In Michaelmas Term 1882 a small group of undergraduates at the University of Oxford were encouraged by the Wesleyan superintendent, Hugh Price Hughes, to undertake a mission in the eastern suburb of St Clement's.Footnote 1 Hughes opened a rented mission room in Catherine Street on 18 January 1883, and it became the base for weekly services, a Sunday School, a Band of Hope and a programme of tract distribution. In the face of competition from other evangelistic agencies in the neighbourhood, the Catherine Street Mission proved to be short-lived, closing by the end of the year,Footnote 2 but the student group that had gathered to undertake the project became the nucleus of the Oxford University Wesley Guild, a society which endured under different names into the twenty-first century.Footnote 3 The early history of the guild offers significant insights into Methodist engagement with higher education, illustrating the church's perception of the opportunities and challenges presented by the repeal of the university tests and showing how far hopes and fears about retaining the loyalty of university-educated Methodists were realized in the ultimate destinations of guild members. The extant minutes of the guild, supported by membership lists and term cards, make it possible not only to offer a narrative of the history, but also to analyse the personnel and fluctuations in membership, the evolving purposes of the group, and the strength or otherwise of denominational commitment among Methodist undergraduates at Oxford in the decades leading up to the First World War.
Although the Wesleys’ Methodism began with the Oxford ‘Holy Club’ in the 1720s and 1730s, Methodism in all its varieties was largely excluded from the university by the middle of the eighteenth century, and the Methodist mission in Oxford thereafter focused on the resident population, not the undergraduates. The university tests ensured that Wesleyan and Nonconformist families were unable to send their sons to Oxford; social expectations, too, helped to keep Methodists out. When Benjamin Gregory arrived in the city as the Wesleyan minister in 1857, he found that ‘[w]ith the University the one unpardonable sin was attendance at a Nonconformist church. Dog-fighting, all sorts of loose escapades and low habits might be condoned, but the line must be drawn somewhere, and it was drawn – at the Methodist chapel.’Footnote 4
By the late 1850s, however, the situation was changing, as Oxford's traditional identity as a bastion of the Church of England came under attack from the long-running agitation for the relief of Dissenting disabilities and from pressure for reform from within the university.Footnote 5 Some relaxation of the tests was achieved in 1854, opening the BA degree to Nonconformists, and seventeen years later the Universities Tests Act (1871) enabled them to proceed to higher degrees and fellowships.Footnote 6
The counterpoint to parliamentary and university negotiations over reform was the expansion of Nonconformity, and especially of Wesleyan Methodism, in mid-Victorian England, and the social aspirations which accompanied numerical growth. The Wesleyans were the largest Protestant community outside the Church of England in this period, claiming a membership in excess of 347,000 in 1871; this had risen by almost 50,000 a decade later.Footnote 7 Although the Wesleyans’ core constituency in the latter part of the nineteenth century comprised the households of skilled manual workers, artisans and those engaged in routine non-manual labour, with a leavening of clerks in the urban areas and labourers in the countryside,Footnote 8 there were plenty of Methodists with educational ambitions. Some were members of the Wesleyan lay elite, while others were drawn from an intellectual aristocracy, closely tied to the ministry. Wesley's insistence that the Methodists should be ‘a reading people’Footnote 9 and his persistent efforts to educate his preachers made many Methodists aspire to learn, and kindled a thirst for knowledge, encouraging Methodists to take the opportunities offered by the educational reforms of the era.
Until the mid-1860s, official Wesleyan educational endeavour focused on Sunday Schools and elementary schools. John Scott led the initiative to establish Wesleyan elementary schools from 1843, with an ambitious programme to build 700 schools in seven years.Footnote 10 Although achievement fell short of aspiration, with the assistance of government grants from 1847–8 the Wesleyans were able to reach a total of 743 schools by 1870.Footnote 11 Secondary provision, however, was very sparse. The Connexion maintained subsidized boarding schools at Kingswood and Woodhouse Grove for the sons of ministers, but the only other schools formally linked to the denomination were Wesley College, Sheffield (1838), and the Wesleyan Proprietary Grammar School, Taunton (1843; renamed Queen's College in 1887), each operating under the direction of a private company.Footnote 12 These schools looked to the University of London for the external academic accreditation of matriculation and for bachelors’ degrees, although by 1868 they were also taking advantage of the Oxford Local Examinations and achieving considerable success.Footnote 13 Connexional policy, however, meant that most boys were required to leave Kingswood and Woodhouse Grove at the age of fifteen, which precluded preparation for university admission.
