In 1829 Thomas Carlyle reflected, ‘Literature, too, has its paternoster-row mechanism … and huge subterranean puffing bellows; so that books are not only printed, but, in great measure, written and sold by machinery’ (‘Signs of the Times’, Edinburgh Review (1829) 49, pp. 439–459, 443–444). Carlyle was writing in the Edinburgh Review and his characteristically dyspeptic comments were a response to the rapid introduction of innovative technologies such as stereotyping and steam-powered machine printing by publishers in the Scottish capital. The increasing pace of technological change, for Carlyle, denuded the printed word of its former spiritual and moral potency. For the Edinburgh firm of W. & R. Chambers, on the other hand, it facilitated a philanthropic endeavour to bring ‘cheap instructive print and education to a universal readership’, enlightening individuals and thereby helping to civilize wider society (p. xvi). Although not cited in Aileen Fyfe's Steam-Powered Knowledge, Carlyle's exactly contemporaneous cavils show that the mechanization of print utilized by the Chambers publishing house could just as easily be considered a force for evil as for good.
William Chambers, as Fyfe shows in her fascinating study, had to adapt the new industrialized printing technologies to his own particular purposes, as well as to the local circumstances of the Edinburgh publishing trade. For instance, stereotypes, a novel form of duplicate printing plates, were conventionally used to supply back issues of journals or print subsequent editions of sold-out books, but Chambers deployed them to enable a separate edition of Chambers's Journal to be simultaneously printed in London. This ensured that large volumes of time-sensitive material could reach autodidactic readers in the much larger English market without incurring the prohibitive costs, or enduring the unreliability, of transporting mass cargoes of printed paper by sea. Similarly, steam printing presses had initially been developed for the specific needs of mass-circulation daily newspapers like The Times. Chambers, however, recognized their utility for also producing magazines, books and part-works in very high volumes, and thus with unprecedented cheapness. Fyfe's account of the introduction of such print technologies in early Victorian Britain is admirably nuanced and especially sensitive to the tacit considerations that shaped both the uptake of new methods of production and then the particular ways that they were put to use.
Steam-Powered Knowledge is, in part, a business biography (as opposed to, say, an intellectual biography), and Fyfe shows how Chambers's shrewdness and market savvy, combined with an almost evangelical sense of purpose, enabled him to harness the new mechanized print technologies of the 1830s and 1840s more effectively than any of his rivals. With his younger brother Robert, well-known to historians of science as the anonymous author of the evolutionary blockbuster Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation (1844), supplying attractive and edifying copy, Chambers's Journal was selling eighty thousand copies a week by the 1840s, far surpassing the circulation even of Charles Knight's famously cheap Penny Magazine. Such success elevated the self-made Chambers to the highest echelons of Edinburgh society, although, in line with his altruistic sense of publishing as a missionary vocation, much of his personal wealth was donated to charity.
New technologies also presented challenges as much as opportunities. Steam-Powered Knowledge is split into three sections, and Parts 2 and 3 describe how the firm of W. & R. Chambers responded first to the coming of the railways and then the advent of new transatlantic steamship routes. The railways afforded a fast and efficient distribution network that was especially important for Chambers, four hundred miles away from London in Edinburgh. For once, however, he was slower than his rivals, most notably George Routledge, to recognize that cheap print was actually the chief form of recreation available to travellers by train. It was Routledge, motivated solely by profit and without any of Chambers's proselytizing zeal for working-class education, who took the lead in developing the new formats of print and innovative methods of retailing them that emerged alongside the rapidly expanding railway network. Similarly, the Cunard Line steamships that dramatically reduced the length of transatlantic crossings in the 1840s opened up the enormous American market to Chambers's publications, with the publisher himself visiting the young republic in 1853–1854. But the cost of sending bulky cargoes of printed books and magazines by steamship remained exorbitantly high, and older sailing routes continued to be used as a cheaper alternative. It was instead piratical American publishers who benefited most from the speed of steamships, which enabled them to import just a single copy of one Chambers's works, reprint it without any international copyright restrictions, and release it to American readers barely days after its British publication.
Fyfe's fine book is another valuable contribution to the scholarly endeavour, over the last two decades, to integrate methods from the field of the history of the book with the history of science. Steam-Powered Knowledge differs from volumes like Marina Frasca-Spada and Nick Jardine's Books and the Sciences in History (2000), however, in one crucial respect. Science is regarded only as part of a broader spectrum of non-fictional information including history, political economy and classics, and is at no point singled out for special consideration. This explicit focus on ‘knowledge’ rather than ‘science’ is certainly attuned to the miscellaneous nature of much so-called ‘useful information’ in the early nineteenth century, and also reflects the thrust of the recent historiographic innovations summarized in Jim Secord's ‘Knowledge in transit’ (Isis (2004) 95, pp. 654–672). It is nonetheless a little unnerving to find such methodological arguments followed through in practice with such rigour and precision. Steam-Powered Knowledge, which employs the term ‘science’ only around fifteen times in the 261 pages of its main text, is an excellent work of history of science, but not necessarily as we are accustomed to think of it.
