We partner with a secure submission system to handle manuscript submissions.
Please note:
You will need an account for the submission system, which is separate to your Cambridge Core account. For login and submission support, please visit the
submission and support pages.
Please review this journal's author instructions, particularly the
preparing your materials
page, before submitting your manuscript.
Click Proceed to submission system to continue to our partner's website.
To save this undefined to your undefined account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you used this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your undefined account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
The targeting of healthcare facilities during conflicts contravenes international humanitarian laws and exacerbates humanitarian crises. In Syria, the systematic attacks on medical facilities have not only led to direct casualties but have also crippled the healthcare system, further intensifying the civil strife.
Objectives:
This study aims to elucidate the patterns and impacts of attacks on medical facilities and hospitals in Syria, employing a robust multi-dimensional statistical analysis to assess the extent and implications of these attacks on healthcare infrastructure and societal well-being.
Method/Description:
Utilizing data collected by the White Helmets from 2016 to 2021, the authors analyzed the basic demographic variables as attack frequency, types, and geographical distribution of the attacks, alongside the responsible perpetrators as well as damage outcome variables as injuries and death. The statistical correlation between damage outcomes and attack frequency was also analyzed.
Results/Outcomes:
This comprehensive analysis identifies Idlib (n=78, 47%) and Aleppo (n=51, 31%) as the regions most frequently targeted by attacks, with the primary method being airstrikes (n=96, 58%). Artillery shelling and barrel bombs are also prevalent (n=22, 13% and n=20, 12%, respectively). Statistical assessments show a robust correlation between the frequency of attacks and the total number of injuries, with a Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.956 (p<0.01), underscoring the direct impact on civilian casualties. The primary perpetrators were found to be Syrian (n=88, 53%) and Russian forces (n=70, 42%), indicating a systematic approach to targeting medical facilities.
Conclusion:
The data underscores an urgent need for international action to enforce accountability and protect healthcare in conflict zones.
The digitalization of the humanitarian sector promises to enable swifter and more efficient aid delivery. However, as humanitarian organizations (HOs) increasingly rely on digital technologies, they become more vulnerable to cyber threats. This vulnerability was highlighted by the data breach suffered by the International Committee of the Red Cross in 2022, and the cyberattacks during the conflicts in Ukraine and the Gaza Strip. Unfortunately, despite HOs recognizing the importance of implementing strategies to mitigate the impact of potential cyber incidents, these often face both academic and practical limitations, as they are primarily designed for private companies.
Objectives:
This study aims to identify cyber threats, challenges and gaps in current strategies reported by the literature to provide recommendations for strengthening cybersecurity strategies tailored to the unique needs and characteristics of HOs.
Method/Description:
This study presents the results of a comprehensive review that maps existing threats and challenges associated with the digitalization of humanitarian aid delivery, as well as the current cyber preparedness, response and communication strategies employed by HOs.
Results/Outcomes:
Our results reveal a range of cyber threats and challenges faced by HOs and show a notable lack of preparedness, response, and communication strategies to address these threats.
Conclusion:
The absence of comprehensive strategies underscores the need for further research and the development of tailored solutions to strengthen cybersecurity within the humanitarian sector. HOs must draw lessons from other sectors and implement robust preparedness and response strategies to mitigate the impact of potential cyber incidents, ensuring the protection of victims and the organizations’ reputations.
The 2024 Noto Peninsula earthquake highlighted the challenges of maintaining effective Early Warning, Alert, and Response Systems (EWARS) during emergencies and disasters. Key issues include damaged reporting capacities of local health facilities, the need to collect data from temporary facilities such as evacuation centers, analyzing data under emergency conditions and implementing on-site infection prevention and control measures.
Objectives:
This report reviews the successful joint operation of Emergency Medical Teams (EMT), Field Epidemiology Training Programs (FETP), and Public Health Rapid Response Teams (PHRRT) during the earthquake.
Method/Description:
Findings were consolidated by joint after-action review.
