A century ago, in 1924, Sir Jadunath Sarkar (1870–1958) completed the fifth and final volume of his magisterial History of Aurangzib.Footnote 1 These five volumes still stand as the most detailed and authoritative work on the last of the so-called great Mughal emperors, Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir (b. 1618, r. 1658–1707).Footnote 2 Scholars widely admire the scale and breadth of Sarkar’s knowledge of the man and the period, particularly its political history, and his careful attention to details and sources, most of which had been unused for centuries. Sarkar wrote in a crisp and readable style, offering clear analytical insights. However, those insights became progressively more polarizing with each volume.
In Sarkar’s early estimation ‘Alamgir was
free from vice, stupidity, or sloth. His intellectual keenness was proverbial, and at the same time he took to the business of governing with all the ardour which men usually display in the pursuit of pleasure. … He faced the privations of a campaign or a forced march as uncomplainingly as the most seasoned private. … Of the wisdom of the ancients which can be gathered from ethical books, he was a master.
Although Sarkar noted that ‘Alamgir’s reign ended in failure, he provided little commentary beyond a vague faulting of the emperor’s “policy and conduct.”Footnote 3 But Sarkar’s opinion had shifted dramatically by the time he published the fifth volume.Footnote 4 The rising Hindu–Muslim religious tensions of the early 1920s as well as Sarkar’s distaste for Muslim nationalist politics had taken their toll, and in the final chapters of his magnum opus Sarkar condemned ‘Alamgir’s reign for enabling “utter dissolution and misery,” economic impoverishment, natural disasters, the “decay of Indian civilization,” vice and popular superstitions, corruption, and a system of Islamic governance that rendered “a fusion between Hindus and Muslims impossible.”Footnote 5 He condemned ‘Alamgir for forcing Hindus to live “deprived of the light of knowledge, deprived of the consolations of religion, deprived of social union and public rejoicing, of wealth and the self-confidence that is begotten by the free exercise of natural activities and use of opportunities, in short, a life exposed to constant public humiliation and political disabilities.”Footnote 6 Although Sarkar’s subsequent rhetoric about the Mughal Empire was less overwrought, in the remaining decades of his prolific scholarly life he was consistent in framing Hindus as victims of a hostile Muslim empire, and ‘Alamgir in particular.
And herein lies the rub. Although negative views of Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir existed long before Sarkar put pen to paper, it was the History of Aurangzib that established the dominant framework through which the emperor has been understood and judged in the modern period. Anyone wishing to contest Sarkar’s views had to go back into a dense archiveFootnote 7 and be willing to enter the increasingly bitter polemic around ‘Alamgir, which has only grown more contentious in recent decades. Most post-Sarkar scholars of the Mughal Empire have tended to tiptoe gingerly around this last Mughal king (see Appendix A), reinforcing Sarkar’s stranglehold over the study of Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir and his reign and essentially abandoning it to popular historians and untrained laypeople who often simply recirculate Sarkar’s views. My aim in writing this book is to offer the reader a fresh interpretation of Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir and the Mughal Empire in the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. The book is grounded in a rereading of historical sources, some well known, others barely or never utilized. It also incorporates and builds upon other recent scholarship focused on the general period.
A Thumbnail Sketch of the Mughal Dynasty and Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir
The Mughal Empire was founded by Emperor Babur (r. 1526–1530) after he invaded northern India from Kabul and defeated various Afghan and Rajput opponents. Despite a rocky start, including the collapse of the empire in the 1540s and early 1550s, Babur’s grandson Akbar consolidated the empire’s hold over northern and central South Asia through extensive military campaigns and transformative administrative reforms. Akbar was succeeded by his sole surviving son, Emperor Jahangir (r. 1605–1628), who built on many of his father’s achievements. Jahangir was followed by his third son, Emperor Shah Jahan (r. 1628–1658). At the end of Shah Jahan’s reign the empire was secure and prosperous, with a rich political and cultural milieu that was the envy of the eastern Islamic world. Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir was born to Prince Khurram (later Shah Jahan) and his wife Arjumand Banu (later Mumtaz Mahal, d. 1631) in 1618. Like his father, he was a third son. ‘Alamgir became the sixth emperor of the Mughal dynasty.Footnote 8
In 1634, when he turned sixteen, Prince Aurangzeb was granted adult status; a few years later he contracted his first marriage. Three more marriages and a total of nine children – five sons, four daughters – followed. Between 1635 and 1657 Aurangzeb was an actively rotated governor-prince. He served in the Deccan twice, in Gujarat, and in Multan. He also led some of the biggest military campaigns of his father’s reign, in Bundelkhand, Balkh, against the Safavid-held fortress of Qandahar (twice), and the Deccan. After 1635, barring a short period in 1644–1645 (when he was under house arrest), Aurangzeb mostly lived away from the Mughal court, largely because of growing political rivalries, first with his oldest brother Dara Shukoh (d. 1659), Shah Jahan’s favorite son, and then, in the 1650s, with his father as well.