The work of the Schools Inquiry Commission (1864–8) prompted the Wesleyans to re-examine their secondary schools.Footnote 14 The commission's categorization of schools according to leaving age ranked the Wesleyan schools embarrassingly in the ‘third grade’. The Wesleyan leadership was well aware of its own burgeoning middle-class constituency, and was fearful that a lack of Methodist provision might encourage parents to send their children to rival schools, with the inexpensive and determinedly high church Woodard schools being a particular source of concern.Footnote 15 In the wake of the Schools Commission's report, and with university reform on the political agenda from 1868, plans for a comprehensive system of Wesleyan schools, reaching from the elementary level to admission to Oxford and Cambridge, were developed by Henry French, mathematics master at Taunton. French set out his plans in a series of letters to the heavyweight Wesleyan weekly newspaper, the Watchman.Footnote 16 Henry Hartley Fowler, rising to prominence in the denomination and in the Liberal party, persuaded the connexion to institute its own schools inquiry in 1871.Footnote 17 Meanwhile, Richard Bell, superintendent minister in Oxford, made an appeal for support for a major extension of Wesleyan work in the city, urging ‘the commanding claims of the educational centres of this country’ on connexional funds.Footnote 18
The flurry of letters and reports in the late 1860s and early 1870s resulted in piecemeal changes. French's comprehensive system was not adopted, although Wesleyan districts were encouraged to set up new ‘middle-class’ schools. Kingswood and Woodhouse Grove were amalgamated in 1875, forming one institution with two centres, and by concentrating the older pupils at Kingswood a stronger upper school was created. A new ‘first grade’ school, The Leys, was opened in Cambridge in 1875. As significant as these developments, perhaps, was the role of particular headmasters in encouraging applications to Oxford and Cambridge: Thomas Sibly at Taunton,Footnote 19 T. G. Osborn at KingswoodFootnote 20 and W. F. Moulton at The Leys.Footnote 21
The universities of Oxford and Cambridge, however, remained a cause of concern to Wesleyans. William Arthur, past president of the Wesleyan Conference, warned in July 1870 that ‘whilst many members of the Wesleyan Methodist Society had gone into Oxford, they had not in any part of the kingdom a member of the Methodist Society who had come out of Oxford’.Footnote 22 Henry Young, superintendent when Alfred Gregory arrived to begin his studies at Brasenose, recalled that ‘there were a few sons of Methodists in various colleges’, but ‘there was no undergraduate attending our chapel’.Footnote 23 One response to this was to conclude that Wesleyans should avoid the university at all costs. Samuel Romilly Hall, delivering the ex-president's charge to newly ordained Wesleyan ministers in 1869, warned them not to jeopardize their children's spiritual welfare for the sake of worldly advancement, and not to send their sons to Oxford or Cambridge.Footnote 24 George Lidgett, responsible for the education of his orphaned nephew, John Scott Lidgett, denied him the opportunity of going to Oxford or Cambridge as his father had intended, and sent him to University College, London, instead. Scott Lidgett reminisced that his uncle thought the older universities were ‘not likely to strengthen, and perhaps likely to undermine, my Methodist convictions and sympathies’.Footnote 25 However, Lidgett's frustration and annoyance at this decision demonstrated that a policy of avoidance would not work, and that Wesleyans needed to make provision for undergraduates at Oxford and Cambridge. This encouraged the construction of new and fashionably Gothic chapels in Hills Road, Cambridge (1870–1) and New Inn Hall Street, Oxford (1877–8), and pressure on the Stationing Committee to appoint suitably qualified ministers to appeal to cultured students.Footnote 26 Cambridge led the way in instituting a regular gathering ‘of a social character’ for undergraduates in 1873, and, with W. F. Moulton's support, this evolved into the Wesley Society.Footnote 27
The traditional method of Wesleyan pastoral care and spiritual nurture was the weekly class meeting, where members gathered to share Christian experience, insight and admonition. Alfred Gregory persuaded two other Methodist undergraduates to form a designated university class in Oxford, and this met during term-time, under the guidance of the superintendent.Footnote 28 The class was a very small group, with membership in single figures through the 1870s,Footnote 29 but it was from the university class, in the winter of 1882, that the idea of a new venture emerged.