Results/Outcomes:
National EMTs such as Disaster Medical Assistance Team (DMAT) reported data on infectious diseases to the EMT Coordination Cell (EMTCC) using the J-SPEED system, which is compatible with the WHO EMT Minimum Data Set (MDS). The robust logistics capacity of EMTs allowed effective data collection from remote and ad hoc facilities. The J-SPEED Analysis Support Team at the EMTCC shared this data with the FETP. Experts from FETP analyzed the data, identifying cases requiring intervention and successfully triggered targeted infection prevention and control measures implemented by PHRRTs specifically Disaster Infection Control Team (DICT).
Conclusion:
The joint operation demonstrated that EMTs can effectively function as ad hoc sentinels within national EWARS. The integration of EMT data with FETP analysis and targeted interventions by PHRRTs proved successful, offering a valuable model for future emergency responses globally.
In February 2024, the Philippine Emergency Medical Assistance Team (PEMAT), specializing in mass casualty incidents and rapid medical response, actively engaged in a comprehensive emergency preparedness exercise at Daniel Z. Romualdez Airport (DZR).
Objectives:
Along with various response teams, this simulation assesses PEMAT’s management and capacity-building skills, with specific emphasis on the team’s efficiency in organizing emergency medical response, triage, treatment, and collaboration.
Method/Description:
Before the simulation, PEMAT conducted a mass casualty management orientation and tabletop exercises for all participating teams. The Office of Civil Defense (OCD) was in charge of evaluating the drill’s overall organization, communication, and rapid execution. During the drill, PEMAT oversaw triage and treatment operations from an advanced medical station, encompassing a variety of realistic scenarios.
Results/Outcomes:
As a result, PEMAT established a legal framework for collaboration among emergency response teams in Tacloban, thereby fostering an unstructured approach to disaster response. PEMAT demonstrated its capacity to manage mass casualty incidents by showcasing its abilities in assessment, intervention, and management. The simulation revealed that the respondents displayed a strong knowledge base. However, this emphasized the importance of continuous training and refining skills, especially in managing mass casualties, to achieve the optimal level of preparedness.
Conclusion:
The simulation revealed useful insights for enhancing resource allocation and communication protocols in high-pressure scenarios. In conclusion, the PEMAT exercise underscored the vital necessity of continuous training and skill development to guarantee effective disaster response. By incorporating these insights into future training, emergency responders can further improve their readiness and coordination during mass casualty incidents.
In May 2024, German EMTs ASB, Cadus, Humedica and Johanniter conducted a joint disaster response field exercise including a Cholera outbreak scenario. The RRML CIBU (Cellule d’Intervention Biologique d’Urgence) from Institut Pasteur, France, embedded in an EMT, supported the exercise. Amateur actors presented injuries and cases of acute watery diarrhea with different levels of severity. Dummy samples were collected and transported to the RRML for analysis. An external IPC-Team from the German Robert Koch Institute conducted facility assessments to provide Cholera-specific IPC advice and training.
Objectives:
To assess
1. the implementation of Cholera-specific IPC measures.
2. the need for and benefit of external IPC support.
3. the interoperability between EMTs and RRML.
Method/Description:
Qualitative evaluation through observation and interviews.
Results/Outcomes:
All EMTs (n=4) had access to IPC guidelines and personal protective equipment (PPE) and implemented active screening for signs of infection (n=4). 75% (n=3) of the EMTs actively isolated suspected cholera cases. EMTs underlined the benefit of external IPC support (n=3) and training provided (n=4). 48 EMT staff were trained in donning/doffing of PPE and management of spill events. The RRML provided transport material and training on packaging of samples. Occasional contamination of the outer packaging and incorrectly filled-in lab forms were reported. Sample transport was aligned to lab schedule.
Conclusion:
The EMTs adapted competently to the Cholera scenario. Interoperability with the RRML was satisfying. The IPC team was seen as important support. Lessons learned included the need for improved isolation precautions, packaging of samples and completion of lab forms.
Rapid Response Mobile Laboratories (RRMLs) are essential for providing timely diagnostics support to affected populations in crisis situations. Recognizing their critical role, the WHO Regional Office for Europe initiated the RRML Initiative in 2018, driven by European partner institutions of the Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network (GOARN).
Objectives:
To enhance coordination and interoperability with the Global Health Emergency Corps (GHEC) partners, the RRML initiative transitioned to a global level in 2024, led by the GOARN Strategic Group for Diagnostic Surge Capacities (DiSC). This transition aimed to establish common standards for RRMLs and develop strategies to deliver quality and predictable diagnostic services to affected populations.