In 1657 rumors reached Aurangzeb in the Deccan that Shah Jahan had died, or was already dead, or was too ill to rule and had passed the imperial torch to Dara Shukoh. Aurangzeb (along with his brothers, Shuja‘ and Murad, then governors of Bengal and Gujarat, respectively) sprang into action, marching north to Agra to fight for the throne. The now-recovered Shah Jahan sent several armies to crush his rebellious sons. Aurangzeb, at first operating jointly with Murad, defeated these armies, then turned on Murad and imprisoned him. Aurangzeb then forced his father to abdicate and crowned himself Emperor ‘Alamgir. Over the next few years he defeated his remaining princely rivals, Dara Shukoh and Shuja‘, and slowly consolidated his hold on the empire. In the subsequent decades ‘Alamgir was an industrious emperor who enacted wide-ranging administrative reforms and engaged in active military expansionism. The empire he presided over grew richer, thanks both to his efforts and to South Asia’s central place in an emerging late seventeenth-century global economy.
In the early 1680s ‘Alamgir set his sights on absorbing the Deccan into the Mughal Empire. It was a region the Mughals had long coveted and had been an object of his military ambitions in the 1650s. In 1686 and 1687 he conquered Bijapur and Golkonda, the last of the Deccan’s independent kingdoms, but these conquests were never fully secured, and he faced continued rebellion from the region’s population for the remainder of his reign. By 1707, when ‘Alamgir died at eighty-eight, he had strained the imperial treasury, presided over the near collapse of the Mughal war machine, witnessed a precipitous decline in imperial morale, brought untold misery to both friends and foes, and allowed political and administrative conditions in the empire’s northern heartlands to deteriorate. The severity of what ‘Alamgir unleashed on the Mughal Empire is apparent in his heirs’ inability to turn the empire’s fortunes around. Within two decades of his death, large chunks of the empire had broken away, and what remained was only barely controlled. The sack of Shahjahanabad in 1739 by the Iranian invader Nadir Shah and the carting away of huge amounts of wealth (including the famed Peacock Throne) marked the point of no return for the once-great empire. Although the Mughals clung to power in Delhi for over a century, they did so at the sufferance of others, despite claiming the mantle of imperial rulership. The British finally dispensed with this fiction in 1857 after crushing a bloody revolt that used the last Mughal emperor, Bahadur Shah II, who was suffering from age-related dementia at the time, as its figurehead.
The Arguments of the Book
This book aims to dislodge the most entrenched scholarly and popular views of ‘Alamgir, which either write him off as a hopeless bigot or extol him as a Muslim hero. I offer a fresh perspective on the role of Islam in ‘Alamgir’s life and reign (Chapter 2), arguing that he drew on Islam-inspired solutions to run the Mughal Empire, not because he aimed at wholesale conversion or religious cleansing of non-Muslims, but because they offered him a moral framework for rulership. ‘Alamgir’s personal devotion to Islam underpinned his long decades of rule over a large and diverse empire, supporting him into old age and a deepening military quagmire in the Deccan. He hoped that Islamic values and regulations would help combat rising social disorder, improve imperial administration, overcome financial weakness, and inspire his subjects to share the devotion to imperial service that he modeled. Success in integrating Islamic values, ‘Alamgir believed, would benefit all his subjects, regardless of religion, and place the empire on firmer foundations. At once pious and pragmatic – a fact often lost in doctrinaire and dogmatic depictions – he changed course and adjusted when confronted with evidence that Islam-inspired solutions hobbled his ability to rule. Moreover, as a Mughal ruler he was as much shaped by and loyal to Timurid and Universal–Indic sovereign expressions as to Islam (Chapter 2). A hyperfocus on Islam ignores all these other facts about Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir, casts a veil over our historical understanding of him, and plays into modern polemics about religion.
