To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
Offering a convincing account of the merchant political economy, its demise in the nineteenth century due to increasing market instability, and the rise of industrial, productivist capitalism as an answer to this crisis, allows us to reassess the project of “total history” developed by the French Annales School in the twentieth century. Rather than retreating into cautious empiricism, or giving up on logocentric meta-narratives, it is proposed to focus on historicizing analytical categories to try and recapture their meanings in the context they were used in the past, thus avoiding presentism. Moreover, asserting the essential variability of sociopolitical equilibria accounts for the diversity of observed societies, while maintaining the notion of an overarching political economy with meta-rules applicable throughout it. This distinction also allows us to differentiate structural change – the shift from one political economy to another, not necessarily a progress but certainly a break – from short-term political upheavals, important but not game-changing. Last but not least, whether the resulting narrative is optimistic or not becomes a political assessment, not a historical one.
This article investigates the relationship between members of the American branch of the International Workingmen’s Association and the women’s rights movement. The International in the United States supported the formation of women workers’ sections. Its members also tended to privately support women’s suffrage, but did not want its inclusion in the International’s platform. In the United States, the question of what women workers should be organized toward was refracted through the struggles over voting rights and political power ushered in by Reconstruction. What distinguished this question in the United States was the entanglement and disentanglement of the abolitionist, feminist, and labor movements, particularly with regard to the passage of the Fifteenth Amendment to the Constitution. Drawing on the papers of the North American branch of the International Workingmen’s Association as well as the minutes of labor and women’s rights conventions, this article shows that the split in the International over women’s suffrage was fundamentally over the question of political power. First, this article examines the split between former abolitionists and the women’s rights movement, which led suffragists such as Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony toward organized labor. The second part follows the split over Section 12’s rise and fall within the International, culminating in Victoria Woodhull's candidacy for president of the United States. The article then moves toward the ruling of The Hague Congress of the International against Section 12 in the third part. Finally, it concludes with Section 26 in Philadelphia’s attempt to enfranchise women in the state constitution of Pennsylvania.
This paper situates José Carlos Mariátegui’s Marxism in the context of emergent anti-Bolshevism in interwar Perú and Latin America. In doing so, the paper locates a moment of overlooked coherence between Mariátegui’s vernacular and universalist interpretations of Marxism during the 1920s in the pragmatic dimension of political meaning. Both Mariátegui’s conceptually national and global uses of Marxism were, in part, responding to the same, hostile context of anti-Bolshevik Othering in Perú, and they were both intended to undermine that project in order to effect the globalisation of Marxism from Europe to Latin America. The paper therefore bridges the gap between the Latin Americanist reading of Mariátegui’s thought and the more recent, global turn in scholarship, by suggesting a way to understand the different scales of Mariátegui’s Marxism holistically.
In 1867, Harriet Law (1831–1897) was the first woman to be elected to the General Council of the International Working Men’s Association. Until 1868, she was the General Council’s only woman. Law was already well known in Britain for her outspoken feminism and as a prominent activist within the organized Secularist or Freethought movement. She was also a socialist and supported Karl Marx against some of the more moderate members of the General Council. This article argues that, despite Marx’s impatience with organized Secularism, Harriet Law’s involvement in Freethought is crucial to understanding how she came to be an early feminist voice in the International. Secularism supported women leaders and speakers and fostered an unusually militant and unrespectable form of feminism at a time when the newly organized British women’s movement pursued a much more cautious public image. Law’s feminism combined support for women’s education and professional employment with advocating for the rights of women workers and a strong critique of the Christian institution of marriage. She saw feminism as going hand-in-hand with socialism and was an early campaigner for universal enfranchisement for both women and men. Her socialism was internationalist in its vision, and she also denounced British imperialism and antisemitism.
