but also invigorating rooting out of Ottoman vocabulary and invention of words to create modern Turkish.
One odd absence in a book that features a mosque on the cover is any sustained treatment of the question of religion. In sentences peppered throughout his narrative, Ahmad notes the milestones of political Islam in Turkey: the abolition of the caliphate in 1924, republican politicians' use of Islam to “pander to popular sentiment,” the transition of Islamist politics from fundamentalism to a kind of “Islamic socialism” (p. 139), and its current incarnation as “responsible” conservatism today. The underlying popular attachment to Islam is never explained, however, nor are the reasons that it remains a powerful force of political mobilization in Turkey. The taboo-breaking idea that Turkey should make its call to prayer in Turkish is recorded, for instance, but without explaining why the Turks should want to make this change or why they changed it back. Typically, nevertheless, Ahmad gives the exact dates that the changes were made (26 June 1941 and 16 June 1950).
Other telling and unusual details are weakened by a lack of context. Few remember Adnan Menderes's proposed loan-hunting trip to Moscow in July 1960, but was this a factor in the May 1960 coup against him? We are told that the second president, Ismet Inonu, was a “clever negotiator” (p. 101), but what were his tricks? If Ankara's political circles were so often in turmoil, how does that account for another key element of the country's identity, the relatively high stability of society and the family? The mostly precise text is not infallible, either. The infamous 1996 accident in Susurluk was caused by a truck, not a tractor, and the European Union's informal membership overture was made to Bülent Ecevit in 1978, not to Süleyman Demirel in 1980.
The book sets out to be an overview, not to advance any particular area of academic or personal enquiry. Without footnotes, it is partly aimed at the general reader. Even so, the succinctness of the narrative makes it dry, and short bibliographies at each chapter's end point only to academic works. Nevertheless, the overall dependability and regularity of the dates in the text, as well as an excellent chronology in an appendix, will make this a useful companion to any who need a quick reference volume for Turkey's modern history.