This book counters another persistent belief: that Aurangzeb did not deserve the Mughal throne, but stole it either from his aging and unsuspecting father Shah Jahan or his hapless humanist older brother Dara Shukoh (see Chapter 1). This conviction has perpetuated a portrayal, both scholarly and popular, of Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir as a devious, cunning, and bloodthirsty regicide and fratricide. By contrast, I lay out the decades-long backdrop of efforts by Prince Aurangzeb to prepare for an anticipated future war of succession. It is a theme I first explored in my 2012 book, Princes of the Mughal Empire, in which I argued that Akbar’s decision in the 1580s to move away from an appanage system (giving princes fixed territories to rule, often for life) created an expectation that princes would fight each other to be the next emperor of an undivided empire. In the dog-eat-dog world of post-1580s Mughal succession politics, therefore, Aurangzeb’s actions were unexceptional and reflected similar maneuvers by his own father Shah Jahan and grandfather Jahangir. The first chapter of this book offers a detailed account of how Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir attained the throne, showing a meritocratic system of succession that valued stamina and strong leadership in the face of constant challenges. As a prince, Aurangzeb built support networks across the empire, constructed powerful households that could administer regions and be mobilized to fight on his command, raised money to support his undertakings, and – in this still-expanding empire – established a reputation for administrative expertise and military competence. Aurangzeb had an acute sense of what it took to mount a successful bid for the Mughal throne, and worked to succeed at these tasks in the face of considerable odds.
This book’s third major argument is that ‘Alamgir depended heavily, and significantly more than previous emperors, on the Mughal institutions of the imperial harem (Chapter 3) and the eunuchate (Chapter 4) to buttress his power and influence, thus marking his own reign and also transforming these institutions. The harem and eunuchate played especially important roles in the final years of ‘Alamgir’s long reign. These institutions have been largely overlooked, especially in ‘Alamgir’s reign, because they are barely evident in the archival sources that historians have relied on, mainly contemporary Persian-language histories written by individuals either connected to Mughal power or close to the court. These sources reproduced the patriarchal mores of the times, ignoring or dismissing evidence of ‘Alamgir’s reliance on women and eunuchs. For their part, women and eunuchs rarely put into print their activities, opinions, and roles, as that would go against social norms and etiquette. Between the blindness of the contemporary chroniclers and the self-effacement of women and eunuchs, these groups and the institutions they peopled and built appear only fleetingly in Persian historical narratives. Furthermore, the full story of how entwined the harem and eunuchate were with ‘Alamgir’s rulership does not resonate at all with misplaced modern-day expectations of him. He is remembered as a devout Muslim and thus unlikely to see women as crucial political allies. Nor would this paper-Muslim ‘Alamgir have embraced eunuchs, given Islamic law’s disapproval of them. Yet the historical record (especially the period’s administrative archives) suggests otherwise. It would be going too far to claim that the harem and eunuchate became co-rulers with ‘Alamgir, but his dependence on them certainly increased as he aged. This enabled their power and influence to survive him into the first decades of the eighteenth century.
A thread that runs through the entire book is the suggestion that Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir represented a departure from previous emperors in areas that have been overlooked, and that he resembled previous emperors in areas where he was thought to have been different. This book highlights four ways in which his divergence from previous emperors has been overlooked: his undermining of the princely institution; his undermining of the empire’s military reputation and administrative effectiveness (despite his own earlier successes); his enabling of and reliance on the imperial harem and eunuchate; and his empowering of nobles. The book also demonstrates two important areas in which he continued in the manner of previous emperors, despite the popular impression that he departed from them: the role afforded Islam during his reign; and the style and character of Mughal courtly culture. What happened to the emperor’s princely heirs offers an excellent starting point. Where every Mughal emperor after Akbar had to deal with rebellious sons in the final years of his reign, ‘Alamgir successfully contained the political ambitions of his sons after an abortive 1681 rebellion by his fourth son, Prince Akbar. What makes ‘Alamgir’s achievement so striking is that he accomplished this despite extreme old age and military failure. How did he manage it? I argue that he did so by playing off sons against sons, sons against grandsons, bolstering loyalists within the Mughal nobility, strengthening the imperial harem and eunuchate, forging an ascetic–renunciate sovereignty that none of his sons could compete with, and mostly leaving his male heirs to their own devices when they began to experience cash-flow problems toward the end of his reign (see Chapters 2, 3, 4, and 5). The Mughal princely institution never recovered its pre-1658 dynamism or its capacity to cause a sitting emperor serious trouble. As Mughal princes became less powerful, the opposite happened to the imperial harem and eunuchate (Chapters 3 and 4), and sections of the Mughal nobility (Chapters 2 and 3). Although the history of the nobility in ‘Alamgir’s reign and the post-1707 period has been well documented,Footnote 9 the same is not true for the imperial harem or the eunuchate that worked to protect the empire, often in opposition to emboldened factions of imperial nobles. To best understand this eighteenth-century story, one must go back to the tectonic shifts unleashed during ‘Alamgir’s reign.
