To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
The Introduction outlines the aims and structure of the book. It begins by situating the Cambridge Social Ontology (CSO) project within the Cambridge tradition and outlining its critique of mainstream economics. It then presents the two central components of CSO, Social Positioning Theory (SPT) and Critical Ethical Naturalism (CEN), as complementary accounts of the social and ethical constitution of human life. Attention is given to the ethical and political dimensions of SPT and to the way CEN provides its ontological and moral grounding. The discussion further examines CEN’s Aristotelian roots and its potential to offer a coherent alternative to dominant moral frameworks. The final section introduces the comparative focus of the book, which explores the relationship between CSO and Amartya Sen’s contributions to political economy and ethics. Together, these sections establish the theoretical and methodological basis for the analysis that follows and clarify the importance of ontological consistency for reviving political economy as a comprehensive social science.
This chapter examines Amartya Sen’s ethical writings in relation to Critical Ethical Naturalism (CEN). While Sen’s capability approach and later work on ethics are often read as alternatives to consequentialism and deontology, he never presents them as a systematic moral theory. His emphasis on freedom, capabilities and functionings reflects an implicit realist orientation which some, notably Martins and Lawson, interpret as ontological in character. Lawson further suggests that Sen’s framework might be viewed as a special case of CEN. It is argued, however, that the two projects diverge: Sen’s ethics rests on implicit ontological tensions, whereas CEN is explicitly grounded in ontological coherence. The chapter highlights these tensions, contrasts the orientations of the two projects toward Aristotle and mainstream ethics, explores the sources of Sen’s ontological reticence, and considers the form of embedded liberalism shaping his stance. It concludes by reflecting on whether limited synthesis between the two frameworks is possible.
The conclusion offers an overview of the book’s central arguments. It first reflects on the development of Critical Ethical Naturalism (CEN) within a particular interpretation of Aristotle, showing how this alignment strengthens both its ethical content and its role within Cambridge Social Ontology (CSO). Situating CEN in this way provides a richer ontological grounding for understanding human flourishing and supports the broader project of reviving political economy on realist foundations. The discussion then revisits the comparison between CSO and Amartya Sen, highlighting that while both seek to integrate ethics and economics, they rest on contrasting ontological orientations. Sen’s reluctance to engage systematically with ontology produces conceptual ambiguities that limit the coherence of his framework. The conclusion also considers how Nussbaum’s and Robeyns’s liberal presuppositions reinforce these tensions. It closes by reaffirming the necessity of ontological inquiry for conceptual clarity, ethical critique, and the revival of political economy as a comprehensive social science.
This chapter examines Amartya Sen’s complex relationship with mainstream economics through a Veblenian lens. While Sen’s contributions to development economics and the capability approach are widely seen as transformative, his continued reliance on formal methods reveals an underlying ontological tension. Drawing on Thorstein Veblen’s original use of the term neoclassical, the chapter argues that Sen embodies the same duality Veblen identified in his contemporaries: an implicit recognition of a causal-processual social ontology characteristic of an evolutionary orientation, coupled with a taxonomic conception of science grounded in event regularities. For Veblen, this combination defined the ’neo’ and the ’classical’ aspects of neoclassical economists. Sen’s work, it is argued, remains neoclassical in precisely this Veblenian sense. Analysing this tension helps explain the persistence of ontological inconsistencies across Sen’s corpus and clarifies the diversity of interpretations his work continues to attract within economics.
This chapter examines the key features of Critical Ethical Naturalism (CEN) through a sustained engagement with Aristotle’s ethics and politics. Four central dimensions of CEN are explored. First, its account of humans as community beings, mutually constituted and co-developing, is illuminated through Aristotle’s notions of character friendship and our intrinsically political nature. Second, the Aristotelian conception of eudaimonia clarifies CEN’s understanding of human flourishing. Third, CEN’s claim that all humans are, in a sense, ethical naturalists, owing to their inherent dispositions to care, is reconsidered alongside Aristotle’s view that rational agents choose to endorse caring tendencies not merely because they are natural but because they are good. Finally, the chapter explores CEN’s recognition of human vulnerability and the social conditions that inhibit care, drawing parallels with Aristotle’s critique of defective political systems. Aristotle’s notion of organic social development also deepens the analysis of authenticity in CEN and its relation to human flourishing.
This chapter examines the interpretive consequences of Amartya Sen’s ontological reticence. While Sen recognises the social world as open and processual, his continued reliance on formal, taxonomic methods generates a deep tension that shapes how his work has been received and operationalised. It is argued that the plurality of interpretations surrounding the capability approach reflects not theoretical flexibility but ontological ambiguity. Drawing on developments in Social Choice Theory and mainstream empirical modelling, the chapter shows how Sen’s framework has been adapted within methodologies that presuppose closed systems, thereby diluting its relational orientation. It then contrasts these uses with heterodox applications that foreground an evolutionary outlook. Finally, by examining the contributions of Nussbaum and Robeyns, it is highlighted how liberal conceptions of personhood reinforce ontological inconsistencies and preliminary counters to their claims are offered. The chapter concludes by reflecting on the stakes of these tensions for the future development of the capability approach and its role in the revival of political economy.
The contributions of Amartya Sen and Cambridge Social Ontology are two important streams in the Cambridge tradition of political economy. Despite significant commonalities, the nature and limits of their convergence remain largely unexamined. Ontology, Ethics and Economics provides the first comparative analysis of these two schools of economic thought. It argues that coherence across economic, social, and ethical theorising can only be achieved when grounded on a solid ontological foundation. While Sen's work has reintroduced crucial ethical dimensions to economics, his reluctance to address ontology systematically has generated tensions that account for the wide and often contradictory interpretations and applications of his work. Offering an explicit account of social reality and its moral implications within a distinctive philosophical framework, this book shows how ontological inquiry can restore political economy's emancipatory orientation and its capacity to offer a genuine alternative to contemporary mainstream economics.
Recommend this
Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this to your organisation's collection.