In this precise legal history, Deborah A. Rosen argues that United States incursions into Florida during the 1810s set precedents of enormous significance for the future of national expansion. Under the command of General Andrew Jackson, United States troops invaded Florida multiple times in the 1810s. They occupied forts, burned towns, and captured or killed British, Spanish, Creek, Seminole, and African American people. United States aggression forced Spain to cede Florida in 1821. In seven chapters, Rosen examines American debates about Jackson's actions in Florida. Perspectives ranged widely, from defenses that Jackson acted in self-defense as a protector of national interest, to objections that the invasion of Spanish territory and the execution of two British subjects violated international law and the United States Constitution. Whereas detractors worried that his flagrant disregard for the law risked the young nation's standing in the world, supporters believed that United States aggression demonstrated American equality with European powers, as a sovereign nation within its own hemisphere of influence. Rosen shows that although Jackson's critics were persuasive and legally correct, their arguments failed, because Spain was relatively weak, voters supported expansion, and Americans' interpretation of the law was selective and self-serving.
Rosen also argues for the significance of events that Americans did not debate: the displacement and killing of Native Americans and African-heritage people in Florida. Such violence elicited none of the outrage Jackson's critics leveled at him over the invasion of Spanish territory or the execution of British subjects. As Rosen explains, Americans likened Indians, runaway slaves, maroons, and free blacks to wolves, pirates, and outlaws under early United States law: “uncivilized” or “savage” persons who, although subject to domestic law, enjoyed no rights under it, and could not (as noncitizens) constitute a sovereign nation under international law. Thus did Jacksonians render Indian removal and slavery “domestic” concerns that were lawful in practice and in theory. Rosen concludes that by the end of the 1810s, the young republic had shifted away from universal natural rights toward positive laws (laws created by governments) that supported an exclusively white republic. This will come as no surprise to most historians, but Rosen's careful exposition of how this happened in the legal and diplomatic context of American expansion into Florida offers new and useful insights. Ultimately, Rosen demonstrates that regarding territorial expansion, most Americans were quite comfortable with ignoring or manipulating both international and constitutional law in order to serve their own national and individual interests.
Rosen occasionally overreaches, for example when she hints that the First Seminole War was the first or most important precedent for Manifest Destiny, a difficult case to make, because Americans were drawing similar racial and cultural lines along many borders in the early nineteenth century. At times she attempts to push her case to global significance, arguing in Chapter Five that “the American approach would strengthen a crucial foundation for Europe's second-wave imperialist projects in Africa and Asia later in the century” (151–52). Again, one may doubt whether European imperialists needed any help from the United States in justifying their actions; however, Rosen has made it clear that historians of colonialism and expansion have ignored Florida for far too long.
Rosen never strays far from law and legal debates; therefore, it is difficult to gauge exactly how some of these diplomatic and legal decisions reshaped life for Americans of different racial and cultural heritages in Florida: did these decisions actually change their lived experiences, or did the law justify the violence and discrimination that were already present? Rosen also argues that the United States took the lead in this legal change because of its proximity (compared with that of Europeans) to enslaved people and Indians. “They had a particular need to develop a special rationale for appropriation and exploitation that would enable them to continue to view themselves as shunning arbitrary and despotic government, adhering to the rule of law, and respecting principles of liberty” (210). The notion that their proximity to the “problem” populations of Indians and slaves explains some Americans' cultural attitudes is somewhat of a truism in United States history. Frontier dwellers frequently pointed out the hypocrisy of Bostonians who criticized expansionist violence on the Western frontier while devouring sentimental novels about noble savages from their comfortably already-conquered territory. Settler colonial studies would have offered Rosen's analysis more depth on this and other topics, as well as some useful comparisons. The legal and diplomatic events she describes in Florida underpin what many historians have come to call “settler colonialism,” but she never invokes either the phrase or the burgeoning literature on the subject. Scholars of settler colonialism will be interested in her account, however, especially alongside other legal histories documenting settler societies in the Americas and beyond.
