West Nile in north-western Uganda, bordering Sudan and Congo, is a frontier in many senses: once the territory of Emin Pasha, eventually a colonial backwater with a closed status, and a reserve of labour and imagined warrior tribes suitable for recruitment to the colonial forces. Even C. G. Jung writes about his visit to West Nile in his memoirs. It was also the origin of the Yakan spiritual movement. And, of course, West Nile was the home of the late Idi Amin, and the place where anthropologist giants John Middleton and Aidan Southall worked.
All these themes are brought up in Inside West Nile, Leopold's anthropological account based on fieldwork mainly in Aura town, combined with extensive literature and archival studies. It is a nicely tuned book which digs into the history as it progresses. The usual and often boring chronology is turned upside down in the effort to present and criticise ‘images’ of history, and indeed, I like the effort. So, besides travelling into the past of West Nile – from the present into the past to end up with the present again – Leopold outlines the debate between Southall and Ali Mazrui, their effort to understand the character of Amin from an Africanist perspective. Here he brings up the kind of pseudo-anthropology (Leopold calls it a racist anthropology) that mapped out Amin and his violent rule against the framework of his cultural background. ‘Masculinity, violence, sexuality’, Leopold notes, ‘all linked to an atavistic racial primitivism’ (p. 61).
Leopold moreover outlines and examines Middleton's work at length. But as the main theme, perhaps, Leopold discusses the ‘curse’ of history that so many West Nilers themselves seem to contemplate. He notes that ‘the peoples of the Uganda/Sudan border areas become seen as the epitome of ‘primitiveness’ (p. 9). In critically assessing this curse, Leopold sets off with a contemporary document produced by some local amateur historians, a kind of inside account of the region's violent history. And he revisits and reinterprets the colonial and early anthropological historiography of the Yakan (or ‘Allah Water’) spiritual uprising (or rebellion); and is able to show that the uprising aspect of the revitalising movement was more of a colonial imagination than a reality on the ground which threatened colonial authority.
Leopold did his fieldwork during a difficult moment in the region's history. Rebel activities in the rural surroundings made him decide to restrict his fieldwork to Arua town, something that he discusses in the beginning of the book. Somehow an irony of the situation, but also a self-reflection I guess, he has a chapter called ‘Arua means prison’. Leopold's honesty must be praised, and indeed, anthropologists have to adjust their fieldwork all the time according to the realities on the ground. We do reflect on these issues, only that most of us just neglect to share our reflections with the readers. Here Leopold adds another important account to the growing bulk of ethnographies of war and violence. I have struggled with similar thoughts during my fieldwork engagements in neighbouring Acholiland, also torn by war. So when Leopold at the beginning of his book tells the story of a Canadian researcher ‘who had been shot dead in mysterious circumstances two years earlier’ (p. 4), I can only add that the same story circulated in Acholi, with the vague indication, as I guess was the case also with Leopold, that I was next. By necessity we have to reflect and deal with these rumours in the field, and it indeed enriches the ethnography when such stories are incorporated to the written account.