As originally conceived, the Wesley Union or Wesley Guild was designed to be ecumenical in membership and evangelistic in focus. In this way it complemented both the university class, which was already meeting the spiritual needs of committed Wesleyans, and the recently-formed Nonconformist Union, which offered a social and intellectual programme to ‘remove the feeling of isolation which Nonconformists experience on entering the University’.Footnote 30 Membership of the guild was not confined to members of the Wesleyan Society: it was open to ‘any member of the University being a regular communicant of some Christian Church’,Footnote 31 and the principal objective of the group was to run the Catherine St Mission. Most of the early meetings were concerned with the practical organization of the mission: devising a preaching plan for the Sunday and midweek services, furnishing the mission room, providing refreshments and raising funds. Several visiting speakers came to address the guild, and most offered guidance on Christian life and witness, although in May 1883 W. H. Dallinger, Methodism's leading scientist, spoke on science and religion.Footnote 32 With the demise of the mission towards the end of 1883, the guild needed a new purpose. Price Hughes suggested ‘some definite work’ in another part of Oxford, perhaps running a Sunday School at New Hinksey, where the circuit had opened a new chapel in July 1882,Footnote 33 but the option of ‘meeting for social purposes, for hearing papers read &c’ was also tabled.Footnote 34 With Hughes's departure from Oxford in the summer of 1884, the guild soon abandoned the challenge of ‘definite work’ and settled into a rhythm of two or three meetings a term, gathering in members’ rooms to read papers, debate issues or listen to invited speakers. Meetings were structured around ‘private business’ – amending and approving minutes, admitting new members, electing officers, changing the rules of debate – and the ‘public business’ of papers and discussions. The rules specified that the host could spend up to 7s. 6d. entertaining the guild, but that the cost of providing tobacco could not be claimed as an expense.Footnote 35
The guild's programme included some high-profile speakers: presidents and past presidents of the conference such as E. E. Jenkins, Frederic Greeves, Robert Newton Young and T. B. Stephenson;Footnote 36 Wesleyan theological college tutors such as F. W. Macdonald, W. T. Davison and J. A. Beet;Footnote 37 and (occasionally) prominent lay Methodists such as S. D. Waddy, QC, MP.Footnote 38 Some came to Oxford to preach on Sunday at the New Inn Hall Street chapel, and met the guild on the preceding Saturday evening: Charles Garrett, ex-president, was due in October 1883, but arrived late after a ‘tedious’ train journey, and sent apologies; Hughes improvised an address on ‘the state of the lower classes and the great need of social reform’.Footnote 39 Hughes returned to Oxford in January 1891, ‘asserting his right to be honoured as the founder of the Guild’Footnote 40 and came back in subsequent years. There were non-Wesleyan speakers too. In March 1890 Canon Fremantle spoke on ‘bringing Christ into all our daily works and pursuits’,Footnote 41 while A. M. Fairbairn, principal of Mansfield College, was a regular speaker at, and host of, guild meetings, and an early vice-president. Recurring themes for speakers were apologetics, particularly approaches to biblical criticism;Footnote 42 consistent Christian living at and after university; and fidelity to Methodism, suggesting that invited speakers were perhaps unaware of the ‘unsectarian’ strand in the guild's rules, and thought that their brief was to strengthen denominational loyalties.