Method/Description:
The DiSC group focused on defining operational standards for RRMLs, outlining future strategic directions, and creating operational plans. Additionally, the group sought to strengthen collaboration between RRMLs and Emergency Medical Teams (EMTs) by serving as a platform for sharing best practices and information exchange.
Results/Outcomes:
The DiSC established a clear leadership structure and coordination mechanisms to facilitate collaboration with GHEC partners (including EMTs), underpinned by standardized operating procedures and workforce development initiatives, including an RRML recognition system. To enhance information sharing and operational efficiency, DiSC integrated its capabilities into the Knowledge and Information Management in Emergency Platform (KIMEP), a digital tool designed for streamlining coordination in the field.
Conclusion:
By establishing the DiSC structure under GOARN leadership and leveraging the KIMEP platform, the RRML initiative has significantly improved information exchange, coordination, and interoperability with EMTs partners throughout the emergency management lifecycle.
Integrating military and civilian capabilities in emergency medical teams (EMTs) is underexplored in Poland. Enhanced coordination between these sectors can significantly improve EMT development and deployment, aligning with international guidelines and adapting to Poland’s specific context.
Objectives:
The primary objectives are to develop policies for seamless civil-military collaboration in EMT operations, establish universally recognized and locally relevant standards, enhance EMT capabilities through joint training programs, implement rapid mobilization and effective coordination strategies, and create interoperable systems for coordination between EMTs and other rapid response capacities.
Method/Description:
This study employs a multi-faceted approach, including developing joint protocols and communication channels for civil-military coordination, aligning with WHO guidelines while adapting to local needs. It establishes benchmarks for consistency and quality across military and civilian EMTs. Joint training programs focus on skill development, operational coordination, and cultural competence. Agile strategies for rapid mobilization and joint operational plans are designed. Interoperable systems for effective coordination and resource sharing between EMTs and other rapid response teams are developed.
Results/Outcomes:
The approach facilitates more efficient EMT deployments, enhances operational consistency through standardized protocols, builds competent responders through training, improves rapid response capabilities, and optimizes resource utilization through seamless coordination and interoperability.
Conclusion:
Leveraging civil-military collaboration can significantly enhance Poland’s EMT capabilities. By focusing on policy innovation, standard setting, capacity building, emergency response, and interoperability, Poland can establish a robust and integrated emergency response framework. This vision strengthens national capabilities and sets a precedent for harmonizing civil and military efforts in emergency medical response globally.
Disasters strain coordination efforts between groups. Interoperability is best assessed while in process, but retrospective analysis can also illuminate problems and identify solutions. COVID-19 created an international public health crisis that required civilian-military response in many locations, creating an opportunity to evaluate interoperability of multiple international systems at a single moment in time confronting a single crisis.
Objectives:
This project uses three published interoperability models to identify interoperability activities during the COVID-19 pandemic. That data was then utilized to assess the interoperability effectiveness. The data was also utilized to develop a framework for assessing a group’s current interoperability and assist with improvement goals.
Method/Description:
Papers on civilian-military interoperability during COVID-19 were identified utilizing a search of medical literature. They were then assessed using three interoperability models: Joint Emergency Services Interoperability Program (JESIP), Organizational Interoperability Maturity Model (OIMM), and the Homeland Security Interoperability Continuum (HSIC).
Results/Outcomes:
Of the 48 articles discussing interoperability criteria, the most common coordination criteria were shared situational awareness, joint understanding of risk, and standard operating procedures. The least likely interoperability criteria seen during international civilian-military COVID-19 disaster responses were co-location, preparedness, shared technology, prior training exercises, and previous experience. Utilizing this data, a combined interoperability assessment model was created for organizations to utilize to evaluate and improve their current level of interoperability.
Conclusion:
Disaster focused organizations with different cultures yet potential future interactions should perform an initial interoperability self-assessment to determine their current level of coordination. They should then follow the next steps for improving interoperability before the next disaster strikes.
