To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
This chapter begins by introducing selection – the appointment, promotion and reassignment of international officials – as an administrative decision exercising discretionary authority, that is inherent to securing the highest standards of efficiency, competence, and integrity necessitated by the treaty-basis of international organizations. Second, the legal principles of selection are identified, namely: (1) Absent abuse of discretion, deference is due selecting managers; (2) Vacancy announcements must be adhered to, but may be revoked; and (3) Selection defects must be manifest, to be contestable. Third, two attendant legal duties of selection are considered, as follows: (1) Selection must be competency-based; and (2) All candidates are entitled to consideration, but not selection. Fourth, non-competitive selection – through direct selection and reassignment – is examined. Fifth, the classification of positions that underpins the objectivity of selection is considered. Sixth, and in conclusion, the employment law of selection at international organizations is restated.
This chapter begins by describing ending service – the automated discontinuance of the employment of international officials, administrated in accordance with the authority of the principal executive officer to achieve an adaptable, effective and highly efficient international organization. (Differently, administrative action may terminate employment as a consequence of performance management – see Chapter 8, ‘Performance Management’ – and as consequence of the enforcement of standards of conduct – see Chapter 10, ‘Misconduct’ – at international organizations.) Second, the legal principles of ending service are identified, namely: (1) Absent abuse of discretion, deference is owed organizational restructuring; (2) Absent abuse of discretion, deference is owed appointment nonrenewal; and (3) Mutually agreed termination may obtain legal release. Third, the related governance of ending service is considered, namely the legal duties that: (1) Abolition of post must be credible; and (2) Recourse to redundancy must exhaust practicable alternatives. Fourth, the chapter addresses service ending in circumstances of an international official unable – as a result of illness or injury – or unwilling to perform their duties. Fifth, service ending upon attainment by a staff member of a mandatory retirement age is examined. Sixth, and in conclusion, this employment law of ending service at international organizations is restated.
This chapter begins by describing performance management – the administrative action of appraising performance and its consequences – inherent to the continuing treaty-based obligation of international organizations to secure the highest standards of efficiency and competence of their staff. Second, the legal principles of performance management are identified, namely: (1) Absent abuse of discretion, deference is owed performance-managers; (2) Performance management defects must be manifest, to be contestable; and (3) Probationary decisions exercise the widest discretion. Third, two attendant legal duties of performance appraisal are considered, as follows: (1) Performance appraisal must be useable; and (2) Performance appraisal must afford an opportunity to respond. Fourth, the temporary intensification of performance management as the basis for termination of appointment – in the context of probation and substandard performance – is examined. Fifth, and in conclusion, this employment law of performance management at international organizations is restated.
This chapter explores the limits of discretion exercised by international organizations, providing a detailed analysis of substantive grounds of review applied by international administrative tribunals. It examines various forms of legal error, including wrongful legal qualifications, and considers the diverging criteria used by these tribunals to safeguard legitimate expectations and binding promises as constraints on discretion. Addressing errors of fact, the chapter notes that tribunals often defer to specialized bodies, intervening only when decisions rely on obviously flawed premises. The concept of abuse of discretion is discussed by reference to three categories, namely bad faith, reasonableness, and abuse of discretion stricto sensu, highlighting administrative purpose as a core element of judicial review. Finally, the chapter scrutinizes key moments in the disciplinary process, highlighting both common aspects of the jurisprudence and sources of divergence, such as the definition of standards of proof and review, and the form of proportionality analysis applied.
ERISA’s underdeveloped civil enforcement mechanism, section 502(a), has generated extensive litigation. Judicially crafted strictures on the relief available to participants have arisen with respect to standing, scope of judicial review, causes of action, and remedies. While the Supreme Court has held those with a colorable claim to benefits have standing, precisely what that means has proven elusive. Judicial review of denied claims is strictly constrained. Court access requires that participants have exhausted internal review processes, and if the plan grants the administrator discretion to determine eligibility for benefits or construe the plan’s terms (which is virtually always), judicial review is restricted to a cursory scan for abuse of discretion. Deferential review survives even if the administrator is conflicted: lower courts are instructed to consider the conflict merely as one factor in and overall assessment of whether discretion was abused. Finally, the Court has held that ERISA does not permit the full panoply of damages one would expect in the aftermath of contractual or fiduciary breach. Consequential damages are unavailable for denied claims, and equitable relief for fiduciary breach is limited to what was typically available in equity in the days of the divided bench.
Recommend this
Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this to your organisation's collection.