The suggestion that guild members might read papers was canvassed as early as November 1883, but the first undergraduate to address the guild seems to have been E. E. Kellett, who spoke on ‘Robertson of Brighton’ in December 1885.Footnote 43 Thereafter members addressed a range of subjects, religious, ethical, literary, philosophical and occasionally political. Kellett discussed ‘Tennyson's Vision of Sin’ in February 1887;Footnote 44 T. C. Piggott, whose father was the senior Wesleyan missionary in Rome, spoke on ‘The Liberation of Italy’ some months later;Footnote 45 A. E. Taylor, honing his skills as a critical thinker, offered ‘An Apology for Wesleyanism’ in November 1894, prompting the superintendent, Enoch Salt, to hail it as the most remarkable paper he had ever heard.Footnote 46 In June 1898, F. E. Corley's paper on ‘Christianity and Social Problems’, supported by references to Ruskin's Unto this Last and Edward Bellamy's Looking Backward, provoked members to disagree with ‘some of his seemingly strongly Socialist contentions’.Footnote 47 Serious papers were leavened with debates in which members took sides at random: thus the guild voted to ‘approve the aims and tendencies of the new journalism’ and agreed ‘that the present position of the Socialist leaders is indefensible’ but rejected a motion that ‘the tone of modern Oxford is deplorable’, declaring: ‘We are young men … we need athletics.’Footnote 48
The legacy of the Catherine Street Mission lived on in the guild's connections with the development of the Wesleyan Settlement in Bermondsey. The guild had begun in the era of concern for ‘outcast London’, and in November 1883 Samuel Barnett, vicar of St Jude's, Whitechapel, came to address a meeting at St John's College on ‘Settlements of University Men in Great Towns’.Footnote 49 One outcome of Barnett's initiative was Toynbee Hall, established in 1884, and this was the model for the Wesleyan Settlement created in Bermondsey by Scott Lidgett. Sanctioned by the Wesleyan Conference in 1889 and opened in 1892, the Bermondsey Settlement followed Barnett's example of placing university and professional men alongside a large working-class population, seeking to strengthen understanding across classes, to offer opportunities for education and to address social ills.Footnote 50 Lidgett came to Oxford in February 1889, accompanied by J. H. Moulton and W. P. Workman, both on the staff of The Leys School, and Percy Bunting, barrister and editor. The deputation shared the vision of the settlement, and the guild carried unanimously a resolution welcoming the scheme.Footnote 51 Thereafter the guild was represented on the committee of the settlement, and Lidgett visited Oxford regularly to report on progress. Several members of the guild moved to Bermondsey after graduation, including W. F. LofthouseFootnote 52 and J. B. Eames, who returned to describe to the guild in June 1897 how he was running a class for the study of literature, observing cheerfully that ‘it appeared that even if the class failed to fully understand Browning, they at all events were not without a lively affection for him’.Footnote 53 Guild members were encouraged to visit the settlement; two years later the guild agreed to host a Whit Monday excursion to Oxford from Bermondsey, and to provide guides and tea.Footnote 54
It has already been seen that the guild began with a commitment to be ‘unsectarian’. F. W. Macdonald, addressing the founding meeting in February 1883, endorsed the choice of the name ‘Wesley Union’ on the grounds that ‘the name had nothing unworthy or sectarian about it, but was in perfect harmony with the spirit of the age’. The first members included one Anglican (R. T. Talbot of Exeter) and two non-Wesleyan Methodists, W. P. Orme of Lincoln and H. W. Horwill of Wadham, sons respectively of New Connexion and Bible Christian ministers.Footnote 55 Hughes quickly recruited the Congregationalist Joseph King (Trinity), secretary of the Nonconformist Union, onto the guild's committee, and brought R. F. Horton, founder of the union and fellow of New College, to lead a discussion on ‘Mission Work in Oxford’.Footnote 56 Several of the guild's founding members were already active in the Nonconformist Union, and the union's rules made provision for denominational representation on its committee.Footnote 57 The change from running the Catherine Street Mission to meeting for papers and discussion brought the programmes of the two societies into close resemblance. In the early part of 1884 it was suggested that ‘closer contact’ with the Nonconformist Union would be desirable, and a guild meeting adjourned early so that members could attend a gathering of the union.Footnote 58 The two groups maintained a separate existence, however, with the guild becoming more definitely Methodist and the union more Congregationalist. In 1898 the guild's rules were revised, striking out the ‘unsectarian’ clause and replacing it with a new Rule 2: ‘That any Member of the University, being also a Member or adherent of any Methodist Church, be eligible for membership’.Footnote 59 Hints in the minutes suggest that the mid-1890s were difficult years for the guild, and that a new start came with the arrival of W. J. Hutton as superintendent in 1896. It is possible that the stronger Methodist emphasis in the rules was part of Hutton's attempt to reinvigorate the guild after a period of ‘drift’.