Another area in which ‘Alamgir had a transformative impact was his non-stop campaigning in the Deccan (c. 1682–1707), which eventually also compromised Mughal control over northern India. Although ‘Alamgir enjoyed some important initial victories, the Mughals ultimately failed to consolidate their control over the region. From the point of view of military campaigns, Aurangzeb was a triumphant Mughal prince; but as ‘Alamgir, he was a failed imperialist: where previous emperors’ military setbacks did not compromise the empire, ‘Alamgir’s military setbacks ultimately collapsed it (an outcome partly his own doing, and partly the effect of broader political and economic currents). ‘Alamgir’s ultimate impact on the empire was disastrous both in terms of men and matériel expended and the collapse of imperial prestige, morale, governance, and finances. Although the Mughals had faced challenges stabilizing the empire’s southern frontiers since the 1590s, at no point did these raise questions about their ability to rule their North Indian heartlands. This was not true after the 1680s. Like a spreading cancer, the failed Deccan campaigns had a negative impact on the entire empire (see Chapters 2 and 5). ‘Alamgir’s desperation to win in the Deccan not only distracted him from adequately administering northern India, but it also led him to bend longstanding administrative norms – especially around the mansabdari and jagirdari systems – to support the war effort in the south. This ended up corroding imperial authority everywhere, to catastrophic effect (Chapter 2). ‘Alamgir’s successors found it impossible to stop the rot and reconstitute the empire as it had existed prior to the 1680s. Mughal failure in the Deccan had another key consequence: it strengthened the empire’s opponents, particularly the Marathas (see Chapter 5), who played a leading role in the destruction of the empire following ‘Alamgir’s death.
Significantly, in one area where many readers might expect ‘Alamgir to have had a transformative impact – namely, around religious issues and Islam’s role in the empire – this was not so. Although he made serious efforts to infuse an Islam-inflected ethos and morality into his personal presentation and that of his family, the imperial court, and ways in which the empire was governed (see Chapter 2), this mostly dissipated after his death. His imperial successors turned their backs on this idiosyncratic and highly personalized reformist project, which they could not or did not want to adopt (see Chapter 6). Similarly, many of ‘Alamgir’s attempts to change Mughal courtly culture – by, for example, discouraging certain forms of financial ostentation and “inappropriate” dressing styles or encouraging better etiquette or greater personal discipline – had no lasting impact. ‘Alamgir is far less exceptional than mainstream portrayals tend to portray him. Like his predecessors he was intolerant of sectarianism, uninterested in forcing Islam on his subjects, focused on protecting his imperial prerogatives, committed to upholding social status and lineage, and invested in military expansionism, good governance, law and justice, and sacred kingship (see Chapter 2). These were all longstanding features of Mughal rulership and the Mughal sovereign tradition. Even when ‘Alamgir distanced himself from previous behaviors – such as in his choice to dress more austerely, shut down certain kinds of cultural patronage, and stop participating in imperial rituals such as jharoka darshan (royal presentation) and wazn/tuladan (royal weighing) and celebrating non-Islamic holidays such as Nawruz – his heirs continued all these longstanding Mughal customs. In most instances he made no efforts to prohibit them from doing so (see Chapter 2). In sum, ‘Alamgir’s reign did not strike the discordant note for his contemporaries that generations of modern historians have assumed it did.
