The title says it all. This is an account of chemistry and power in the twentieth century with a focus on Spanish history. As such, it is firmly anchored on and contributes to the literature on science and politics in recent history, making the case for the need of a larger presence of chemistry to enrich existing narratives. The Politics of Chemistry is a welcome step in that direction, among other things because its selection of the first three-quarters of the Spanish twentieth century provides an entry point into an age of extremes in a country with as many particularities as international connections. Analysing the political roles of Spanish chemists across liberal and dictatorial regimes sheds new light on the place of chemistry in twentieth-century societies.
The book's main thesis is that, throughout time, it was precisely the perceived political neutrality of chemistry which enabled chemists to use it as a sort of ‘joker’ in the service of their political projects. This means that the connections between politics and chemistry are not always direct or internal, but mediated by the scientists’ political use of chemistry. As such, the book's explicit methodology is that of a ‘prosopography’, except that in this case the actors forming the dynamic community of Spanish chemists have traceable biographies, which Nieto-Galan masterfully reconstructs, mobilizing a rich variety of archives he has dug in for at least fifteen years. This painstaking work enables Nieto-Galan to present an intricate web of scientists, instruments, research programmes and political projects with very real effects on social and economic life.
Chapter 1 explores the efforts made by a handful of chemists across the political spectrum to modernize their discipline according to international standards. The first third of the century saw the collapse of the monarchic restoration's bipartisan system, the military-led economic measures of the First World War (in which Spain was nonetheless neutral), and the rise of Primo de Rivera's dictatorship. In those turbulent times, both liberal educators and right-wing bourgeois industrialists seemed to agree that the country's economy demanded chemical research oriented towards import substitution and productivity.
Chapter 2 describes the crystallization of the efforts mentioned above during the Second Republic (1931–6). There are three distinct landmarks: the creation of the National Institute of Physics and Chemistry (financed by the Rockefeller Foundation), the celebration of the International Conference on Pure and Applied Chemistry in Madrid, and the first results of the collaboration of chemists in production industries. At this point, dozens of names and careers have already appeared in the book. While potentially puzzling, these trajectories weave a coherent narrative across the book's chapters.
Chapter 3 is perhaps the most original. Histories of science in Spain tend to focus on the so-called silver age up to 1936 or on the Franco years post-1939. The Civil War in between is comparatively under-studied. The chapter has two parts. The first shows the extent to which contenders mobilized chemistry in the war effort, including the production of poisonous gas on both sides but also contributions to explosives, the design of defence strategies, and protection measures for the civil population. The second is a vivid and tragic account of the breaking of the chemical community in a context of radical polarization. While the political account might be too thin for readers not familiar with the intricacies of the Spanish war, the prosopographical methodology is particularly powerful to highlight careers truncated by repression (again from both sides) and later the exile of those chemists who were not in line with the Francoist victors. Often it was chemists themselves who led prosecutions against their own former colleagues and the institutions they had created. This bitter political split of a rising community had lasting consequences for the development of the discipline in Spain. This is perhaps most visible in the biographies of those scientists who chose to stay in the country but were considered suspicious by the new authorities. They faced a sort of internal exile.
The next two chapters deal with the place of chemistry in the new regime. Religion and chemistry merged in shaping new versions of the so-called national–Catholic ideology, which through organizations like the Opus Dei and the Jesuit Order advocated for advancing applied science in the service of the national economy. The pursuit of self-sufficiency in strategic industries guided much of this applied work, if scarcity often curbed grandiose projects. A new community of technical chemists emerged. National autarky was a transnational endeavour, and thus this newly formed community, as well as the academic chemists they worked with, established solid international relationships. They acted as diplomats in times of relative political isolation.
Chapter 6 delves into the rhetoric of ‘neutral chemistry’ and its role in legitimizing Francoist developmental policies, including the role of ‘corporate chemistry’ in facilitating foreign investments in the 1960s and 1970s.
The final chapter turns to the political opposition of the chemical dissenters, including exiled chemists and ‘internal refugees’. Here, as elsewhere in the book, the (underanalysed) liberal (democratic)–reactionary (dictatorial) binary tends to obscure the heterogeneity of political options during the twentieth century.
The book's conclusion wraps up some central features of chemistry as a profession and its political import in the twentieth century, such as the pure–applied dualism, the ‘moral ambiguity of chemistry’ vis-à-vis modernization and professional identity, the role of chemists as (Gramscian) intellectuals, and the links between history and (political) memory. Here the author makes explicit his aim to write a militant history of twentieth-century Spain and its chemists. But Nieto-Galan's ‘motivational presentism’ (he quotes Oreskes) might in fact impose some distortions upon the historical material and the categories mobilized to analyse it. I have already mentioned his liberal/illiberal dichotomy. Also, more attention to ‘capitalism’ or ‘production’ as historical categories might have helped stress continuities across periods of ideological and constitutional rupture. Those are, however, open questions which further national and transnational histories of science and politics will have to deal with.
A brief addendum devoted to chemist Juan Julio Bonet takes the narrative beyond 1975. As such, it marks the way for further research onto a crucial period in which to trace the political meanings of chemistry through the transition to democracy, political decentralization and full European integration.