The guild did not keep consistent records of membership or attendance, particularly in the early years, and membership lists in the minute books were annotated working documents, marking admissions, resignations and changes of residence as they occurred rather than tabulating statistics. Those who stayed on in Oxford after graduation retained membership, but were not clearly distinguished from undergraduates until a category of ‘Life Members in Residence’ was created; similarly, local ministers were included in the lists until separately designated as ‘Honorary Members’. It is possible, however, to take soundings across the years between 1883 and 1914 and to assess the size, strength and composition of the guild. Membership tripled in the first decade, from an initial sixteen in 1883 to forty-eight in Michaelmas Term 1892. Thereafter a steep decline set in, so that in Hilary Term 1898 there were just sixteen members again. Numbers recovered slowly: there were twenty-five undergraduate members in the autumn of 1900, twenty-nine in 1904 and thirty-seven in 1905, and up to the First World War undergraduate membership remained in the thirties, with typically ten new members elected each Michaelmas Term to replace the leavers of the previous summer. There was a wide representation from the colleges, unsurprisingly with clusters at particular times: Balliol, Merton, Christ Church, Jesus, Wadham and Corpus Christi were consistently well represented, and the guild also attracted non-collegiate students, who comprised a significant and distinctive element of the university's population.Footnote 60 Taking Michaelmas Term 1891 as an example,Footnote 61 the guild claimed thirty-three undergraduate members, drawn from eleven colleges and with five non-collegiate students. Seven had matriculated from Kingswood School, five from Taunton and three from Rydal School, Colwyn Bay – all Wesleyan institutions – but there were also representatives of St Paul's School, Manchester Grammar School, the City of London School, Dulwich College and several other provincial grammar schools, as well as two from the Wesleyan School, Oxford, the brothers Albert and Gilbert Richardson, sons of the local Wesleyan schoolmaster.
Attendance at guild meetings rarely exceeded twenty, and for a long period through the 1890s it was regularly in single figures. High-profile speakers sometimes attracted better audiences, including visitors and guests: among the best-attended gatherings of the period were Price Hughes's ‘earnest address urging on the aristocracy of learning a deep and real sympathy with the poor and helpless’ in June 1894 and W. T. Davison's careful summary of recent developments in biblical criticism in November 1899.Footnote 62 Conversely, attendance in May 1892, when Revd Nehemiah Curnock spoke about religious journalism, was ‘scanty’, due to the proximity of Eights Week, while the meeting on 19 May 1900 was abandoned due to the imminent celebration of the relief of Mafeking.Footnote 63 When W. F. Moulton queried the programme of two or three meetings a term, urging the advantages of the Cambridge pattern of a weekly gathering, A. E. Taylor replied that Oxford undergraduates were too busy with ‘hard reading’ for additional activities.Footnote 64
It remains to be asked whether the Wesley Guild fulfilled the hopes of its founders and promoters. Hugh Price Hughes's initial scheme to recruit an interdenominational group of students to staff a mission room in the expanding working-class suburbs of East Oxford soon petered out, but commitment to a broadly based approach to evangelism and social concern endured, both in the guild's long-term support for the Bermondsey Settlement and in the subsequent careers of guild members such as W. F. Lofthouse, a founder member of the Wesleyan Methodist Union for Social Service,Footnote 65 and E. E. Genner, who represented the university on the Oxford Board of Guardians for more than twenty years.Footnote 66 A much more general statement of purpose – that the guild ‘has been formed to afford Members of the University an opportunity of mutual intercourse’Footnote 67 – was certainly fulfilled by the meetings, but did the guild succeed in sustaining the denominational identity and loyalty of Methodist undergraduates in the face of competition from other churches and world-views?