A second and final thread running through this book is the claim that ‘Alamgir’s reign is most usefully and accurately understood as transitional in the chronological record. Although historians always place it in the Mughal “high period” (1526–1707) rather than the era of Mughal decline/decentralization/collapse (1707–1857), it shares important characteristics with both. Indeed, it has more in common with the latter than has been appreciated. Prior to the onset of the Deccan campaigns (1682) the empire was relatively well ordered; its rules and regulations were followed more often than not; it was at the center of the political imagination of most politically ambitious individuals and groups in North India; and was generally able to impose its writ on its opponents. But all of these characteristics receded in the final decades of ‘Alamgir’s reign.Footnote 10 By the end of his life the empire more closely resembled that of the 1710s than it did the empire pre-1682, let alone pre-1658. A key feature shaping this transitional nature of ‘Alamgir’s reign is the impact on the Mughal Empire of new, rapidly rising forms of wealth due to the influx of New World gold and silver and the emergence of a truly global economy in the seventeenth century. Starting in the 1630s and 1640s, under Emperor Shah Jahan, the empire began to see the first signs of empowered merchant and banking classes, the commercialization of religious life, vibrant commercial towns, emergent public spheres, and expectations among the population of improved justice and better governance. These trends intensified across ‘Alamgir’s reign.Footnote 11 However, instead of strengthening the empire (by fortifying its tax base, for example), some of these forces, particularly the rise of regional contenders supported by increasingly globally connected and post-Mughal bankers and merchants, contributed to its destruction in the post-1707 period.Footnote 12
Note on Sources
This book draws on a large, mostly Persian-language, archive. It includes officially sanctioned and privately written histories, administrative records, traveler accounts, hagiographies, biographical dictionaries, local and regional histories, collections of imperial and noble correspondence, and miniatures. But it owes a special debt to two and, to date, barely utilized Persian-language collections: the Akhbarat-i Darbar-i Mu‘alla (News Bulletins of the Exalted Court or, as S. R. Sharma preferred to call them, Minutes of the Proceedings of the Mughal Emperor in CourtFootnote 13), and the now defunct Dastawizat (Az ‘Ahd-i Mughaliya) (Documents from the Mughal Era). Without them, this book would have been unable to challenge many of the overcomplicated and mistaken plotlines that dominate our understanding of Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir and the Mughal Empire in the seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries or to offer fresh lines of inquiry around, among others, the imperial harem or the eunuchate. For more about these extraordinary collections, see Appendix B.
Structure of the Book
This book has three parts, each with two chapters. Part I – offering a fresh assessment of Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir’s career as a prince and then emperor – follows a broadly chronological format. Part II – which deals with two key institutions of ‘Alamgir’s reign, the imperial harem and the eunuchate – is thematically structured. Part III focuses on the final weeks of ‘Alamgir’s life and then on posthumous efforts to memorialize him. I use this hybrid format so that this book is not mistaken for a conventional biography: it does not recount all known details of Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir’s life, nor does it delve into his psychology. I also use it to allow the reader to select whichever chapter they wish to read first. Each chapter stands alone. The intended effect is to retell the story of Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir, offering new understandings and challenging stale and misguided misconceptions, while also highlighting little-known areas of research and foregrounding new archives (especially the Akhbarat).
Chapter 1 examines how the intense political competition linked to Mughal succession practices framed ‘Alamgir’s princely life. The central assertion is that Prince Aurangzeb engaged in decades-long efforts to build empire-wide support networks, construct a princely household, gather wealth, and prove himself a formidable administrator and general. Although he faced many challenges along the way, including occasional military and administrative setbacks and rising tensions with Shah Jahan and Dara Shukoh, he was a formidable opponent. At the heart of his success – this chapter argues – was an inclusive leadership style that cultivated loyalty in his personal household, the spaces around him, and across the empire. Ultimately, he was well positioned to mount a bid for the Mughal throne in September 1657 when he first heard that his father was seriously ill and might even be dead.
Chapter 2 uses the twin rubrics of “state” and “sovereignty” to understand many of the most important or controversial aspects of ‘Alamgir’s forty-nine-year reign. It foregrounds the ways the empire sought to recalibrate itself in the decades following ‘Alamgir’s accession in 1658. Although he mostly positioned himself as a typical Mughal emperor in terms of his sovereign self-expression, he also articulated an innovative ascetic–renunciate sovereignty that radiated from his person to the court and empire in distinctive ways. Ultimately, his decision to invade the Deccan in the early 1680s proved his and the Mughal Empire’s undoing. Not only did he fail to anchor Mughal rule in peninsular India, but he also could not stop the gradual degradation of imperial institutions in the northern imperial heartlands. Against this backdrop, and for the duration of what is still a Methuselah-like lifespan, ‘Alamgir held on to his throne. How did he do so? This chapter ends by arguing that his emergence as a particular kind of Mughal “saint–emperor” was one of the key factors in his political survival.