This chapter considers unlikely affinities between liberal human rights discourse and Marxist theories of guerrilla warfare. Commonly seen as worlds apart, these modes of action converged after 1968 in their parallel emphasis on spectacle. Both aimed to capture the attention of prospective spectators and witnesses. As each shaped the other, the intended audience of the spectacles turned inward. To demonstrate, this chapter presents a history of activist discourse in 1970s Iran, where we see a shift in the use of human rights discourse, from moral appeals about injustice directed at powerful parties abroad to spectacular projections of aggrievement and loss directed at one’s own community. Conventional distinctions between individualism and collectivism, and guerrilla warfare (deemed revolutionary) and human rights (deemed counterrevolutionary), become tenuous as a result. While liberal and Marxist activists were marginal to the mass movement of the late 1970s, their unintended collaboration draws a sketch of the collective subjectivity that later prevailed.
This chapter proposes an approach to social science inquiry suited to the Iranian case and, more broadly, to the silences that constitute revolutionary mobilization and memorialization. With reference to a partial archive of interview data with people who experienced the mass uprisings of late 1978 and early 1979, and analytical statements they made in interviews about their experience of popular assemblies, the chapter shows how individual accounts from opposing ideological positions and social classes converged around a shared concept of collective identity in the image of Zaynab bint Ali. The chapter weaves between interviews conducted with pro-Khomeini Islamists active in Iran during the late 1970s (all of whom were men) and interviews conducted with women from leftist groups or unaffiliated members of the population as well as stories from a women’s daily magazine published at the time. It shows that narrative reception and judgment play an important role in revolutionary action, the representation of which augurs a comparative methodology for social science inquiry about revolution in the Global South.
During the first half of 1978, mourning processions were held in Iran for activists felled in prior demonstrations. The device occasioned subsequent political protests, fostering a series of horizontally organized demonstrations that lasted six months. Accounts of what transpired, published in pamphlets at the time, are replete with exhortations for others to join. The documents extend discursive patterns found in courtroom appeals and defenses made by leftist activists over the course of the twentieth century. In this language, we find visions of a collective revolutionary subject configured as an individual worthy of empathy and observation, recalling overlaps between human rights advocacy and guerrilla warfare. The discursive pattern challenges divides between materialism and culture in the study of modern Iran. Analyses of the revolutionary process in Iran make recourse to pragmatism, and yet they elide the importance of language and culture displayed here. This chapter argues that a pragmatic sensibility corresponds with adaptations of the Karbala paradigm in Taziyeh processions. To the extent that the former reflects individual investments in self-preservation, the latter cultivates investment in communal self-preservation through memorialization.
The introduction begins by connecting the prevalence of apocalyptic expectations and end-of-the-world scenarios in our culture to the dystopic dominion of capitalism, offering some basic definitions to clarify the key concepts. While there seems to be no alternative to this dominion, I pose the central question of whether the church can be a site for contestation and transformation.
Drawing from the analysis of the prior argument, this chapter describes how the Marxist utopianism of Fredric Jameson plumbs a deeper reading of the political unconscious capitalist culture to illuminate how, despite the pervading sense of dominance, antagonisms remain, opening possibilities for transformation. In the end, however, his utopianism remains a politics of via negativa and, thus, unable to provide a real alternative.
Interlude 2 compares the lives and ideas of Radhabinod Pal and Samuel Eisenstadt. Both were shaped by the political upheavals of 1905 in Europe and Asia. They both devoted parts of their academic works to defending their respective religious legal systems, Hindu and Jewish law, against Western evolutionary narratives, seeking to downplay hierarchical elements such as caste structure or gender inequality that existed in these systems, and both embraced a vision of the legal past aimed to challenge Western cultural dominance. However, Pal portrayed Hindu law as a stabilizing force, while Eisenstadt, a socialist-turned-communist, cast Jewish law as revolutionary and egalitarian. Another difference between them was that while Pal, influenced by English jurisprudence, was uninterested in the idea of legal revival, Eisenstadt, who assimilated the ideas of the German Historical School, actively promoted Jewish law as a foundation for Israel’s legal system. The interlude ends with a reflection on the way Pal and Eisenstadt used their respective religious legal traditions to construct utopian alternatives to Western law, idealizing Hindu and Jewish law, and overlooking the flaws in their traditions.
