To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
Chapter 3 examines how the Economist Mental Model (EMM) influenced voting behavior in the 2016 Brexit referendum. Using British Election Study data, the chapter shows that individuals with higher economic knowledge – a proxy for the EMM – were 11 percentage points more likely to vote than those with lower economic knowledge – a proxy for Alternative Mental Models. The effect of economic knowledge on Brexit preferences is comparable in size to established predictors like income and regional exposure to globalization, underscoring its importance. Robustness checks confirm the relationship remains strong after accounting for media consumption patterns. Moreover, EMM-oriented individuals also favor other welfare-enhancing policies, such as free trade and immigration, yet do not differ from others on noneconomic social issues like LGBTQ+ rights. Thus, economic reasoning specifically shapes economic policy preferences, rather than reflecting broader ideological leanings.
Chapter 5 investigates whether learning economic concepts can make people more patient, rather than simply attracting already patient students to economics. Building on the link between economic knowledge and lower discount rates identified in Chapter 4, it proposes that understanding ideas like compound interest and the time value of money reduces subjective discount rates (SDRs), fostering greater willingness to accept short-term costs for future benefits. Using a classroom experiment at the University of Washington, the chapter finds that undergraduates who received economics instruction had significantly lower SDRs by the semester’s end, while those enrolled in political science classes showed no similar change. Furthermore, both groups exhibited comparable SDRs at the start, ruling out self-selection of inherently more patient individuals into economics. These findings underscore a causal relationship between economic education and time preferences, with implications for public policy and intertemporal decision-making on issues ranging from retirement planning to climate change.
Chapter 2 explains how the Economist Mental Model (EMM) is measured by capturing two key dimensions: familiarity with core economic concepts (e.g., inflation, supply–demand, market dynamics) and the application of economic reasoning tools (e.g., cost–benefit analysis, opportunity costs, marginal analysis). This measurement approach uses an index of “economic knowledge,” drawn from original surveys in the US, Italy, and the UK. By assessing both factual economic knowledge and the ability to apply it to hypothetical scenarios, the index distinguishes EMM users (high economic knowledge) from those with Alternative Mental Models (AMMs) (low economic knowledge). Descriptive findings reveal that older, educated, wealthier men tend to score higher, with no strong partisan gap. Notably, EMM adopters do not value economic objectives more than those with AMMs, highlighting that differences in policy choices likely stem from how trade-offs are interpreted rather than divergent fundamental values. Demonstrating strong consistency across contexts, these measures set the stage for subsequent empirical analyses.
Chapter 1 outlines how mental models – cognitive frameworks for interpreting the political economy – shape policy preferences. It contrasts the Economist Mental Model (EMM), marked by a strong grasp of fundamental economic concepts and economic reasoning tools, with Alternative Mental Models (AMMs), which lack systematic economic reasoning. Equipped with tools like cost–benefit analysis, EMM adopters recognize intertemporal trade-offs, possible positive-sum outcomes, and distributional impacts, aligning decisions more effectively with aggregate welfare. In contrast, AMM users focus on immediate, visible effects and often adopt zero-sum thinking, leading to policies that cater to short-term priorities but diminish aggregate welfare over time. Crucially, Chapter 1 stresses that the EMM does not imply different values; rather, it shapes how individuals perceive trade-offs. The chapter also predicts that those with the EMM are more likely to update their views based on new economic information, while AMM users often rely on simplified cues, reinforcing existing misconceptions.
Chapter 7 investigates how mental models shape Americans’ attitudes toward globalization, focusing on trade and immigration against a backdrop of growing economic nationalism under both the Trump and Biden administrations. Using survey data and conjoint experiments, the chapter reveals that individuals who think like economists (i.e., high economic knowledge) view trade and immigration more favorably. To address the concentrated harms of globalization they prefer strategies such as unemployment benefits and retraining programs rather than protectionist measures. By contrast, those with Alternative Mental Models tend to support protectionist measures that promise immediate relief but undermine long-term welfare. Crucially, people aligned with the Economist Mental Model are more responsive to new economic information; when presented with evidence of net gains, they adjust their stance in favor of globalization, and vice versa. This responsiveness underscores that their support for free trade and immigration is not blind but rooted in systematic cost–benefit analysis.
Chapter 4 investigates how mental models, particularly the Economist Mental Model (EMM), shape Italians’ support for globalization policies: EU membership, free trade, and immigration. Against a backdrop of economic stagnation and rising populism, the chapter shows that individuals with higher economic knowledge – those who think like economists – are significantly more likely to favor these welfare-enhancing policies. Notably, this holds even for “losers” of globalization in terms of lower income, lower education, or routine jobs, suggesting that economic reasoning can override short-term self-interest. The chapter also explores time preferences, finding that EMM adopters have lower subjective discount rates, making them more apt to weigh long-term gains over immediate costs. Additional tests confirm these findings are not driven by general education, highlighting the distinctive role of economic reasoning in shaping attitudes toward globalization.
