‘Shared care in mental health is now a policy imperative in England and Wales, yet its meaning … [is] … still open to debate’. Dr Lester's opening line says it all (Lester, 2005, this issue). We're all in favour of it, but none of us is exactly sure what it is. Ambiguity is considered a failing in academic publications and, under pressure from editors, we usually excise the unnecessary and unclear. Politicians, however, often deliberately insert ambiguity, as it allows scope for interpretation. By a simple shift in emphasis, either shared care's achievement can be claimed as a manifesto success or slow progress towards it can be cited to justify further targets.