In this chapter, we, as two transnational language teacher educators (LTEs), critically reflect on our evolving identities as LTEs, by explicitly focusing on our emotions and agency. Methodologically, we use collaborative autoethnography (CAE) to blend dialogic co-interviews, autobiographical writing, and self-reflection, situating our identities at the intersection of personal, political, and professional experiences. Our stories include these takeaway points: (1) border crossing and in-betweenness are integral aspects of our identities, (2) teacher educators, specifically those with transnational backgrounds, require more support and opportunities for reflective practice to reconcile their multifaceted identities and responsibilities, (3) navigating our transnational identities involve significant emotion labor and emotion work, (4) our sociopolitically -situated agency is intertwined with the emotional and reflective identity work, and (5) our personal and social identities, vis-a-vis culture, language, gender, nationality, and religion, amongst others, are inseparable from ongoing professional identity work.