Chapter 9 examines how mental models shape attitudes toward artificial intelligence (AI), a rapidly emerging yet relatively unpoliticized technology. Initially, individuals with and without an Economist Mental Model (EMM) show no strong divergence in their baseline assessments of AI’s risks and benefits, likely reflecting the technology’s novelty. However, two survey experiments reveal that EMM-oriented respondents adapt their views more readily when presented with economic information about AI’s impacts on productivity, wages, or inequality. By contrast, those with Alternative Mental Models (AMMs) remain largely unmoved by the same data. In a second experiment using a conjoint design, EMM-oriented participants systematically adjust their support for AI adoption in hypothetical firms, raising support when gains outweigh losses and reducing it when the scenario shows net harms. Conversely, individuals with AMMs maintain fixed views. This responsiveness underscores the role of economic thinking in evaluating AI’s trade-offs and shaping policy preferences.
Chapter 6 examines zero-sum thinking (ZST) – the idea that one party’s gain must be another’s loss – and contrasts it with the Economist Mental Model (EMM), which recognizes that economic interactions can be positive-sum. Historically adaptive in static, resource-scarce settings, ZST becomes counterproductive in modern, dynamic economies built on cooperation and specialization. Using survey data from the US, the chapter differentiates between generic ZST (a broad tendency to see life as win-lose) and policy-specific ZST, which can reveal partisan divides. Democrats often display zero-sum views about redistribution, whereas Republicans do so regarding immigration or trade. Crucially, people with higher economic knowledge – those more aligned with the EMM – show markedly lower generic ZST and are less inclined toward protectionist policies than those with lower economic knowledge – aligned with Alternative Mental Models (AMMs).
In 2011, Italy narrowly avoided financial collapse, prompting the formation of a technocratic government tasked with enacting sweeping reforms. Although these measures stabilized public finances, they drew fierce opposition and highlighted a broader pattern of public skepticism toward expert advice. Similar dynamics unfolded during the 2016 Brexit referendum, when voters dismissed economic forecasts, and in Donald Trump’s election, where nationalist rhetoric overshadowed warnings on protectionism. These events highlight a persistent gap between how economists and the general public evaluate policy trade-offs, often producing outcomes economists view as welfare-reducing. This book explores how mental models, particularly the Economist Mental Model (EMM), shape individual political decisions and explains why populist solutions gain traction despite longer-term harms. Through diverse cases – from Brexit and US protectionism to price controls – it argues that wider adoption of the EMM could enhance support for welfare-enhancing policies, a crucial insight in an era of heightened populist sentiment.
Chapter 8 investigates how mental models shape individuals’ responses to policy information and partisan cues. Through a survey experiment in Italy involving hypothetical price controls on olive oil, the chapter shows that people with high economic knowledge – the Economist Mental Model – are far more influenced by cost–benefit data, reducing their support for price controls by 20 percentage points once presented with evidence of net societal losses. Meanwhile, those with lower economic knowledge respond more to partisan cues, increasing their support by about 6 points when party leaders endorse the policy. Notably, both groups share similar baseline preferences in the absence of new information, indicating that economic knowledge – not preexisting ideology – drives these contrasting reactions. The chapter further reveals that high-knowledge participants are 25 percentage points more likely to calculate the policy’s true societal impact, illustrating the distinctive role of economic reasoning in integrating and acting on new policy information.
Recent populist waves raise crucial questions about why economically harmful policies such as tariffs, Brexit, or immigration restrictions gain popular support. Conventional explanations focus on economic self-interest or cultural values; however, Beatrice Magistro's Who Thinks Like an Economist argues that the puzzle lies in how voters think. She introduces the innovative Economist Mental Model (EMM), which predicts attitudes toward trade, immigration, AI, and more. She explains that those adopting the Economist Mental Model are more likely to favor welfare-enhancing policies and prioritize cost-benefit information over partisan cues, while individuals with Alternative Mental Models (AMMs) show limited responsiveness to economic information and tend to support policies promising short-term relief at the expense of long-term welfare. Drawing on surveys and experiments in Italy, the UK, and the U.S., Magistro offers an indispensable guide for scholars and policymakers seeking to understand—and counter— the appeal of populist policies that ultimately harm society.
Recommend this
Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this to your organisation's collection.