Part II concentrates on two key imperial institutions that deepen our understanding of ‘Alamgir’s reign and the period. The emergence of Prince Aurangzeb’s princely harem and his relationship, as emperor, with the imperial harem is the subject of Chapter 3. In evaluating the former, I examine Aurangzeb’s marriages, rivalries between his senior wives, and the ways his harem was buffeted by his shifting political fortunes. Post-1658, the focus shifts to how ‘Alamgir asserted his control over the imperial harem, his dependence on his sisters (first Roshanara, then Jahanara), the harem’s role in safeguarding the biological continuity of the dynasty and healing old political wounds, the rise of dissent within the harem in the late 1670s and early 1680s, and the remarkable career of ‘Alamgir’s daughter Zinat al-Nisa. By the end of her father’s reign Zinat al-Nisa was likely the second-most-powerful person in the empire and a key political and financial buttress of ‘Alamgir’s power. The final section examines an extraordinary moment in Mughal history, the only time the imperial harem was split, with one section in the Deccan with ‘Alamgir and the other in Shahjahanabad/Delhi, where it anchored imperial authority in the city, contributed to a lively cultural scene, and acted as a beacon for a possible return of the imperial court to northern India once ‘Alamgir passed away.
The imperial eunuchate is the subject of the fourth chapter. I begin by looking at the place of eunuchs in the life of the empire prior to 1658, then examine the rising presence of eunuchs in Aurangzeb’s princely household and their central role in helping ‘Alamgir consolidate his power post-1658. Despite ‘Alamgir’s concerns about the creation of and trade in eunuchs, he appreciated the strength and usefulness of the imperial eunuchate and encouraged its growing power. This chapter also evaluates Khidmatgar Khan III, possibly the most powerful eunuch in Mughal history and the head of the imperial eunuchate from the early 1690s to his death in 1704. Such power did not come without resistance from uncastrated men jealous of the eunuchate’s wealth and power. This included ‘Alamgir himself, who, despite heavy dependence on imperial eunuchs, tried to maintain some checks on them, even if these weakened toward the end of his life.
Part III focuses on the end of ‘Alamgir’s reign and its aftermath. Chapter 5 uses the Akhbarat to explore the final two weeks of ‘Alamgir’s life, highlighting various topics and characters (some important, others minor) to illustrate daily life at court and to offer longer perspectives on ‘Alamgir’s life and reign. There are sections devoted to the relationship between ‘Alamgir and his three surviving sons; the tensions between his sons and grandsons; the impoverishment of the Mughal nobility; the biographies of some of his favorite nobles as well as of his last surviving wife (Udaipuri Mahal); conversion to Islam at the Mughal court; and the struggle against the Marathas. Other sections highlight ‘Alamgir’s physical and mental frailties; his work ethic; his interest in intelligence gathering; and the deep sense of personal failure and recrimination that hung over his final decade. Together these stories offer insights into ‘Alamgir, the court, and the empire on the cusp of a new era that everyone feared might be even less settled than the one that was ending.
Chapter 6 examines a remarkable effort to memorialize ‘Alamgir in the decades after his death. This was an unprecedented effort in Mughal history: no other emperor, not even Akbar, was eulogized with the same intensity and for as long. In its early stages this project was led by a small group of noble ‘Alamgir loyalists mostly based at the Mughal court. In time, however, the effort extended to other parts of the former empire as well as, unexpectedly, to groups that had either been only nominally under Mughal rule or had actively opposed it. The end product was a rich trove of histories, administrative manuals, collections of orders and letters, and miniatures depicting ‘Alamgir. Although the participants’ motivations varied, the results point to a broad consensus about his greatness across much of northern and central India. As we contemplate ‘Alamgir’s vilification today, it is worth remembering the widely divergent views of many of his contemporaries or near contemporaries. As we ask why, it becomes imperative to recall and reflect on this forgotten story. Ultimately, this book does not seek to excoriate or to exonerate Aurangzeb ‘Alamgir. Rather, it seeks to reconsider existing stories and tell new ones, thus intervening in ways that might allow us to probe and, perhaps, transcend the polarization that inevitably accompanies any conversation about this important historical figure and his times.
