Eric T. Kasper and Troy A. Kozma worry that The Prince is misunderstood by contemporary audiences who approach the work with prejudice and are not enlightened once they read it because they are unfamiliar with the historical examples Machiavelli uses to illustrate his maxims. In Machiavelli Goes to the Movies, Kasper and Kozma endeavor a “retelling, re-explaining, and in some respects a reimagining” of The Prince for contemporary audiences using characters from popular culture (22). In this ambitious book, Cesare Borgia, Pope Julius II, Agathocles, and Cyrus are replaced by Michael Corleone, Walter White, Charlie Wilson, and Frank Underwood.
Kaspar and Kozma situate their work in the growing vein of literature seeking to redeem The Prince; like other scholars, they emphasize the final chapter, where Machiavelli's shocking lessons are presented as the necessary steps to achieve the noble goal of liberating the Italian people from their oppressors. Kaspar and Kozma distill the overall theme of The Prince to the familiar adage, “the end justifies the means,” which they admit is a loose translation of Machiavelli's actual words in chapter 18 (7). While the authors concede that The Prince does encourage ruthless elimination of one's opponents using violence, cruelty, and deceit, they remind the reader that Machiavelli is critical of many of the historical figures in his vignettes, highlighting their failures and qualifying their successes. Kasper and Kozma attribute these failures to a collective inattention to the greater good, a fault shared by many of their pop culture protagonists, whose ends are either self-interested or woefully misguided. Thus, in both this retelling and the original, the antiheroes use “Machiavellian tactics” or means, but they are often imperfect embodiments of Machiavelli's intended message about ends in The Prince.
The book is divided into twenty-two substantive chapters, which, with a few exceptions, follow the chronological order and topical content of the twenty-six chapters in The Prince. Each chapter is structured to mirror the style of The Prince, opening with a brief statement of the lesson and then offering illustrative examples. In this book, the lessons are synopses of key passages from The Prince, including relevant quotes and occasional footnoted annotations to scholarly commentary in support of the provided interpretation. Each chapter consists of two to four examples from film and television, all with a principal character in a position of power, many of which are political and a number involving organized crime. Just as Machiavelli uses characters such as Alexander the Great to illustrate multiple lessons, some of the films and shows appear in several chapters. The Godfather's Don Vito and Michael Corleone take the place of Machiavelli's all-star father and son duo, Pope Alexander VI and Cesare Borgia, and similarly exemplify how to annihilate the opposition when rising to power and how to effectively use deception and religion to advance one's goals. Breaking Bad's Walter White models both the fox and the lion, combining force and fraud as he eliminates his enemies and navigates the dangerous drug-trafficking underworld. Frank Underwood kills and climbs his way to the White House in House of Cards, demonstrating how traditional virtues can be vices when you are trying to solidify authority and showcasing the appropriate use of favors to keep advisors loyal once you have attained power. The title character in Charlie Wilson's War is one the authors look to frequently, exemplifying how the best leaders acquire extensive knowledge of history, have access to their own arms, and possess the ability to foresee and mitigate future crises. Other protagonists such as Mad Men's Don Draper make only one appearance, but the description of how Draper overcomes his humble beginnings to rise to the top of his firm through fortune and virtue is relayed so compellingly that the reader is left with the impression that this character likely would have fit in any number of the chapters.
Readers who have studied The Prince closely will find some of the examples less convincing substitutes for the originals. In several key chapters, the character sketches are an uneven mix of weak and strong narratives and underdeveloped characters. For example, in Chapter 16, scenes from The Godfather, Primary Colors, The Walking Dead, and Bob Roberts are used to depict Machiavelli's lessons about deception found in Chapter 18 of The Prince. Michael Corleone's use of religion to garner respect and authority and Jack Stanton's creative storytelling in order to boost his popular appeal are persuasive depictions of the need to appear to be something one is not and to be circumspect when doing so. Indeed, Corleone is the example par excellence, since Machiavelli stresses above all the need to appear to be religious. In contrast, the governor from The Walking Dead and the title character in Bob Roberts are so brazen that their ill-conceived plots predictably unravel, making theirs an example of deception simply, but not the kind that Machiavelli advises. It is puzzling that for one of the pivotal chapters in the book, the authors turned to these protagonists who are arguably not true to the heart of the lesson when a more thorough explanation of the integral and better fitting examples from The Godfather and Primary Colors would have sufficed, or other fantastic examples at their disposal could have been used, including the underutilized Frank Underwood and the entirely absent pop-culture juggernaut, Game of Thrones. Chapters such as this leave the reader feeling that the narrative is at times too closely tethered to and driven by the structural formula that attempts to mimic the source text, and that the authors' admirable attempt to supply a multitude of examples has the unintended consequence of distracting from those characters who are outstanding incarnations of Machiavelli's philosophy.
Another challenge resulting from the attempt to tie together very diverse films and shows is that Machiavelli's lessons are sometimes reduced to the least common denominator, and the nuance and genius of the original are lost in translation. For instance, Kasper and Kozma's chapter 18 is drawn from chapter 19 of The Prince, which deals with ways to avoid contempt and hatred. While the authors capture well Machiavelli's probing assessment of human nature and the danger of avoiding alliances in favor of neutrality in the introduction to the chapter, in the pop-culture application, this moral is boiled down to simple “decisiveness” and “sticking to one's decisions” (145–53). Consequently, the application to films and television is not as robust as it could be.
Remakes are seldom as good as the originals, so holding this “retelling” to the standard set by The Prince would miss all that is good about it. The book is almost as much fun to read as I expect it was to write, and it makes an important contribution to the expanding field of literature examining how classic works of political philosophy influence pop culture. For faculty wishing to incorporate film and television into their courses, this is a great reference, and scholars and novices alike will find the book provides a helpful starting point for conversations about one of the most influential books ever written. For these reasons, I give the book three out of four stars.
