It is never easy to review an edited volume, and this one poses as difficult a challenge as any. It would be impossible to adequately summarise and comment on all the various contributions in the book, so I will mostly limit myself to making some observations on how well the book as a whole succeeds in its expressed intent to present an overview of Latin America's ‘struggle for democracy’. Inevitably, due to space constraints, the review will sound more negative notes than positive ones, although the volume collects much fine work from excellent contributors on some of the key moments and places in Latin American politics over the last five years. In this case, however, as occasionally happens with edited volumes, I believe the whole is somewhat less than the sum of its parts.
Struggle for Democracy is with only two exceptions a compilation of articles published from 2004 to 2008 in the Journal of Democracy, all roughly addressing the question of democracy in Latin America – its institutional manifestations, social bases and actual operation. The book is meant simply as a re-publication of works – without updating or further editing – on the rash of national elections that took place in 2006, plus some works on the most important trends in Latin American politics. The list of contributors is impressive, including many of the authors of the most important contributions to the literature on Latin American politics over the last couple of decades. The book's greatest value lies in collecting in one place (usefully for classes on Latin American politics) a series of articles that address key elections and trends in Latin America. The ‘trend’ articles cover interrupted presidencies, the loss of confidence in representative institutions, the rise of indigenous politics, the ‘turn to the left’ and the transformation of the labour arena by increasing informality and the weakening of unions. These are certainly worth reading. The country studies include Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Peru, Colombia, Venezuela, Ecuador, Mexico, a chapter on Central America (commissioned for the book) and a chapter on the Caribbean (updated for the book). Many of these also continue to be worth reading.
For the most part, I found the ‘trend’ articles the more useful ones, since they are less tied to events that are rapidly receding in time and importance, and more informed by an analytical framework. Many of these articles will continue to be important contributions to our understanding of Latin American politics for years to come. In addition, the analyses of Mexico's 2006 election by Andreas Schedler and by Estrada and Poiré offer a useful analysis of the contrasting perceptions of the election, and the institutional failures and partisan, clientelistic roots of protest in its aftermath. Lourdes Sola's chapter on Brazil does a nice job of explaining how Lula maintained a delicate balance between meeting the demands of his (shifting) base and maintaining macro-economic stability and market-based economic prosperity. Several of the other chapters are equally useful overviews of recent events in Chile, Peru and Colombia.
The book is marred by two perhaps unavoidable problems. First, it reads exactly like what it is: a set of disconnected articles. In spite of Diego Abente Brun's interesting introduction, the book largely misses the opportunity to establish common threads or themes (the introduction is good in itself, but too remote from the actual articles to bind the volume together). There are repeated references in different chapters to institutional weaknesses as one reason why Latin America ‘struggles’ with democracy, and a corresponding emphasis on institutional reform as a solution. The fact that these references come in relation to different countries, different institutions, different origins and different consequences leaves the reader struggling to pull it all together into one coherent argument. Similarly, one can detect a novel emphasis on the perils of success – electoral, economic – that strikes an interesting counterpoint to the long-standing emphasis on the perils of perpetual crisis. But again, in some cases it is parties who are too successful, in others it is the economy, in others popular leaders or enduring party coalitions, so the reader is left wondering whether there really is a major theme connecting all these disparate phenomena. Fairly minor updating of the articles and a heavier editorial hand might have helped the chapters come together; a more substantive introduction with a more robust analytic framework for the contributions would have helped the book cohere; and a concluding chapter to pull out the collected lessons of the various contributions would have helped craft a quilt from a collection of swatches.
Secondly, one is repeatedly struck by how quickly several of the articles, especially the case studies, have been overrun by recent events, giving the book an occasionally anachronistic feel. Some of the articles begin stories they never finish: we get an interesting peek at the origins of Ecuador's 2008 constitution, but at the time of writing, the convention had not finished its work, so the ending is missing. Other chapters rest their analysis largely on elements that have radically changed in the interim. When we're done reading about the oil money bonanza that fuelled presidential strategies in Venezuela and Ecuador, we most want to know how these strategies have changed now that the boom in oil prices has become a bust. When we read about the utter dominance of Néstor and Cristina Kirchner in the 2007 Argentine elections, we desperately want to know how they came to implode in such a spectacular manner. So, while the book often provides a very useful overview of important recent events in Latin America, including an excellent discussion of central trends in the region's politics, so much has changed that the reader is left searching for the next volume. This is of course inevitable – every book on politics tells an unfinished story – but it is perhaps the ambition of the book as an overview of democracy in the region, and the mostly descriptive nature of many of the chapters, that leaves one with the feeling that it is already dated.
There is one additional, relatively minor, issue. At least in tone, several of the book's contributions all too clearly take sides with the ‘good guys’ who pursue liberal, market-based policies – Bachelet, Lula, even Alan García – and against the ‘bad guys’ who pursue populist, authoritarian, statist, economic-nationalist policies – Chávez, Correa, Morales, López Obrador, Ollanta Humala. Uribe's concentration of power and elimination of re-election barriers, for example, gets a much easier pass than similar events in Ecuador, Bolivia or Venezuela. To be sure, there are often good reasons to prefer the former over the latter – the weakening of institutions, the strengthening of the executive at the expense of the legislature, the use of legal institutions to stifle opposition. But there is in some chapters an over-identification of liberal economic policy with democracy, so that the authors seem to lose sight of the fact that serious failures of ‘market-based’ policies and a persistent exclusion of subordinate groups under previous governments played a role in bringing these new leaders to power. This is more a matter of emphasis and tone than a serious analytic flaw, but it might call into question the objectivity of the authors of some of the most critical pieces in the volume.
In summary, the book includes a good many insightful analyses of recent events in Latin America and usefully begins a series of conversations. Many of its chapters most certainly deserve to be on the reading lists of classes in Latin American politics. However, readers, instructors and students are left to do much of the work of pulling these various contributions together, tying up loose ends, updating with more recent events and making sense of the whole.
