Caregivers play a pivotal role in shaping the nutritional health of young children and pets. Early feeding experiences influence future dietary preferences(1,2) and misguided feeding practice can have detrimental consequences for the health of children(3,4) and animals.(5–7) Despite evidence-based feeding guidelines, confusion, scepticism, and expanding food options complicate caregivers' decision-making,(8,9) but the precise influences on caregivers' feeding decisions are not well understood. This study explored how caregivers navigate these complexities, comparing the motivations, contextual influences and relational dynamics that underpin feeding practices for children and pets. This enables understanding of household caring dynamics and supports the development of nutritional interventions within a One-Health framework.
This qualitative study examined factors that influence caregivers' diet choice, feeding practice, perceptions of nutrition and level of attachment to dependants. UK-based caregivers ≥18 years with responsibility for >1 child aged ≤10yrs and a cat/dog were recruited between July-November 2024. Purposive sampling ensured participant diversity according to shared characteristics, such as age, gender, dietary preferences, feeding habits and diet choice. Semi-structured online interviews were conducted with 17 participants. Given its exploratory nature, the study employed an inductive, data-driven approach rather than being guided by a pre-existing theoretical framework.(10) Data was analysed by the lead author using the nine heuristics of interpretive thematic analysis.(11) Rigor of this single coder approach was achieved through data immersion, maintenance of an audit trail and by giving the developing analysis some distance.(11,12) Ethical approval was granted.
Three main themes highlighted caregivers’ perceived importance of nutrition across species, with feeding framed as a core caregiving responsibility and considered central to health and wellbeing. Caregivers relied on observable cues, emotional feedback and socially shared norms to judge ‘appropriate’ nutrition for children and pets. Up to three themes (eight subthemes) emerged regarding children’s diet and feeding practices, and two themes (seven subthemes) regarding pets. Children’s food choices were negotiated within bidirectional feeding relationships, where preferences, routines, and agency influenced what was eaten. Caregivers balanced healthy eating aspirations and preservation of long-term relationships with food, against time pressures, financial constraints and fears of coercion. In contrast, pet feeding decisions were more routine-driven, shaped by trust in commercial foods, perceived nutritional adequacy, and pet-specific needs, with cost and convenience identified as dominant influences. Regarding attachment, although pets were considered family members (theme one), their feeding reflected greater dependency and lower priority relative to children (theme two), revealing how caregiving hierarchies shape feeding behaviour of both dependants.
Findings help explain why people feed dependants the way they do. Caregivers’ commitment to nutrition as a marker of responsible, optimal care coexisted with everyday constraints. Diet-related recommendations must acknowledge emotional bonds, relational dynamics, and practical constraints, rather than focusing on information provision and assuming rational, knowledge-led feeding behaviour.