With empathy under reevaluation, this study analyzes its place at the beginnings of the Jesus movement. As a capacity to resonate with the condition of another, “empathy” entails vicariously feeling or acting as though their situation is one’s own. Related concepts in antiquity, more often under the terminology of sympatheia (συμπάθεια) and cognates, concern interactions between body, soul, and cosmos. In this context, the Apostle Paul 1) formulated the cosmic significance of Christ’s empathetic embrace of human suffering; 2) urged humans, in turn, to embody Christ’s death and resurrection as their own; and 3) conceptualized the community as Christ’s body, empathetically uniting individuals and the creation itself. Hebrews adds a cognitive dimension: Christ’s experience of human suffering enables him to aid them in their own suffering, and members of the community should each imagine themselves in place of the other. Finally, Matthew identifies Christ as “the least of these,” making compassion toward him the basis for apocalyptic judgment.