While pension economics and finance have become recognized fields in their respective disciplines, a major shortcoming has been the absence of a compendium to map the terrain. With this pair of books, David Blake has provided the profession with the needed collected material, in a format accessible to non-specialists (although some background in economics and finance would help). Equally, the books aim to build a class of pension scientists -- people well versed with the multi-disciplinary and often complex nature of the field of pensions.
The theoretical framework for the economic and financial analysis of pensions rests heavily on a few ideas. At the individual level, utility maximization in a life cycle context is the central building block, qualified by questions about human cognitive ability and less-than-fully rational decision-making. Risk is built into this, usually characterized by uncertainty of outcome of a few key variables (investment returns, inflation, mortality). At the macroeconomic level, models capture the dynamics of overlapping generations, as well as the role and influence of governments through taxation or debt-creation in providing for pensions during retirement. In between, there is the supply side: why do corporations often provide pensions, and what are the challenges posed?
Blake appropriately chooses to embed exposition of pension economics in these ideas. He does a thorough job of bringing them together, showing how they are related to one another. The reader will find a theoretical discussion of the questions of importance to a pension economist: from life-cycle models determining labor supply and retirement decisions, to models determining efficiency conditions for an economy that demonstrates the economic impacts of unfunded schemes; from issues of risk sharing in pension plans, to those of bounded rationality influencing how people “actually” behave.
Pension Economics may be read in three parts. The first segment focuses on decisions of economic agents. After an introductory chapter, Chapter 2 presents the standard life-cycle model and its implications for individual saving and retirement. This is thoroughly done with geometric development of the main ideas. Chapter 3 turns to issues in corporate pension provision, beginning with a list of reasons why firms offer pensions. It makes the point that in the real world workers will not be indifferent between compensation from pensions or wages due to imperfect capital markets, risk, tax breaks, selection and sorting effects, among other explanations. The chapter also addresses the important topics of valuation of pension liabilities and agency relationships in pension schemes and funds.
The next two chapters examine the implications of alternative pension paradigms for the economy as a whole. Chapter 4 presents the Diamond Samuelson overlapping generations approach, and Chapter 5 focuses on the Blanchard Yaari characterization. The two well-known results are developed: first, that uncertainty attached to survival results in an individual discounting utility from future consumption more heavily, and second, that it is optimal for individuals with no bequest motive to annuitize all their wealth and hence perfectly hedge the mortality risk that they face.
The final portion of the book turns to specific topics. Chapter 6 introduces demographic change to examine the economic implications of a changing dependency ratio in an overlapping-generations framework. The author outlines the generational accounting approach to assessing the inter-generational impact of social security plans. Chapter 7 deals with private and public risk as it impacts pensions, focusing on moral hazard and adverse selection in both pension and annuity markets. It also discusses inter-generational risk sharing which has motivated the setting up of many pension schemes. The final chapter takes up the implications of behavioral research for pension scheme design, by highlighting the importance of default choices in defined contribution plans and the usefulness of simplified menu design in retirement plans.
Pension Finance tackles the specific challenges for pensions that a financial perspective highlights. Firms and governments the world over are grappling with how to transition from pay-as-you-go DB to DC systems; others seek to set up new individual account DC systems. Both reforms engender concerns about the ability of pension funds to provide retirees with adequate retirement income. Other questions relate to fund asset allocation, distribution channels, fees and charges, and pension fund governance issues. By dealing with such questions, this volume provides a window into the “real” world of this ever-evolving industry.
The first three chapters of the book are introductory in nature. A longish first chapter describes the range of assets held by pension funds and highlights key characteristics. Chapter 2 discusses the broad allocation of personal sector wealth; the discussion provides a conceptual bridge between the two books in that a consumer utility function is introduced. Chapter 3 highlights different professional approaches to pension topics, for instance comparing the actuarial versus the economic approaches to valuing pension fund liabilities. This comes down to the choice of discount rate, and Blake supports the economist's preference for using a riskless rate because the present value of liabilities is not reduced by investing in riskier assets. Similarly, the accounting convention of separating a corporate's pension fund balance sheet from that of the firm itself (the “accounting” approach) is criticized and compared with the financial economist's preference for integrating the two balance sheets. The chapter then analyzes the relationship between a pension fund's asset allocation and the sponsoring company's profitability, credit rating, and share price.
The next two chapters cover DC plans, split naturally into the accumulation and decumulation stages. These chapters rely heavily on stochastic simulation analysis to drive home their message about risk and return. Both chapters discuss charging regimes, a surprisingly neglected issue in academic analysis. There is a useful, if somewhat taxonomic, discussion of annuities in Chapter 5.
A short Chapter 6 turns to DB schemes and the assessment of DB liabilities. The discussion focuses largely on option concepts when relating DB and DC arrangements. The author defines a DB scheme as a DC scheme plus a put option (issued by the sponsor) minus a call option (issued by a member). This leads naturally to a discussion of the role of fund managers (Chapter 7) and governance structures. Chapters 8 and 9 deal with portfolio performance. The discussion evaluates benchmarks and risk-adjusted measures of portfolio performance, and also examines recent investment performance of both DC and DB pension funds in the UK. The author then turns to risk management in pension funds and how financial instruments can be used to hedge various risks. In particular, he introduces longevity bonds and mortality-linked derivative instruments as means of hedging longevity risks. Finally, Chapter 10 examines government guarantees of DB plans and the risks facing both the UK Pension Protection Fund (PPF) and the US Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) in the context of pension fund regulation. The establishment of these institutions has transformed pension promises into guarantees partially underwritten by taxpayers, which leads Blake to call for more stringent regulation than the standard prudent person rule prevalent in most pension regimes.
Both books follow a similar logical flow, from individual decision making to economy-wide implications and then to other specific issues. This linear progression of thought enables the reader to see the fields of pension economics and finance in their entirety, instead of a series of conceptual islands. Questions provided at the end of each chapter assist in recapitulation of the main points and serve as a benchmark in measuring understanding. Appendices on financial arithmetic, yield curves, duration and convexity of bonds in Pension Finance are also useful for clarifying discussion and serve as a quick reference guide. A glossary of technical terms would have been a further useful addition to these technical aids.
In reviewing such an ambitious enterprise, it is easy to carp. Perhaps two criticisms might be noted. First, there are inevitably some gaps. The most important is that issues in developing pension and retirement provision structures for emerging economies are neglected. Establishing broad worker coverage for such initiatives, as well as the challenges of immature financial and (especially) insurance markets, are vital for the majority of the world's population living in emerging economies, and these include examples of rapid population ageing. It would also have been useful to list issues and topic for further research. Second, the formal treatment is highly variable, in terms of the sophistication demanded of the reader. For example, Chapter 2 in Pension Economics which deals with the life cycle model, is intuitive and easy for a non-specialist to grasp; by contrast, Chapter 5 on overlapping generations models is quite formal in its treatment and lacks extended interpretative guidance.
Having said that, a generalist need not go through all the formal models in Pension Economics to understand the fundamental lessons that economic theory has to offer to pension professionals. Similarly, Pension Finance does an excellent job of covering the several questions that investment of pension funds have opened up: where to invest, how to invest, and how much to pay for that investment. Given that regulation and governance are two sides of the same coin, the book's coverage of the Myner report on institutional investment is apt. The discussion of charges is also very pertinent to the pension fund industry at large.
In sum, between them, the two books comprise a very considerable addition to pension analysis. For those familiar with only one dimension of pension analysis, including academics who work on pensions, industry professionals, and policymakers, the books offer a unique one-stop shop. It will encourage a more complete appreciation of the complementary perspectives that must be brought to bear on the field.
