Andrea Turpin's ambitious new book offers an innovative analysis of how gender shaped the ways nineteenth- and early twentieth-century Americans understood moral formation in higher education. She looks at a wide variety of schools, including all-women colleges, all-men colleges, and state schools. While only some of the schools were founded with a distinctive Protestant denominational focus, the leadership of all adopted Protestant-infused understandings of the moral development of their students. Overall, Turpin argues that “the arrival of female students to the academy was a key factor in the creation of a new ideal of student moral and religious formation—for both men and women” (4).
Turpin challenges the notion that by the twentieth century, institutions of higher learning had abandoned their religious foundations as they embraced secular understandings of knowledge and morality. Instead, she argues, colleges and universities continued to embrace theologically based moral formation of their students, but in new ways. In particular, she analyzes a shift in what she calls “relational spirituality” (17). In the pre-Civil War era, she argues, college leaders adopted a vertical theology, one that prioritized the relationship between God and individuals. Those that embraced this view saw the purpose of moral formation to be helping students strengthen this vertical relationship and training them to help others find a path to salvation. In the post-Civil War era, a more modernist and horizontally based theology became predominant in higher education. Academy leaders who adopted this view saw the central goal of moral formation to be more about healing broken human relationships and less about the individual's relationship with God.
The first section of the book focuses on two colleges founded during the 1830s—Mount Holyoke and Oberlin—which were shaped by a vertical relational spirituality. The programs of moral formation at both of these colleges exemplified what Turpin terms “evangelical pragmatism,” or doing whatever it took to prepare as many students as possible to convert to Christianity as many people as possible. Mary Lyon, the founder of Mount Holyoke, believed women as well as men should take up this holy work, and to do so, they needed similar training to men in scripture and fields in the liberal arts. The early leaders at Oberlin pioneered co-education as a way to live out their radical egalitarian Christianity. The women students at both institutions were encouraged to pursue callings that would allow them to have the greatest moral impact on the world. This was less about emphasizing essentialist differences between the sexes and more about practicalities. For instance, Mary Lyons argued that women should go into teaching not because they were natural nurturers, but because of “the comparatively few demands on the time of benevolent, educated ladies” in comparison to the demands on men (44). The success of women students at both of these schools pushed a wide variety of academic leaders to rethink their ideas about whether women could handle higher education as well as the purpose of men's higher education.
The second section of the book examines the changes in ideas about moral formation in the post-Civil War era. More women than ever entered the academy just as debates about Darwin and biblical criticism began to shake traditional foundations of knowledge. Moreover, colleges and universities struggled with how to equip their students for the fast-changing industrial economy. Yet with all these changes, the focus on moral formation did not fade away but instead changed form. Leaders promoted a moral vision that focused on using the ethical lessons of the Bible as a basis for improving humanity through social reforms. This approach was more grounded in this world than the next, which made it more connected to popular understandings of gender. According to Turpin, this led academic leaders to emphasize separate approaches to the moral formation for men and women. At Princeton, presidents like Woodrow Wilson de-emphasized making men into Presbyterian ministers and instead focused moral formation on manly self-control and the ability to be leaders in an industrializing society. Women's colleges began to emphasize specific roles for women in the new industrial order, ones that tapped into their feminine nurturing qualities. At Radcliff and Wellesley, for instance, college leaders and professors pushed for curriculums that were equal to that of men's colleges, but in service to the idea that women would enter gender-specific careers, like the emerging field of social work. An outlier to this was Bryn Mawr College, whose first president, M. Carey Thompson, saw the greatest moral challenge of modern society to be the equal inclusion of women in politics and the professions, and aimed the moral formation of her students in that direction.
Emerging state universities also saw moral formation as their mission. The Universities of Michigan and California started out as men's institutions, but quickly saw desirable reasons for co-education, not least of which was that women students could serve as a civilizing force to rowdy male undergraduates. The leaders of these institutions framed moral formation much like those of men's colleges, seeing their main job as training men for national service, while women's training was to prepare them to be a moral force for their families and communities.
By the early twentieth century, colleges and universities began to depend on student organizations to take the lead in moral formation. The Young Men's Christian Association and the Young Women's Christian Association emerged as the most prominent organizations to take up this work. These groups sought to promote a Pan-Protestant theological perspective among their members, but they also made distinctions between men's and women's service to the world, and this fit well with the moral vision of the colleges they served. Yet tensions arose when students in these groups tried to bring in all who professed Christianity, even though the national Ys insisted that members belonged to an evangelical Protestant Church. This led to clashes between students who “believed that forgiveness of sin through faith in a divine Christ was the essence of Christian belief” and those who were, in the eyes of the YMCA and YWCA leadership, “merely embracing Jesus’ ethics” (151–52). This, along with greater religious diversity on campuses, led to a decline in the Ys’ role as moral educators on campuses.
At the beginning of her book, Turpin admits that the institutions she examines are limited to white, Protestant-dominated institutions, and calls for future historians to examine ideals of moral formation at Catholic, African American, southern, and fundamentalist colleges and universities. I still would have liked more consideration in how the gendered understandings of moral formation at the institutions she chose were also shaped by the growing religious diversity in American society. She mentions that Catholic and Jewish students were present at these colleges, but gives no explanation about the ways they responded to moral visions dominated by Protestant theological perspectives. Further, I wondered whether the growing focus on horizontal spiritual relationships provided an intellectual foundation for Protestants to have a greater acceptance of religious pluralism in the Progressive Era.
Overall, though, the strengths of Turpin's book are many. Her focus on relational spirituality helps us understand the nuances in the ways nineteenth-century Americans understood the relationship among gender, religion, and morality. Moreover, she shows how the presence of women in higher education had a profound impact on the larger United States society.
