As the LGBTQ+ community has become an increasingly salient political constituency, questions of their belonging and their rights have become highly contested in the American mainstream. This paper examines the nexus between this relatively new battlefield and one that predates the American republic—racial exclusion—by examining the rhetoric of a contemporary far-right group espousing Neo-Confederate and Lost Cause values. Identity Dixie (ID) fits this bill—a loose collection of bloggers that championed Southern nationalism and the preservation of a white supremacy that they felt was under siege. Five years of ID’s blog posts show that this segment of the far-right perceives sexual minorities’ march for progress as an existential threat to their racial and sexual hierarchy. Such groups rely on claims of victimhood status. Society’s increased acceptance of LGBTQ+ people has, they have claimed, undermined their traditionally understood rights. This paper contends that these groups are responding to their perceived victimhood by attempting to re-racialize “pink” as the latest non-white threat to their traditional dominance, linking racism explicitly with restrictive notions of gender and sexuality. And, critically, their perception of lost rights has transcended the American South; they feel besieged in modern America by the direction of the nation as a whole.