On June 8, 2016, the European Union (EU) adopted the Trade Secrets Directive, which aims to harmonize the laws of the EU member states on the protection against the unlawful acquisition, use, and disclosure of trade secrets. Trade secrets are defined as information that is secret, meaning it is not generally known or readily accessible; has commercial value because it is secret; and has been subject to reasonable steps to keep it secret. Member states were required to transpose the directive into their national laws by June 9, 2018. The directive is modeled after US law, where trade secrets law harmonization started in the 1960s with the Uniform Trade Secrets Act. The United States enacted the 2016 Defend Trade Secrets Act around the same time as the EU Trade Secrets Directive.
The Harmonization and Protection of Trade Secrets in the EU describes and analyzes the EU Trade Secrets Directive with a particular focus on national implementation. It is written by experts in the field of information and intellectual property law in the EU. Their combined experience makes this book a valuable resource for practitioners, academics, and students alike. Due to the short introduction to the topic that precedes each chapter, no specialized background knowledge is necessary to understand the book.
The book can be divided into four parts. Part 1 introduces the structure and objective of the book and gives a general overview of the directive. Part 2, the largest part, focuses on national transposition and provides a comparison to US law. Part 3 deals with specific issues, such as employee mobility, choice of law, big data and artificial intelligence (AI), and enforcement. Part 4 discusses the application of the directive in very specific areas, such as adaptive immune receptor repertoire sequencing, AI in personalized medicine, and publicly funded research collaborations. The parts can be read separately, although starting with the first part is advisable. Readers may refer to the index at the end of the book to identify the chapters pertaining to their particular interests.
The contributions in the part on national transposition are worth highlighting for their practical relevance. Several authors point out the way that a specific country has either copied the text of the EU directive verbatim or followed it very closely. Other countries have deviated from it or expanded the protection to areas not generally considered trade secrets, which raises questions of compatibility with the directive. Even though the Trade Secrets Directive allows EU member states to provide for more far-reaching protection against the unlawful acquisition, use, or disclosure of trade secrets, rules must nonetheless not contradict the general aim of the directive. In particular, Ansgar Ohly's contribution on the German Trade Secrets Protection Act of 2019 points out that the addition of an additional element to the definition of “trade secret” in Germany is most likely inconsistent with article 2 of the directive. Several authors note that these issues will have to be resolved by the Court of Justice of the European Union and lead to further harmonization.
US readers will be particularly interested in the chapter on US law and its influence on the EU Trade Secrets Directive. Sharon K Sandeen, in her chapter on the topic, first lays out the general history of trade secret harmonization efforts. She then describes the scope and application of US trade secrets law and dispels frequent misconceptions. With that background in mind, she explains the expanded protection for trade secrets according to the EU directive. As Sandeen concludes, “there are both pros and cons to the Trade Secret Directive,” and seeing it as a reflection of US law might help interpret and address concerns about its limitations.
The topics addressed in parts three and four are very specific, and might not interest every reader. However, they address important issues of enforcement and highly relevant topics, such as big data and AI, which are relevant for other areas of EU law. An update of the book when the case law has evolved is worth considering. It will be particularly interesting to see how the interpretation of the EU directive will be influenced by the fact that it is modeled on US law, or vice versa how EU law will influence US law interpretation. In summary, the book covers a topic that becomes more relevant each day for both large and small companies in all economic sectors, not only in the EU but also globally, and is therefore a good addition to any law library.
