There has been a piece missing from the puzzle of modern African American literary history for some time now. We have known that the piece fits in what Daniel Widener in 2010 called the “critical interregnum between the Harlem Renaissance and the 1960s.” But we have known far less about the shape of this piece, or indeed whether it is a single piece or multiple ones that should organize the years between the 1930s and the early 1960s. Many have given up caring, a fondness for biographies having replaced that for broad syntheses. And the game of coining periodizing terms has been shoved into a scholarly sideboard. “Individual black writers did so well, especially between 1940 and 1953, that the idea of the artists operating as a cohort has been obscured” (3), Lawrence P. Jackson explains at the start of his important new work. Fortunately Jackson still wants to play the old game, inspired by his belief that he has found the piece that completes our puzzle (actually three pieces, which is a problem). He calls it the indignant generation, and spends some five hundred pages reminding us what fun we can have in these pursuits.
The Indignant Generation refers to that group of writers and critics who “flat-out rejected the modes and attitudes of racial accommodation, especially in their scholarship” (19). But the term is not entirely successful, in part because of its insistent singularity. For this work turns on the existence of, if not three generations, then at least three interconnected groups, with Jackson's argument implicitly organized into three related blocks that span roughly 1934 to 1940, 1938 to 1953, and 1953 to 1960. Only the strategic placement of the work's excellent photographs reminds us where, in this dense study, these crucial organizational fault lines lie. Still, the decision about where to draw those lines is most definitely Jackson's, and stems from the type of intellectual history he wishes to write.
A series of contentions about the history of American literary criticism guide Jackson's explanations about the shifting political and intellectual outlook of the black artists he discusses. The rise and spread of John Crowe Ransom's techniques of new criticism, which helped to establish high modernist principles, and to overturn social-realist ones, sits beneath Jackson's argument that racial liberalism became dominant in literature and the social sciences in the 1940s and early 1950s, for example. The gritty realist accounts of black life that Richard Wright fictionalized, and that the social scientists Horace Cayton and St. Clair Drake documented, were gradually displaced by the symbolism of Ralph Ellison's short stories, overturned by James Baldwin's polemics against the protest tradition, and obscured by Gunnar Myrdal's characterization of race relations as a “moral dilemma.”
Jackson is keen that we recognize the correspondence between these literary shifts and the direction of and possibility for political discourse. He spends a great deal of time showing us that this was a moment when aesthetic discourse was understood by many as providing an unrivalled source of knowledge. Yet instead of Lionel Trilling making this familiar point, the poet Sterling Brown tells us that Wright's Native Son (1940) was discussed in “grills and ‘juke joints’ as well as at ‘literary’ parties” (120), and the sociologist Cayton extols the “raw emotional appeal” of Lillian Smith's work (188). While the emotive charge of Smith's novel Strange Fruit (1944) led it to be banned in Boston, the lives of many black writers were affected far more profoundly because of what they wrote on the page. When the NYU-trained critic Hugh Gloster journeyed through Mississippi, Jackson describes how “even literary criticism brought on potentially hazardous complications” (151).
Gloster is just one of a number of black critics whose life and work The Indignant Generation uncovers, which it establishes as important elements in the mid-century American literary landscape. “It took good criticism to elevate the aesthetic standards sufficiently to produce enduring literary work” (277), Jackson writes of the work of men (and with the odd exception, these critics were men) like Eugene Gordon, Eugene Clay Holmes, Ulysses Lee, Nick Aaron Ford, Arthur P. Davis, and Louis Burnham. Their criticism, commentary, and editorial work was evident in the countless periodicals that were established in this period, many of whose covers are gloriously reprinted here, and whose contents carried the political values of new criticism from the seminar rooms of Vanderbilt into the nation's intellectual bloodstream.
Each of the three aesthetic regimes described by Jackson had a corresponding raft of journals: New Masses and Dorothy West's New Challenge served the social realists; Partisan Review, South Today, Common Ground, and Harlem Quarterly for the high modernists; Présence Africaine for some of the growing chorus of disaffected cultural nationalists of the mid- and late 1950s. In discussing these periodicals in such detail, Jackson extends in interesting ways that line of interpretation that demonstrated the function of journals in nurturing black writing in the 1920s. But this focus also reminds us that at a time when black intellectuals were not as closely associated with the university as they would become in the 1960s, journals provided an apprenticeship of sorts. Occasionally, such publications also drew writers into common endeavour, as happened with the Harlem Writers Club and the ventures it spawned. But this was not common.
Deciding in what sense Jackson's indignant generation is a generation at all will prove crucial in determining whether this term is used to organize modern African American literature. Those who like robust demographic definitions will probably wish to clarify further who is encompassed by the term. There were ten years between Ralph Ellison and James Baldwin, and more than twenty years between Horace Cayton and Baldwin, and not much evidence that any of these men sought a collective appellation. Similarly, adherents to strict aesthetic principles will also harbour reservations. The modernist emphasis on individuality and alienation hardly sounds like the stuff of group cohesion, and even Jackson has to admit that writers like Chester Himes possessed a “keen sense of individuality” (277). None of the works published in these decades carried a dedication like that which Alain Locke inscribed in The New Negro: An Interpretation (1925): “To the younger generation.” The work is much better on period.
Starting in 1934 and finishing in 1960, The Indignant Generation broadly traces the contours of the career of Richard Wright, who, Jackson insists, was the period's “dominant figure” (9). But there are other reasons for the precision of his periodization: 1934 marked the year of the Julius Rosenwald Fund's decision to funnel its largesse to black artists, a practice it continued until its funds were exhausted in 1948. It was these institutional transformations – in patronage, in publishing, in pedagogy, and so forth – that fundamentally governed both the possibilities for and the politics of production for many black writers. When “the relationship between sponsor and client … unravel[ed]” in the late 1950s it helped to create the conditions for a different, more global, alignment of black writers (483).
Jackson's formulation of the indignant generation is a prodigious contribution to African American literary history. Even if there is much work to be done before all the dust and dog hairs are removed from it, and its lineaments can be seen with clarity, its pegs fit snugly within our existing puzzle.