The Specialized Care Teams (SCTs) provide additional specialized care supporting an existing local facility or a type 2 or 3 EMTs. The “rescEU EMT” project, funded by European Union, currently under development, aims to become the largest field hospital globally, made of 21 capacities, including EMTs and SCTs. The EMT2-ITA Regione Piemonte is in charge to develop the ICU Truck-based (together with Germany), Portable CT Scan, Dialysis and Oxygen Supply (together with Portugal and Türkiye) SCTs. Even though the WHO is working to publish technical notes for SCTs, at the moment, very few documentation is available.
Objectives:
To describe the process of designing SCTs in a multi-national project.
Method/Description:
The working group was composed by medical doctors, nurses, engineers, technicians coming from the partner countries of the project. This multidisciplinary and multinational team carried out a 3-phase process: (1) a literature review searching for publications, international and national guidelines, legislations relevant for the SCTs under development; (2) the definition of standards of care and deployment’s policies for each SCTs; (3) a market survey to reach a realistic budget estimation and to investigate technologies, materials, and products.
Results/Outcomes:
The main result is the definition of the technical specifications for each SCT to be used during the next procurement phase. The main challenges were the tight deadlines, the harmonization of different medical practices and the level of the care to provide.
Conclusion:
This model can offer valuable guidance and can be applied by other teams involved in the development of SCTs.
The US National Disaster Medical System (NDMS) deploys specialized teams for acute trauma, pediatric care, mortuary services, and veterinary response to manage various disaster scenarios. These teams offer potential models for enhancing the WHO Emergency Medical Teams (EMT) program’s international humanitarian and disaster response capabilities.
Objectives:
This study analyzes the structure, effectiveness, and lessons from NDMS specialized teams, assessing their applicability to the WHO EMT program. It aims to provide recommendations for developing specialized teams for international disaster medical response.
Method/Description:
A comprehensive review of NDMS team deployments is conducted, focusing on organization, training, utilization, strategies, and outcomes. Data is collected from NDMS reports and debriefings. Comparative analysis identifies best practices and key lessons for the WHO EMT program.
Results/Outcomes:
Preliminary findings indicate that specialized teams effectively address specific disaster needs. Strengths include specialized training, rapid deployment, and targeted medical care. Lessons from NDMS emphasize the importance of specialized skills, interdisciplinary coordination, and flexible operations, enhancing generalized response capabilities. These insights support recommendations for the WHO EMT program to develop specialized teams for diverse humanitarian and disaster challenges.
Conclusion:
NDMS specialized teams provide a valuable model for the WHO EMT program. Adopting and adapting this model can enhance the WHO EMT program’s capacity to offer specialized support in international humanitarian and disaster medical responses. Developing trauma, pediatric, mortuary, and veterinary teams within the WHO EMT framework can improve global disaster response effectiveness and efficiency.
Past studies have raised the need for improvements in the Korea Disaster Relief Team (KDRT)'s communication and information management systems.
Objectives:
This study aims to develop guidelines to enhance the technological interoperability of KDRT medical teams, focusing on communication and information management systems at international disaster sites.
Method/Description:
A literature review and analysis of KDRT documentation and international research were conducted using PRISMA methodology. The study applied the Interoperability Continuum Framework’s five domains to assess and enhance KDRT’s technological capabilities. The PRISMA flow diagram was used to systematically identify, screen, and include relevant studies and documents.
Results/Outcomes:
From 17369 initial documents, 20 were included in the final qualitative synthesis. Key areas for improvement were identified:
1. Governance: Establish a robust structure for clear decision-making and coordination. Create an inter-agency committee and regularly review policies.
2. Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs): Develop and standardize SOPs aligned with WHO standards. Provide regular training for team members.
3. Technology: Integrate advanced communication systems for real-time data sharing. Utilize digital platforms for resource management. Regularly evaluate and update tools.
4. Training & Exercises: Implement comprehensive training programs, including joint exercises. Focus on real-life scenarios and new technologies. Conduct after-action reviews.
5. Usage: Ensure team proficiency in using guidelines and tools. Monitor effectiveness during deployments. Analyze data to improve practices.
Conclusion:
Implementing the proposed guidelines will enhance KDRT’s technological interoperability, streamline disaster response, and align with global standards. This will maximize life-saving interventions and improve crisis coordination, addressing current gaps and leveraging advanced technologies for efficient future disaster relief operations.