Wahidin and Carr’s introduction to criminal justice in the United Kingdom is a terrific resource for students beginning their studies in the field (as well as for their instructors). It provides a thorough, yet impressively concise, overview of the various components of the system, including the areas of convergence and discrepancy between the institutions and practices in England, Wales, Northern Ireland, and Scotland.
The chapters are generally divided thematically to cover different aspects of the criminal justice system, and begin with a general introduction to the field. The first two—“What is crime?” and “What is the criminal justice system?”—address many of the overarching questions that new students in the field will raise, as well as set the critical tone of the book, encouraging students to look beyond the information presented to consider possible objections. In the first chapter, the authors present crime as a social construction whose nature and significance change over time. To illustrate the point, they present two different perspectives on crime—a legalistic view, and one considering it as a social harm—to show how crime may have different meanings for us depending on the way in which it is framed. They also consider ways in which circumstantial issues (such as underreporting of crime, attrition, etc.) can skew our understanding, by giving us a false sense of crime rates or of the efficacy of certain measures of prevention, for example.
The second chapter introduces the various agencies of the criminal justice system in each jurisdiction, and the main goals of the system itself—prevention of crime, punishment, and/or rehabilitation of criminals—to consider the extent to which the constitutive agencies of the system operate cohesively or independently. As throughout, this chapter considers the important ways in which the criminal justice system operates differently in England and Wales relative to Scotland and Northern Ireland.
The authors, in “Police and policing,” then provide a brief overview of the history of policing and the organization of the police, including an account of significant scandals (such as the Brixton scandals and the subsequent inquiries) that have shaped perception of the role and responsibility of the police. This chapter also includes a discussion of the historical background in Northern Ireland—namely, the Troubles—that has led to a unique relationship between the civilian population and the police.
The authors next focus on the prosecution stage of the criminal justice system, including the history and process of the Crown Prosecution Service, and the structure of different courts in England and Wales, Northern Ireland, and Scotland. They distinguish between the different forms of court (the types of cases tried in each, their sentencing powers, and the processes for appeals), and outline some potential issues. They consider, for example, the extent to which each can be considered representative when their racial and gender constituency is markedly different than that of the general population. This chapter also includes a discussion of some examples of miscarriage of justice, to illustrate the importance of recent reforms (and of reforms, generally).
Chapter 5, “Probation and community justice,” examines community-based punishment, probation services and social work, and the extent to which these operate as punitive or corrective means, or as forms of crime prevention and deterrence. It discusses the notion of ‘risk’ and the role of ‘risk assessment’ (including its inherent limitations and potential problems as a guiding principle) as an organizing principle in the criminal justice system, and explores (and evaluates) the consequences of that new focus. The authors consider various forms of intervention and rehabilitation—such as those based on the risk represented by the offender and his/her need of services, and cognitive-behavioural approaches. They also consider reasons for desistance (maturational reform, structural factors, etc.), and criticisms of existing models that call into question underlying assumptions about the nature and role of the individual labelled ‘offender’ (including the label itself).
In Chapter 6, the authors consider prisons—their development, the current state of affairs, and the abolitionist debate. They discuss some of the major historical events that led to the modern prison system, including discussions of the historical background in Scotland and Northern Ireland. The authors consider the prison population, efforts to privatize operations, and operating costs. The chapter concludes with a discussion of the abolitionist debate; it summarizes the criticisms raised against the current system and the proposed alternatives.
Chapter 7, “Youth justice,” contains the authors’ examination of the unique place and priorities of the youth justice system. The authors discuss the significance of the age of criminal responsibility (and the fact that it is relatively low in the U.K. compared with other Western nations), including the effect of the murder of James Bulger on public opinion about young offenders and policy formation. The chapter discusses diversionary efforts, as well as forms of prevention and early intervention (such as Youth Inclusion Programmes). The authors also critically discuss risk factors and the ways in which they are assessed (including inherent problems or limitations with this paradigm as a framework for youth crime prevention and support). The chapter concludes by examining rights-based approaches and the restorative justice model currently used in Northern Ireland.
The eighth chapter considers restorative justice as an alternative to the adversarial model of justice currently used in the U.K. It raises the issue of victim-displacement (in the latter), and highlights some of the consequences of restorative programs—both positive and negative—for all parties involved. The chapter provides an overview and outline of restorative justice approaches—including victim-offender mediation, restorative circles, and restorative conferencing—and reflects on the place of such processes in the criminal justice system (again, highlighting important differences between England, Scotland and Northern Ireland). It concludes by considering some of the critiques of this model, and responses to them.
The final chapter recalls the overarching themes with which the book began, and reconsiders them in light of the material covered since: the relationship between crime and societal values, the place of criminal justice in public perception, and the response to crime (punitive vs. restorative measures). The authors discuss recent changes in the tone of criminal justice debates and policy decision, and the extent to which the current culture is one of ‘control’ (as outlined by David Garland in The Culture of Control). Finally, they consider the future of criminal justice in the U.K.
Wahidin and Carr’s book is valuable not only for the way in which it expertly balances depth and breadth of inquiry with clarity and concision, but also for the numerous resources it provides for further study and deeper consideration of the issues raised. Each chapter concludes with a glossary of key terms, a list of discussion questions, and a short bibliography for further reading. The book is very well organized, with section headers and case studies to frame and supplement the theoretical material. For a book of its size (approximately 150 pages), it is impressive in its accomplishments. Indeed, for these reasons, one could consider it valuable as both an introductory text and pocket reference guide.
