Bacteriology in British India sets out to provide an account of how European bacteriological developments were institutionalized and practised in British India in the late nineteenth and the twentieth centuries. In tackling this subject, Chakrabarti weaves together narratives covering climatic and environmental history, bacteriology, epidemiology, nationalism, imperialism and tropical medicine.
Chapter 1 introduces a number of broad themes which underpin the remainder of the book, inviting us to consider who exactly colonial medicine was for, to what extent medicine was the provenance of colonizers or the colonized, and how demands for new bacteriologically focused institutions were played out in both medical and public circles. Although there was notable resistance to Pasteurism in Britain during the last two decades of the nineteenth century, where the popularity of epidemiological methods remained deeply entrenched, in India the British viewed institutionalized Pasteurism as a tool of modernity, enabling closer control of the colonial environment.
The laboratories associated with this strategy were in the main stationed in the rural hills of India in climatic conditions designed to mirror those of Europe, offering a literal and metaphorical separation of the British scientists and their research from the hostile tropical environment. A key driving force behind this move was the largely British Indian Medical Service (IMS), whose members were key advocates for the application of Pasteurian and Kochian microbiology from the turn of the twentieth century. The continuing racialization of the IMS, which had only a small fraction of Indian members, was reflected in its advocacy through the Indian Medical Gazette, a critical component in shaping the landscape of bacteriological opinion in India. In secluded laboratories (there is little hint from Chakrabarti that such activity was consciously secretive), medical scientists were able to experience a curious and unique hybrid of continental European bacteriology and British imperial medicine, which included a strong focus on animal experimentation.
Vivisection and the role of laboratory animals in Indian research is the subject of Chapter 3, which highlights the multifarious nature of anti-vivisection sentiments; in India, existing Victorian concerns about the practice of vivisection were allied with religious anxieties and a more nebulous fear that Indian animals were becoming appropriated and dominated by the apparatus of colonialism. Despite the complex intertwining of different sociocultural objections to animal experimentation, Chakrabarti argues, the status of science as a key ‘moral force’ gave vivisectors a strong degree of insulation from such critiques. Chapter 4 moves beyond the laboratory to examine how the ‘local scourge’ of snakebites appeared to be another field in which bacteriological methods and techniques were manifest as a panacea; such research embodied the dream of a modified version of Pasteurism in the form of a methodology which drew on disparate elements of laboratory science.
The ideological baggage of ‘live’ and ‘attenuated’ vaccines is addressed in Chapter 5, where Chakrabarti ties together often competing arguments over potency and safety. Here again the tropical environment exacerbated this dichotomy and gave added impetus to the need to balance the efficacy of a vaccine against its potential to induce the very disease against which such preparations sought to protect. The final chapter draws us back to what is perhaps more familiar ground by discussing cholera research. By locating this material in the twentieth century, however, the author is able to enhance existing narratives about this much-studied subject, drawing our attention to how the distribution of cholera shifted during this period.
Overall, this is an extremely detailed book, whose every page is crammed with information from across a diverse range of primary sources. Whilst this does occasionally make for a draining experience for the reader (this reviewer found that revisiting earlier passages was a frequent necessity), the sheer volume of material present reinforces the meticulous and thorough nature of the research. Bacteriology in British India is not simply a repetition or reinforcement of staid notions of imperial tensions and the role of medical science as a tool of empire. Rather we learn that colonial scientists adapted their understandings of bacteriology to fit new environmental contexts, and that this led to the extensive deployment of French and German bacteriological strategies which were never quite as thoroughly adopted in Britain. There are clear parallels and intriguing contrasts with the case of bacteriology in Australia, where (largely French) medical scientists such as Adrien Loir (Pasteur's nephew) treated both the country and its wildlife as a new and exciting playground in which to further explore the possibilities afforded by laboratory and field experimentation. Just as Bombay became an ‘experimental theater of plague vaccines’ (p. 54), Loir and his colleagues gave dramatic public displays of European vaccination proficiency and superiority.
It is perhaps unsurprising given the obvious stated scope of Chakrabarti's work that we learn little of the similarities and differences between colonial India and other parts of the British Empire, yet this points to limitations elsewhere within the field, where the potential for internationally comparative studies has yet to be fully realized. In this sense, Bacteriology in British India invites exactly such synthetic studies; we might learn much from combining the insights from this excellent book with other case studies of colonial and imperial bacteriological assimilation, transition and transformation from around the world.
