Grass in Their Mouths is an important and neglected study of an important and neglected subject: the East India Company's struggle to establish an effective administration in the vast North Indian plains in the early nineteenth century. Once the battles were over, the alien conquerors had to transform their military supremacy into power on the ground: they had to maintain order, collect revenue, and settle legal disputes in regions in which they were outnumbered by their Indian subjects by ten thousand to one. The scale and complexity of the problems were so great, they were never properly resolved—and even now, seventy years after independence, they continue to plague the everyday state in South Asia.
Dirk Kolff's overall argument—that the Cornwallis Regulations of 1793 (the “Magna Charta” of the Company) gave the Bengal Civil Service a collective pride in their civilizing mission just as it was failing, miserably, to provide an adequate framework for the new administration—is indisputable. The forty-eight regulations combined the most enlightened principles of French philosophes bent on preventing “despotism” and the most self-serving prejudices of Whig landlords bent on promoting “development.” The scrutiny of every decision taken by the executive by an autonomous judiciary (the contribution of the philosophes) paralyzed the local representatives of “the state” by reducing their actions to gambles in a dilatory legal casino with an entire hierarchy of appeals to increasingly remote arbiters; the permanent settlement of the land revenue (the contribution of the landlords) robbed the state of the manpower to enforce its will in the countryside, exposed it to bankruptcy as inflation bit into the most significant source of taxation, and condemned it to perpetual dependence on the zamindars. District officers were systematically deprived of the power to contain the most exploitative elements in Indian society. Official factions, tax farmers, oppressive landowners, usurious moneylenders, and locally dominant subcastes filled this administrative vacuum by carving out small tyrannies in an orgy of legal chicanery, corruption, and violence. The Company's servants regained the moral high ground, after the scandal of the nabobs and the impeachment of Hastings, by abandoning Indians to their own devices. The slogan of the regulations might have been, “See you in court.”
The core of Grass in Their Mouths consists of five case studies of the Cornwallis regime in a single region: the upper Ganges basin. Each of these studies is a gem in itself, admirably researched, superbly detailed, and fluently written. The first (“The Gujars of the Upper Doab”) looks at the violent resistance of a tribe of semi-pastoralists to the threat to their local domination posed by rival subcastes and the feuds between their own leaders. The second (“A Change of System in Merath”) explains the failure of a district magistrate, Francis Smith, to get a particularly corrupt and violent police force under control. The third (“Beyond Rules and Regulations: Dehra Dun under Frederick Shore”) is a rare success story: it shows how an arch-paternalist could create a relatively benevolent “little kingdom” through sheer determination and a little luck in a district that was a long way from Calcutta. The fourth (“How the Landhaura Riyasat Was Dissected”) shows how a pack of predators broke up a small state (a large estate) by exploiting its management by a widow in an extremely insecure environment. The fifth (“Lawlessness and Legal Plunder in Saharanpur”) exposes the network of Indian officials who really ruled the district.
We have, in a sense, been here before—with Frykenberg in Guntur and Yang in Saran, with McLane on the zamindars and Arnold on the police. But no historian concentrating on a single district or a single institution has ever produced such a comprehensive indictment of so many different kinds of misgovernment in such diverse situations with such compelling clarity. As a study of the problems of establishing an efficient local administration in early nineteenth-century British India, Grass in Their Mouths is a tour de force in a class of its own. It goes to the heart of the matter: to the face-to-face interaction between the colonizers and the colonized. The routine day-to-day administration of the Raj was one of the major determinants of the well-being of the population of an entire subcontinent over 200 years.
It comes, therefore, as something of a shock to realize that Grass in Their Mouths has not received the attention it deserves. How could such a magnum opus possibly be ignored? The foundations of the British empire in India are not, it is true, a particularly fashionable subject. The title, also, is a little opaque. Grass in Their Mouths does not tell prospective readers much about the content of the book. Then there is the length: over 650 pages is a little intimidating. But even so, a book like this is a definitive work, the achievement of a lifetime, an expression of the highest-possible methodological standards. If it had not been for the price, €190.00, it should have walked off the shelves.
