Although the scholarly literature on the Palestinian–Israeli conflict continues to expand and even flourish, few writers have critically addressed the legal and bureaucratic character of Israeli authority and the extent of its impact on Palestinians since 1948. Oren Yiftachal's Ethnocracy: Land and Identity Politics in Israel/Palestine does precisely this and much more. His work focuses judiciously on territorial politics and the enduring forms of manufactured separation and segregation between Israeli Jews and Palestinians, so critical to Israeli rule. However, unlike most other recent works on this conflict, Ethnocracy goes further and effectively writes colonialism back into an analysis of the Jewish state. Yiftachel draws from a range of sources to underline his case, including documents of Israeli planning circles, human-rights reports, and a diverse set of theoretical sources from the realm of radical geography. He thoroughly details the centrality of land and territory to the formation of identity and social difference in this contested region.
Crucial to Yiftachel's analysis is the notion of “ethnocracy,” which he spells out in the introductory chapters. He defines an ethnocracy as a regime that “facilitates the expansion, ethnicization, and control of a dominant ethnic nation . . . over contested territory and polity” (p. 11). In the context of a comparative analysis of such regimes in Chapter 2, he refers to Israel and other states in this category as possessing certain democratic features while at the same time being constrained by the fact that rights flow not primarily from citizenship but also from one's ethnic, religious, or racial assignment. In the case of the Jewish state, all three of these forms of identity are relevant in establishing a strict and often severe hierarchy of what he refers to as “ethnoclasses.” Those exclusions are built into the very structure of the Israeli state, according to Yiftachel. As a result, even Palestinians who are citizens of the state are forbidden from leasing or living on land in large swaths of the territory within Israel.
Building on an analysis of these sorts of exclusions, the author goes on to demonstrate why Israeli rule (both before its seizure of the territories occupied in 1967 and in the intervening forty-two years) should be regarded as a colonial authority. In Yiftachel's view, settler colonialism in this context has meant an active campaign to “Judaize” the majority of the land of former Palestine and make it off-limits to Palestinians and other non-Jews. This set of measures combines racist principles with ongoing state strategies to appropriate and expand into territories—and even the very homes—of Palestinians.
One particularly novel element in Yiftachal's analysis is his insistence on not cordoning off the Palestinian territories occupied by Israel in 1967 from those appropriated in 1948. Rather, he demonstrates how the lines that divide these lands have, for successive Israeli governments since 1967, only marked a historical limit on expansion. He further illustrates how appropriating Palestinian land in a city like Nazareth in 1948 (now within Israel's internationally recognized boundaries) is connected with the colonization of territory in and around a West Bank city such as Nablus or Jenin. After reading this insightful work, the reader comes away with a much more complex historical understanding of the nature of this ongoing clash of nationalisms. Yiftachel asserts convincingly that the core concerns that perpetuate Arab–Jewish hostilities date back to the last months of British rule in 1948, not simply the period after the conquest of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip in 1967.
Yiftachel's characterization of Israeli rule as colonialism is as daring as it is welcome to the literature on this conflict. The book also effectively lays out in the middle chapters some of the ways in which the ethnocratic state has fissured Israeli Jewish society and created various, differently privileged Jewish “ethnoclasses.” As he describes, “the Judaization of Palestine has had many consequences for Askenazi/Mizrahi relations” (p. 133). These “exigencies of Judaization” produce “unequal types of citizenship” (p. 126) within Israel.
In Chapter 3, Yiftachel discusses the clash between Israeli settlement policies (hitnahalut) and practices of Palestinian steadfastness (ṣumūd) that has served as one of the few forms of resistance Palestinians have available to them in the face of disproportionate political and military power. His consistent use of the term “creeping Apartheid” is meant to describe the simultaneous Israeli policies of expanding into Palestinian land and establishing Jewish settlements, places that exclude Arabs de jure. Given the variety of ways in which this has been done (from the sprawling concrete separation barrier that opponents refer to as the “Apartheid Wall,” to the demolition of Palestinian homes, to the recent public refusals by Netanyahu's government to stop settlement construction) the reader comes away illuminated about how an Apartheid landscape is becoming an irreversible reality in this contested place.
Ethnocracy's most important insights are apparent in Chapters 4 through 6. Here, the author makes a major contribution to the literature on Israeli rule by setting firmly in his sights the myth of Israeli democracy. He undermines the popular notion of Israel as a democracy by demonstrating the multiple institutional and noninstitutional ways in which non-Jews (Palestinians in particular) are excluded and discriminated against in myriad realms. He describes how these measures reproduce the Arab citizens of the state as second-class citizens. Moreover, as an Israeli Jew who knows his society well, Yiftachal is especially well placed to describe the corrupting impact on Israeli society of religious chauvinism and the dictates of exclusion coming from Orthodox, Ultra Orthodox, and other groups. This, he believes, also belies the notion that Israel is a democratic state.
Yiftachel is a geographer whose work is fairly eclectic and crosses different boundaries within the social sciences. His approach creates innumerable insights, and his analysis is often theoretically well informed. The various maps he produces in this work, for instance, are generally pertinent and helpful. However, no writer can do everything in one text, and his approach is sometimes a bit too wide ranging. For instance, some of the poetry he quotes at length, while often powerful, does not seem to mesh with the broader structural analysis he skillfully employs. Further, the various graphs and diagrams he deploys in an effort to depict the complex phenomena of racism, ethnocracy, and societal division in Israel are more often than not confusing and obscure.
Ethnocracy is a fascinating, bold, and dynamic book that adroitly details the character of a complex nation–state. The research presented is quite thorough and represents a vital intervention in the literature on nationalism and colonialism, both in Israel and Palestine and beyond. Its exploration of the shifting contours of colonial rule is a most welcome contribution to the writings on the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. Ethnocracy is accessible for advanced undergraduate readers and offers a great deal of illuminating material for those who seek to better grasp the complex relationships between occupier and occupied, colonizer and colonized, across this deeply contested territory. For those drawn to nuanced analyses of the intersection of land law, nationalism, and military rule, this work is a must read.
