Living Standards in Latin American History is a multiauthored work compiled by Ricardo D. Salvatore, John H. Coatsworth, and Amílcar Challú that offers new historical evidence on the standards of living in Latin America from the late colonial times until the present. With this evidence, the authors set out to explore traditional questions on Latin American economic history, providing novel answers. The research covers topics such as epidemiology and market integration, racial and class inequality, and health policy efficacy under authoritarian and democratic rule. This volume is an exciting contribution to Latin American historical anthropometrics, a field hardly explored until recently.
The first two essays, jointly, cover living standards in Mexico from 1750 until 1950, a tremendous achievement. Challú covers the late colonial era until the early Republican times. Using soldier heights, he finds that this country experienced a decline in living standards during this period. He claims that increasing cost of living and adverse climatic conditions explain this trajectory. The rise in food prices and El Niño had divergent effects on the different strata of the population. The author argues that the more vulnerable groups, i.e., uneducated, were hit harder. López-Alonso completes the Mexican picture, looking at standards of living from 1850–1950, also using physical stature. Restricted to the popular social class, the study shows a decline in heights followed by stagnation. The factors behind this trajectory point at harmful effects of land tenure policy, which, to some extent, were mitigated by the growth spur during the Porfiriato. Notable is the little effect improvements in public health and the agrarian reform had on heights.
This volume also provides interesting findings with respect to two underresearched countries in Latin American economic history: Colombia and Guatemala. Using passports issued between 1870 and 1919, Meisel and Vega explore the trajectory of living standards of the Colombian upper class. The authors find no significant improvement in stature during this period. Given that the sample is restricted to the elite, inadequate access to food does not provide a suitable explanation for this trend. Therefore, the authors conclude that poor health conditions were to blame. In Guatemala, Ríos and Bogin find deterioration in welfare in the late 1970s and early 1980s due to the Civil War and economic environment. However, they note a modest improvement in welfare based on heights in the last couple of decades. When looking at the first half of the twentieth century, the authors discover that stagnant heights suggesting insufficient expansion of the sanitary and health systems.
Salvatore in “Better-Off in the Thirties” calls for a review on the effects of economic growth on Argentina welfare in the 1900–1940 period. Using welfare indices a la Crafts, he finds that the living standards of the Argentines deteriorated at the turn of the twentieth century to improve considerably in the 1920s and 1930s. This discovery challenges the typical portrait of Argentina during this period. Certainly, the country was the picture of prosperity in the early 1900s followed by the “great delay.” In the first decade of the century, the author finds markers of nutritional stress whereas the expansion in sanitation and stricter laws on child labor are cited as the main drivers of welfare improvement.
High inequality has pervaded Brazilian history. Monasterio et al. look at the association between economic inequality and average height in Brazil from 1940 to 1981. Using family budget surveys, they find persistent disparities in height due to income, education level, and geographical location. Thus, the sustained economic growth during these decades failed to fully translate into more egalitarian welfare among Brazilians.
While most of the chapters explore anthropometric measures to assess living standards and welfare, two chapters diverge using other indicators such as the human development index (HDI) and mortality. Bertola et al. compare three Mercosur countries, i.e., Argentina, Brazil, and Uruguay during the twentieth century. In this chapter, the authors construct historical human development indices (HHDI) using data on GDP per capita, life expectancy, education, and income inequality. As expected, Argentine living standards—as measured by HHDI—peaked at the beginning of the twentieth century losing more ground during the infamous the 1980s, “the lost decade.” For Uruguay, the HHDI increased until the 1950s followed by a downward trend since then. Brazil started at the turn of the century at a much lower level than Argentina and Uruguay; however, the authors discover an upward trend until the 1980s followed by a decline. In sum, these countries diverged from core countries, in particular after the 1980s. For Chile, McGuire analyzed the notable improvement in living standards from 1960 to 1995. In particular, he looks at the rapid decrease of infant mortality during this period. What is curious about this development is that the bulk of the improvement in health conditions occurred during the dictatorship. As a result, the author questions the need of a democracy to guarantee public policies for the improvement of child and maternal care.
This edited volume is a much-needed addition to understanding the trajectory of living standards in Latin America in time. Its broad scope and multifaceted methodology will definitely serve as foundation for future work in this underresearched area.
