The Second World War created a rubber bottleneck. Japanese invasions across Southeast Asia foreclosed well-trod pathways to a material that had become ‘strategic’—desired for its elastic and impermeable qualities in wartime industrialisation. Governments called on civilians to ration and salvage rubber and piloted research in synthetic substitutes. Yet the trees bearing latex in Vietnam were not only important in this moment of global crisis, as Michitake Aso makes clear in his formidable new book Rubber and the making of Vietnam. Rubber trees were also central to colonial, capitalist, and nation-building strategies that linked Vietnam and the wider world: from the Nguyen dynasty to French colonial rule, from anticolonial independence to infighting between capitalist and communist Vietnamese parties, and from Vietnamese victory in the American War to participation in the neoliberal international order. Drawing upon archives across North America, Europe, and Southeast Asia, and myriad written and oral testimonies in English, French, and Vietnamese, Aso reveals the importance of rubber trees across the long twentieth century, highlighting surprising continuities over time in the ‘entanglement of science, commerce, and governance on Southeast Asian plantations’ (p. 3).
Using the rubber plantation as a bridge across the ambitious periodisation of the book, from early colonial forays to contemporary multinational operations, Aso enacts an impressive multi-scalar, multi-perspectival analysis. The author switches resolution from the wide-angle to the granular view, linking international relations and political economic agendas to the local plantations in the red and gray soils of Vietnam and Cambodia. The balancing act succeeds through a focus on different mediators—for instance, scientists working on agriculture or medicine, or a long list of politicians, plantation elites, international rubber producers, extension agents, workers, poets, and other human actors. One such mediator is Alexandre Yersin, a Swiss medical researcher with a passion for agricultural experimentation. Celebrated for founding the Pasteur Institute in coastal Nha Trang, Yersin also draws just scrutiny in the pages of this book for his part, like his mentor Louis Pasteur, in actively aiding the French colonial project through the creation of laboratories of and for empire. Yersin's research led to the widespread cultivation of Hevea brasiliensis, a species of rubber tree taken from the Amazon region to Vietnam.
Aso's dynamic approach to scale and perspective enables a rich account of the many individuals who shaped and were shaped by nonhuman nature. On the one hand, the reader sees much evidence of top-down government planning in colonial and postcolonial contexts calling forth roadbuilding, monoculture planting, and clean weeding, as well as the international machinations of rubber producers who selectively exchanged knowledge to combat plant diseases. On the other hand, the reader also follows the tappers on the ground, as they interact with the more-than-human world while making their skilful incisions into the bark of hundreds of trees amid rain, dense vegetation, and heat. Readers discern constant pushback from impoverished or sickened workers and critical journalists disillusioned with the ills of the rubber plantation economy. There is also evidence of tactical exchanges across the hierarchy, as the French colonial state's technique of ‘encadrement’, or shaping landscapes to meet different goals, became a technique useful to those revolutionaries fighting the French in the First Indochina War. Such contingency was evident as well in the American War, as the NLF, RVN, and US government vied for control over plantation workers and landscapes. As Aso summarises, revolutionaries ‘made history, but not on the landscapes of their own choosing’ (p. 171).
Beyond centring the rubber tree in Southeast Asian history, Aso also advances debates across fields of environmental history, the history of science, agricultural history, and global commodity histories. This includes the agency of nonhuman nature in shaping human artifice, from political institutions to scientific and capitalist ones; the transformative effects of the materiality of rubber for human actors situated across a wide social field; and the generation and circulation of ideas about nonhuman nature in imperialism, development, and other projects. The latter aim is perhaps the most fully realised throughout this richly detailed book. Aso highlights how ideas about nature revealed scientists’ racial prejudices that prevented them from recognising material realities. A collaborator of Yersin's insisted on an arbitrary latitudinal limit to the rubber tree's growth at 15 degrees, a political rather than geographic distinction framed as neutral empiricism. The bending of environmental ideas to serve different agendas was similarly evident as rubber producers in the 1930s framed malaria outbreaks as unexpected ‘epidemics’ rather than the predictable product of a plantation complex that, through deforestation, produced stagnant, unshaded water that served as breeding grounds for the plasmodium-bearing Anopheles minimus mosquito. In response, after the Second World War, anticolonial Viet Minh fighters tightened ground-level associations between rubber trees and vicious colonial oppression through their anti-imperialist campaigns, at times destroying latex-bearing trees, before turning the cultivation of rubber trees into a foundation of the socialist project.
Aso also shows how material landscapes conditioned different possibilities, evident in the challenges and unintended uses of the plantation complex. Official planning rarely flowed without friction caused by carbon and nitrogen-phosphorous-potassium cycles, the tropical climate, or plant diseases. Vernacular adaptations to those environments, moreover, provided space for resistance, as Vietnamese workers foraged or, later, during the defoliation campaigns of the American War, gardened on the plantation's edges to nourish their bodies. While there is, at times, an overwhelming density to the webs of connection Aso traces—historically and historiographically—the work retains focus and marshals incredible insights. Especially exciting for this reader was the notion that commodities like rubber, far from being reducible to some chemical fact, geopolitical interest, or abstract exchange value, have been ‘defined by the ways and locations in which it has been produced, along with the people who have produced and consumed it’ (p. 4). Raw materials, rubber tree plantations included, have been imaginative and material clay sustaining colonisation and decolonisation, and numerous other projects across scales. We would do well to approach them with the dynamism and elasticity that Aso brings to this analysis.
