To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
This chapter outlines why EU Cohesion Policy must end and explores reform challenges. Despite consuming a third of the EU budget, structural funds have failed to reduce disparities, creating a resource curse that fosters dependency, misallocation, and reform delays. Conditionality mechanisms are ineffective: national governments promise reforms that rarely materialize, while the European Commission prioritizes absorption over accountability. Monitoring remains weak, and political incentives favour short-term spending and pork-barrel projects. The chapter argues that subsidies deny lagging regions the chance to learn from poor choices, perpetuating stagnation. Ending Cohesion Policy is essential, but politically difficult due to entrenched interests and lobbying. Gradual phase-out may be more feasible than abrupt termination, though both face commitment challenges. Freed resources should fund competitive programmes in research, innovation, and defence or return to citizens via tax cuts. The EU must abandon idealistic redistribution and focus on enforcing the Single Market, improving governance, and fostering competitiveness. Without reform, Cohesion Policy will continue to undermine Europe’s economic resilience and democratic integrity, threatening the EU’s future.
This chapter traces the origins and evolution of EU Cohesion Policy, a project born from the utopian vision of eliminating regional disparities across Europe. Initially absent from the Treaty of Rome, cohesion emerged gradually through political bargaining, notably during enlargements and the creation of the Single Market. Structural and investment funds – such as the European Regional Development Fund, Cohesion Fund, and European Social Fund Plus – became central instruments, eventually consuming about one-third of the EU budget. Their stated aim has been convergence, with transfers heavily concentrated in regions below 75 per cent of EU average income. Over time, Cohesion Policy expanded dramatically, reinforced by successive treaties and reforms, and complemented by instruments like the Recovery and Resilience Facility. Yet, despite unprecedented scale – far exceeding the Marshall Plan – the policy lacks a coherent economic theory or even a precise definition of ‘cohesion’. Its persistence reflects political expediency: richer states fund poorer ones to secure integration, while poorer states lobby for continued support. This chapter argues that Cohesion Policy is less an economic strategy than a political bargain.
This chapter argues that EU Cohesion Policy – through its structural and investment funds – has failed to achieve its core objective of regional convergence and has instead produced harmful economic and political consequences. Despite consuming roughly one-third of the EU budget and enjoying strong political support, these funds have not reduced disparities; in fact, some regions and entire countries, such as Portugal and Greece, have diverged from the EU average. I contend that cohesion funds operate as a form of resource curse: they distort incentives, foster dependency, and delay structural reforms, ultimately weakening competitiveness and governance. While the European Commission claims high returns on investment, credible evidence is scarce, and monitoring remains inadequate. Drawing on historical analogies and case studies, I show that these subsidies misallocate resources and undermine institutional quality, contributing to Europe’s stagnation relative to global competitors. Ending Cohesion Policy – while preserving beneficial aspects of EU integration – is essential for revitalizing the Union. This chapter sets out the intellectual foundation for that reform, challenging entrenched assumptions and calling for a serious debate on the future of EU regional policy.
This chapter argues that EU Cohesion Policy has created a resource curse within Europe, fostering dependency, misallocation, and institutional decay in several Member States. Despite decades of structural funds – amounting to hundreds of billions – countries like Greece, Portugal, and southern Italy have failed to converge and, in fact, diverged from EU averages. The chapter explains how continuous inflows of ‘easy money’ distort incentives, delay reforms, and weaken democratic accountability, while official EU reports rely on implausible models and confuse spending with outcomes. Economic mechanisms such as Dutch Disease inflate non-tradable sectors like construction, while political effects include rent-seeking, clientelism, and executive dominance over parliaments. Funds often substitute for national spending, finance short-term projects, and encourage pork-barrel investments, rather than fostering innovation or competitiveness. Although some Central and Eastern European countries have converged, warning signs suggest similar risks ahead. Cohesion Policy, intended as solidarity, has become a poison pill: perpetuating stagnation and undermining governance. Without credible reform or termination, the EU risks deepening regional divergence and weakening its long-term economic resilience.
This concluding chapter argues that EU Cohesion Policy, despite its stated goal of reducing regional disparities, has failed and should be terminated. Consuming over a third of the EU budget, structural funds have not delivered convergence; instead, they have fostered dependency, misallocation, and a resource curse that undermines competitiveness and governance. The EU continues to promote unrealistic claims about cohesion’s benefits while neglecting its core mission: enforcing the Single Market. Evidence shows that subsidies distort incentives, delay reforms, and weaken accountability, harming both poorer regions and the EU as a whole. The utopian vision of equalizing Member States through transfers is unattainable and counterproductive. Ending Cohesion Policy would free resources for priorities such as science, innovation, demographic resilience, and defence – areas critical for Europe’s future. Reform faces strong political resistance from net beneficiaries and entrenched interests, but pressure from net contributors will eventually make continuation unsustainable. A serious intellectual debate is urgently needed. Cohesion Policy has failed for decades; prolonging it risks further economic stagnation and geopolitical vulnerability. The time to end Europe’s resource curse is now.
This book offers a critical analysis of the European Union’s Cohesion Policy and its structural and investment funds. These instruments, aimed at reducing regional disparities and fostering growth, distribute billions annually to poorer EU regions. While rooted in noble intentions, evidence of their effectiveness is limited and inconclusive. I argue that this policy’s utopian vision is unattainable and that its implementation has become a major factor behind Europe’s economic stagnation, political malaise, and demographic challenges. Rather than promoting innovation and competitiveness, structural funds often perpetuate dependency and misallocation, undermining the EU’s long-term stability. Drawing on academic literature, media sources, and case studies – particularly from Portugal, Greece, southern Italy, and post-communist Member States – this book calls for the termination of these subsidies and a fundamental rethinking of EU priorities. It seeks to open a rigorous debate on the root causes of Europe’s decline and the urgent need for institutional reform to secure the Union’s future.
For more than seven decades, the European Union has delivered on its founding promise of peace in Western Europe. Yet serious economic and political problems persist, among them widening regional inequality. Europe's Poison Pill exposes the hidden costs of EU Cohesion Policy, showing how initiatives meant to promote convergence instead entrench stagnation, distort incentives, and defer essential reforms. Drawing on historical evidence, contemporary case studies, and economic analysis, Nuno Palma demonstrates that structural and investment funds operate as a modern resource curse, weakening many of the regions they target. The book offers a roadmap for restoring Europe's competitiveness and institutional credibility. By challenging entrenched orthodoxies, it reframes the debate on Europe's future and confronts the costs of preserving a failed model.
Recommend this
Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this to your organisation's collection.