Deborah Wong’s extraordinary book situates taiko, the now globalised drumming practice that started in Japan, as a noisy, ever-shifting, and sometimes empowering performance practice that is impossible to unwind from Asian American history, orientalist representational practice, gender politics, and late capitalist multiculturalism. Wong re-thinks the building blocks of ethnomusicology while modelling a rigorous interdisciplinarity, engaging performance studies, global Asian American studies, gender studies, and more with astonishing depth and a piercing matter-of-factness. Her ethnographic sites are in Southern California, but her analyses are wide-ranging, finding connective tissue among SoCal taiko and street car racing, Japanese nationalism, religious pilgrimage, Bruce Lee, and the onomatopoetic phrase pikadon. Without ever seeming impenetrable or inaccessible, Wong works through assumptions in the two disciplines at the heart of the book, taiko and ethnography.
The book’s seven chapters are framed by an introduction and conclusion, and interspersed with “transitions”—brief, often poetic provocations grounded in taiko practice. The Introduction lays out the broad historical, critical, and methodological contexts for the book, situating it firmly as a work of multimedia ethnomusicology. Chapters 1 and 2 introduce readers to ways of understanding taiko while at the same time problematising the very tools ethnomusicologists use to do so. Chapter 1, “Looking, Listening, and Moving,” unsettles the often-uncritical ways ethnomusicologists approach musical works and photographic documentation, “push[ing] at how ethnomusicology has depended on critical moves that limit how we are able to think about performance—that is, how we are able to see performance and thus to see the serious cultural work that performance does” (53). Chapter 2, “Inventories,” re-works the practice of enumerating, labelling, and taxonomising musical instruments by building inventories that bridge the deeply personal (what’s in a friend’s taiko bag) and the global processes that produce these items (i.e., the material conditions under which drums, drumsticks, and T-shirts are produced). Far from a tear-down of ethnomusicology at large, these chapters model a politics of care in documenting performance and minoritised performers.
In many ways, the heart of the book, Chapters 3 through 6, probe the material realities and political economies that undergird the emotional landscapes of taiko performance. Chapter 3, “Dancing the Body Politic,” engages bon-odori, Japanese and Japanese American festival dancing that is not taiko, but is deeply entwined with the historical forces that have made both practices part of Japanese American and Asian American life in Southern California. Wong’s enthusiasm for bon-odori and her documentation of the material culture and cultural history of the practice build an adjacent context for re-thinking what “traditional” means for Japanese American expressive forms. In a tight ten pages, Wong articulates in Chapter 4, “Good Gigs, Bad Gigs,” how the best and worst contexts in which taiko players perform are never truly separate. Chapter 5, “Taiko, Erotics, and Anger,” moves back and forth between intensely personal moments of pleasure and anger (her own and others’) and histories of Japanese American incarceration, reparations, pilgrimage, and Japanese nationalism. Refreshingly, the critical lens of gender is not tied solely to women, and is entwined with racial analysis. Chapter 6, “Pain and the Body Politic,” leverages an interview about bodily injury (blisters and sore muscles) to drill down to an uncomfortable truth about U.S. taiko players’ circumventing the history of Japanese American incarceration: “a huge amount of dedicated work goes into bypassing the pain and citing not it but instead a preincarceration, preimmigration body as a way to reconstitute history” (172).
The heart-wrenching transition, “How to Leave a Taiko Group” follows Chapter 7, “Cruising the Pac Rim,” which swirls around to the “ethnographic center of Asian and Asian American hip” (193) by weaving together a close reading of a 2005 Mitsubishi ad featuring taiko, detailing parts of its audition and production process, and documenting the global circulation of J-Cool via street racing and Hello Kitty. The chapter, which I initially found an odd fit in an otherwise deeply ethnographic book, drives home Wong’s argument that taiko and Asian American self-representation are inseparable from late capitalist globalisation.
Wong builds her work through generous dialogues with scholars in a range of disciplines and with other taiko scholarship, including my own. Besides her focus on the Southern California region, the attention to political economy and Japanese American incarceration make Wong’s extraordinary book distinctive among taiko scholarship. Moreover, Wong’s mode of critique, particularly of taiko practitioners, is delivered with the utmost care and humility and with thorough acknowledgement of the structures that surround and shape taiko players’ philosophies and actions.
The book and its visual and audio examples are available in open-access format online. Wong writes in a stunningly accessible and candid first-person voice, and chapters and transitions are designed to be easily excerpted, making the book very teachable. Although in some key ways, Wong addresses herself to ethnomusicologists, this book should be required reading for performance studies scholars and for anyone engaged in ethnographic methodologies. Wong’s engagement with the preoccupations, problems, and fissures in Asian American studies over the course of many decades makes it similarly essential for scholars in that field. Acknowledging that taiko is perhaps “being forced to do too many kinds of cultural work” (20), Wong nonetheless writes the material, bodily experiences of taiko into being with devastating precision and performative effect.
