If you have been asked to review for the Journal of Dairy Research, it means that an editor believes you are likely to have relevant expertise and knowledge in the discipline of the manuscript, or at least for some component of the manuscript in the case of multi-disciplinary studies. We have approached you to exploit your scientific expertise in the discipline, not for your potential as an editor of the manuscript.
We want to make the peer-review process more effective and easier for those who give up their time to review, and we want some flexibility in the coverage that reviewers can provide for each manuscript. Not every reviewer needs to comment on every aspect of every paper.
To make more effective use of reviewers’ time, we are changing the review report format to enable a reviewer to clearly (and guilt-free) specify those areas of a manuscript that they haven’t assessed, whether from lack of time or because it is out of their comfort zone.
We would like reviewers to assess the following three aspects of the manuscript.
1) Internal validity: This term is generally used to describe the extent to which relationships between outcome and explanatory variables (dependent and independent variables) have been demonstrated. More broadly (including simple, descriptive studies as well), it is the extent to which the study has been conducted rigorously and documented with high fidelity.
2) External validity: Here we are interested to know whether any generalisations that the authors make from the study are relevant to any scenario outside the very specific circumstances of the study they describe.
3) Novelty and innovation: contribution to the discipline: We need experts to assess whether the manuscript is (or could be) a useful contribution to knowledge in the discipline. This is one of the more difficult things for the editors to assess, as it is dependent on expert knowledge of the state of the art and the body of literature. The Journal of Dairy Research is rather oriented to applied than theoretical science and novelty is not as highly weighted as a basic science journal. We recognise the need to replicate studies, particularly where there is some degree of uncertainty about the expected findings. However, there are some subjects that really don’t need revisiting, or would need a strong justification to revisit.
4) Ethical compliance: The editorial team follows procedures to identify papers with potential ethical problems so they are not sent out to review, but inevitably some issues will only be detected by people who are active in the discipline. Are there any ethical aspects of the paper that concern you? This could include evidence of plagiarism, manipulation of images, inappropriate use of personal or unattributed use of public data or resources, animal welfare, human ethical permissions, potential data misuse.
We do not ask you to provide feedback on the following.
1) Expression and grammar: There is no need to spend time recommending changes to expression. Please point out where the text is ambiguous or unintelligible, but do not feel obliged to correct grammar and expression. If a sentence doesn’t make sense to you and you think it might be incorrect but can’t tell from the way it is expressed, just flag it up as potentially confusing or wrong. All manuscripts will be checked by an editor before acceptance and again before publication. We make limited edits at those stages, not to apply a consistent journal style of writing, but to make sure that the meaning of statements is clear and we reduce the number of errors.
2) Formatting: As with expression and grammar, we don’t expect reviewers to refer in detail to our instructions for authors and style guide. Only comment on formatting where something is a clear departure from convention, or where it is difficult to understand.