The history of Cairo and its monuments is a field almost as old and as crowded as the city itself. Dominated in the past half century by Janet Abu-Lughod's epic sociological study, Cairo: 1001 Years of the City Victorious (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1971), it has been told by residents and scholars for millennia. Nezar AlSayyad has contributed extensively to this literature in the past three decades. His most recent book, Cairo: Histories of a City, draws on his extensive knowledge of Cairo, Islamic architecture, and urban planning and echoes his earlier virtual modeling of the city. This book spans the entirety of Cairo's 6,000-year history and offers a compelling visual reconstruction of the city's layers of built environment as well as its marking by the political and personal ambitions of its various rulers and elite residents. AlSayyad's lively and empathic narrative voice reflects a profound respect for the city's architectural feats and a critical view of its seemingly overwhelming problems.
AlSayyad has produced an innovative textual model to narrate the history of Cairo. Working from his premise that “the history of a city is mainly that of specific individuals, places, and events” (p. xiv), the book charts twelve periods of Cairo's past and identifies each with a specific place in the city, one or several important individuals and events, and one or two historical manuscripts or travelogues. The text is copiously illustrated with maps, photographs of monuments, and reproductions of engravings and opens with what AlSayyad calls “a road map,” a table summarizing each chapter's time period, main event and personage, dominant buildings, and primary historical sources. It is not surprising that the major actors who emerge in the text are rulers and famous chroniclers, such as Ibn Battuta, Ibn Khaldun, Taqi al-Din al-Maqrizi, ʿAbd al-Rahman al-Jabarti, David Roberts, Edward William Lane, ʿAli Mubarak, Najib Mahfuz, and Alaa Al Aswany. While AlSayyad's unique model has resulted in an elegant book that will certainly appeal to an audience beyond fellow scholars (and including, I would think, undergraduates in introductory history, political science, art history, and sociology courses), it has analytical limitations. Despite his prefatory cautions about the limits of “objectivity” in the writing of history, AlSayyad argues that in his book “the multiple histories of Cairo speak for themselves” (p. xvi). His focus on great men and great buildings is an interpretative choice that foregrounds a certain model of historical agency even as the book demonstrates that the urban fabric and political realities ultimately constrained interventions into the city's built environment.
Cairo: Histories of a City provides detailed and engaging discussions of architectural form mixed in with an animated political history that focuses on the colorful personalities of Egypt's rulers and other elites. Stories such as Auguste Mariette's mid-19th-century discovery of ancient Memphis and Murqus Simaika's early 20th-century discovery and “remaking” of Coptic Cairo open the book's early chapters on the initial millennia of urban development. These anecdotes raise provocatively the question of historiographical representation—“that the writing of history will always be, first and foremost, an art of interpretation, not a science of representation” (p. xvi). At other times, the chroniclers of various eras of the city's history are used as lenses on less-elite life at the time: rather than periodize the history, the lives of al-Maqrizi, ʿAli Mubarak, William Edward Lane, and others are woven directly into later chapters to provide ethnographic detail and texture to the political history as much as to make less transparent the source material of historians. At times this narrative strategy veers into the realm of speculation in a way that does not seem to advance the argument of the book, such as when an imagined encounter between al-Jabarti and Lane on the Citadel is used to introduce them as comparative representatives of the periods in which they lived in Cairo. Nevertheless, the emphasis on architectural themes also brings unusual clarity to the history of the city. For example, AlSayyad cleverly carries his focus on funerary architecture—understandable in the ancient and medieval periods because tombs remain one of the few traces from those periods—into the late 20th century by opening his final chapter on the contemporary city with a discussion of Sadat's tomb within the Monument of the Unknown Soldier. Contextualized in the story of Sadat's assassination by Islamic militants who accused him of being “the last of Egypt's modern pharaohs” (p. 256), the built form of the tomb as a pyramid would have been, AlSayyad argues, “[i]ronically, one of the last things Sadat would see during his final moments” (p. 253).
The book offers a particularly strong analysis of the city's development in the Mamluk period. Drawing on al-Maqrizi's extensive documentation and the persistence of many monuments built in this period, AlSayyad contextualizes Mamluk political history and monumental building with an analysis of Mamluk architecture's effect on the overall built environment—for example, how the Burji Mamluks instituted “some of the city's most elaborate, irregular building plans in an effort to adhere to a street pattern that they had inherited from earlier times” (p. 145)—or how the extensive construction of domes, protruding entrances, and taller minarets, and their placement within the existing urban fabric began to knit together and balance the older elements of the city, created a “distinctively new architecture” (p. 146), and provided visual markers to help residents navigate through increasingly dense streets. The book offers many intriguing stories and wonderful data about the complex uses of buildings—the construction, dismantling, and reconstruction (from images of a replica at the Chicago Columbian Exposition) of the sabīl and kuttāb of ʿAbd al-Rahman Katkhuda; the Bohras’ late 20th-century restoration of al-Hakim's mosque; or the triangulated placement of the Cairo Tower, the Nile Hilton, and the Arab Socialist Union during ʿAbd al-Nasir's reign.
Any book designed around neat conceptual models, and especially one about a city as old and sprawling as Cairo, will have some inconsistencies of method and presentation. AlSayyad prepares his readers for some of these: not all historical periods will receive equal treatment, some eras (Memphis, Coptic Cairo) are narrated through their recent discovery rather than through their actual development, and some chapters, such as that on the history of Ottoman Cairo, cannot be linked to a particular monument or person. (In the case of Ottoman Cairo, AlSayyad argues, the city's demotion from capital to provincial city resulted in a stagnating built environment.) The frame of political history perhaps makes for elegant periodization, concise synthesis, and popular name recognition, but it cannot do justice to the complexity of forces that AlSayyad has documented elsewhere as responsible for the development of the city. Smaller inconsistencies of fact (e.g., differing dates for the reigns of Muhammad ʿAli and his son Ibrahim, pp. 197 and 202) are a minor price to pay for the broad narrative scope of the book. Overall, this is a valuable, concise, and innovative contribution to the historiography of Cairo that deserves wide readership.
