On the cover of Julie Greene's new book is a photo circa 1910 of workers building the foot gate of Gatun Locks at the Panama Canal. The image is at once telling of the engineering feats that have long defined the history of the canal's construction and suggestive of the less familiar story of the workers who built it. This history of the white Americans, West Indians, and African Americans, among others, who came to build the canal, reveals how a working-class history of the Panama Canal changes the understanding of this moment in history. The Canal Builders contributes to an emerging literature on the history of the United States in the world that shows not only the reach and power of America's imperial ambitions, but also its limits, as workers challenged American labor regimes and laws on the isthmus.
U.S. officials in the Canal Zone, led by chief engineer George Washington Goethals, aimed to create a highly efficient and orderly construction project through a kind of “benevolent despotism” (74). Still, as Greene so ably shows, workers building the Panama Canal often “challenged, shook, and transformed” the vision of government officials (74). U.S. government officials used police spies, vagrancy laws, and race- and skill-based segregation laws to impede labor organizing. Under the terms of the U.S. military occupation of the Canal Zone, officials could even deport workers, including white Americans citizens, who threatened to strike (88). Laboring under these constraints, skilled white Americans working the steam shovels and cranes in the Canal Zone turned to their unions in the mainland United States to assert in Washington their workplace demands.
Such examples highlight the ways in which the history of workers' agency has been intertwined with race and citizenship. As white American workers pressed for better pay and benefits, canal officials began recruiting West Indians and other alien workers. Though officials established a two-tiered workforce—with most white and skilled workers paid in gold and most non-white and unskilled workers paid in silver—alien workers increasingly replaced white workers relegated to the silver roll. In this process, Greene writes, “Supervisors found West Indians to be competent workers and easier to supervise—in part because they lacked union representation and in part because Congress and the American public cared little about their welfare” (93).
Unlike white American canal workers, West Indians and other noncitizens lacked the power of U.S. domestic unions to press their cause. Nevertheless, as Greene uncovers, they still managed to attain a measure of agency in the Canal Zone by voting with their feet. Quitting, changing jobs, and refusing to show up for work proved effective strategies for these workers to win more tolerable working conditions. By refusing to work every day, for example, West Indians forced foremen to maintain a much larger labor pool than was needed on any given day, thereby affording laborers an occasional respite from the grueling pace of construction work (146).
African Americans, as non-white American citizens, challenged the strict segregation of the gold and silver rolls by claiming full citizenship rights. For reasons of foreign relations with the newly formed Republic of Panama, the United States had included “negro” Panamanian workers on the gold roll. African Americans, however, were restricted to the silver roll, despite being skilled riveters, blacksmiths, and firemen. In 1909, six African-American blacksmiths protested such restrictions, claiming their American citizenship entitled them to gold-roll status. After investigating the matter, Goethals agreed to pay these workers in gold but insisted on keeping the official designation of “silver roll” in their contracts (105–06). Such examples highlight, Greene argues, how American practices of Jim Crow segregation collided with imperialism in the Canal Zone.
Indeed, one of the great strengths of this book is the way in which it draws together domestic U.S. politics with American exploits on the isthmus. It reveals, for instance, how Republican Party officials worried that the mistreatment of black workers in the Canal Zone could compromise President William Howard Taft's standing among African-American voters in the North. The Canal Builders also shows how others in the United States found much to celebrate in the project. Progressive reformers, for instance, took great interest in the canal, seeing it as a grand experiment in state intervention. Reformers such as Gertrude Beeks and Arthur Bullard hailed the collectivist approach to government that seemed to benefit white American workers. However, these same reformers paid little attention to the West Indian laborers also working in the zone or to the Panamanians whose sovereignty had been so clearly compromised. As Greene writes, “In the years to come, such neglect of the wider world would shape the character of the American empire” (225).
Just as Greene situates the story of the Canal Zone within U.S. history, she also shows how it is part of Panamanian history. In the final years of building the Panama Canal, U.S. efforts were compromised by the very group American reformers had seemed to ignore: Panamanians. In the 1912 Cocoa Grove riots of Panama City, for instance, clashes between Panamanian police asserting sovereignty and U.S. soldiers and workers claiming American privilege erupted into violence, bringing construction to a temporary standstill (333).
Partly because of such riots, Greene argues, U.S. officials undertook an elaborate public relations campaign during the 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition in San Francisco in order to shape world opinion of the canal's significance. At the center of the exposition was a model of the Panama Canal, which cast the engineering achievements of the project as a symbol of American power and the workers who struggled to build it as merely the “labor of an empire” (366). In reconstructing the canal workers' world, The Canal Builders reframes the Panama Canal as a zone of contestation where workers from around the world challenged American imperial ambitions.