Looking first at the sixteen founding members, R. T. Talbot came from an Anglican background and became an Anglican priest. Six of the others, all from Methodist backgrounds, took Anglican orders, some entering parish ministry and others pursuing careers in education.Footnote 68 Five definitely remained in Methodism: J. J. Findlay, headmaster first of Queen's College, Taunton, and subsequently of Wesley College, Sheffield, and then professor of education at Manchester;Footnote 69 H. W. Horwill, who followed his father into the Bible Christian ministry and then became a journalist;Footnote 70 E. E. Kellett, schoolmaster at The Leys;Footnote 71 A. F. Kerry, who stayed in Oxford as organist at New Inn Hall Street and headmaster of the City Technical School; and Sidney Vanes, who was an active lay Methodist and schoolmaster in Adelaide until his death in 1901.Footnote 72 Others went on to careers in the home civil service,Footnote 73 in IndiaFootnote 74 or in politics,Footnote 75 but their later religious allegiance is unclear.
This pattern persisted. Some guild members entered the Wesleyan ministry, including W. F. Lofthouse, J. H. Ritson and R. N. Flew, all later presidents of the conference, and A. J. Costain, headmaster of Rydal Mount School. Others were active as lay Methodists, like F. E. Corley, who taught at the Madras Christian College from 1906–36,Footnote 76 and E. E. Genner, fellow of Jesus College, Oxford, and then of Oriel. A. S. Peake, of Primitive Methodist stock, was a member of the guild before leaving Oxford in 1892 for his life's work of training ministers at Hartley College, Manchester, where he did much to establish the university's faculty of theology. Others joined the Church of England, such as A. E. Taylor, philosopher and Gifford Lecturer,Footnote 77 and A. E. Hillard, later high master of St Paul's,Footnote 78 or moved away from denominational loyalties and faith commitments altogether, like W. P. Crozier, later editor of the Manchester Guardian.Footnote 79
Although each biography has its own unique blend of influences and experiences, the haemorrhage of Oxford-educated young men from Methodism in this period is striking. The jeremiads of the 1870s had warned that Oxford and Cambridge were unconducive to the maintenance of Methodist loyalties, and the history of the Wesley Guild seems to show that these fears were not unfounded. Methodist and free church students remained a minority in the university, and although there was no coercion, social and cultural pressures to comply with an Anglican norm were very present. Graduates seeking careers in education had limited opportunities in Methodist schools: a significant number of those who entered Anglican orders became schoolmasters. Although by the end of the nineteenth century the Wesleyans had many imposing city centre and suburban chapels, with affluent middle-class congregations, most Wesleyans still worshipped in small chapels or places with a working-class majority. There were serious scholars in the Wesleyan ministry, but only a small number of graduates, and swathes of the connexion remained suspicious of academic expertise. A combination of personal circumstances, career opportunities and cultural affinities may help to explain the departure of Wesley Guild members from Methodism.
In November 1899 W. F. Lofthouse, by now tutor at the Wesleyans’ Handsworth College, returned to the guild to open a debate on the topic ‘Wesley College, Oxford’. Plans for a Methodist college in Oxford were under discussion, its advocates hoping perhaps to emulate the Congregationalists’ Mansfield. Lofthouse was sceptical, reflecting that many of ‘our men’ in the theological colleges ‘have not much education’, and that it would not work to bring them ‘straight from the plough or desk to Oxford’. Furthermore, ‘the chief need of our ministers was not academic culture’. William Bradfield, the superintendent, strongly disagreed, declaring that ‘we owe it to the world to rear scholars’.Footnote 80 These tensions and realities were played out in the early history of the Wesley Guild, illustrating the social and academic aspirations of Methodism in the late nineteenth century, and also its fears of cultural assimilation and denominational extinction in a milieu dominated by other traditions and values. Despite its beginnings in ecumenical cooperation and evangelism, the guild soon became a safe and supportive community for a small group of Methodist undergraduates. Exposed to the challenges and opportunities of an Oxford education, some were able to combine professional success and Methodist loyalty, while others found different paths as their careers unfolded. Access to Oxford and Cambridge certainly brought the advantages and status long denied to Nonconformists, but, in spite of the best efforts of groups like the Wesley Guild, sustaining Methodist identity in the university and thereafter proved a very tall order.