Chapter 4 discusses the life and thought of Samuel Eisenstadt, one of the founders of the Tel Aviv School of Law and Economics. Eisenstadt was a Russian-born Jewish legal scholar. His career spanned pre-revolutionary Russia, the Soviet Union, Mandatory Palestine, and Israel. His legal scholarship drew on the German Historical School, which viewed law as a historical and cultural phenomenon, and on Marxist legal theory, which described law as an instrument of class struggle. Eisenstadt sought to show the superiority of Jewish law, for example, by arguing that traditional institutions of Jewish legal education were better than Western ones because of their non-elitist and non-materialist nature, or by arguing for a genealogy of labor and international law which located its origins in the Bible. Eisenstadt was also engaged in apologetic efforts to defend the more problematic aspects of Jewish law, such as its treatment of slaves and women. Eisenstadt’s legal thought provides an example of the intersection of legal nationalism and socialism, and the attempt to reconcile Jewish traditions with progressive ideology.
In this chapter, I consider the deployment of the dominant philosophical conception of hope within political theory. I introduce different contexts in which political theorists ascribe hope an instrumental value, based on its suggested power to motivate agency: these theorists claim that belief in the possibility of a specific future can generate the confidence to engage in important political action. After discussing the relationship between agency and hope (found originally in Aristotle), I consider an ambitious neo-Kantian attempt (put forward by Jakob Huber) to vindicate the instrumental value of hope for democratic politics on a non-contingent basis. I argue that this attempt fails but does so instructively, as the power it ascribes to hope comes from an auxiliary concept, which is faith. I find further endorsements of hope that depend on a prior commitment to faith (in a moral sense) in the thought of Kant himself, and (in a predictive sense) in the Marxist tradition, and I suggest the value of separating these two ideas.
In this chapter, I consider whether Rorty’s political theory can make sense of the legitimate hopelessness/despair that might follow entrenched marginalisation or historically embedded forms of injustice. Since Rorty appears to present hope as a political attitude and theoretical disposition that we can embrace relatively straightforwardly, we might read his normative commitment to liberalism as an expression of privilege that is incapable of getting to grips with urgent political struggles. To determine Rorty’s response to this concern, I juxtapose his critique of Marxism to his interpretation of feminism, arguing that his reasons for rejecting the former (as held captive by scientism) relate to his affirmation of the latter (as the expression of political and philosophical hope). I then explore whether Rorty’s thought can make sense of the concept of power. Finally, I show how one of the most striking contemporary implications of Rorty’s world view is that commitment to political realism is hopeless.
This chapter describes the way capitalism, while posing as simply an economic process, captures the political will, commandeering the state and colonizing the subject to its regime of accumulation so as to eliminate politics and secure its dystopic order.
There has been a longstanding tendency within the domain of Turkish and Comparative Literary Studies to associate the history of Turkish modernism with Nâzım Hikmet’s early career in the Soviet Union by focusing on his mediation of the international avant-garde. While his early futurist poems calling for the abolition of traditional verse are frequently cited as illustrating the emergence of Turkish modernism, his prose poems “The Gioconda and Si-Ya-U” and “Why Did Banerjee Kill Himself?” signify the conclusion of a Soviet-inflected Turkish avant-garde. Acknowledging the importance of Nâzım’s early poetics, this chapter provides a more comprehensive and multifaceted account of Turkish modernism’s “Easterly” trajectory. Scholars of Middle Eastern and Comparative Literary Studies refuse to ascribe any literary value to socialist realist aesthetics, immediately dismissing it as Soviet-sponsored dogma. Challenging this critical “prejudice” against leftist literatures (excepting the avant-garde), this chapter demonstrates that the history of Turkish modernism cannot be understood without exploring its entanglements with the histories of socialist realism and Marxian aesthetics.
Chapter 20 focuses on Lima Barreto’s 1915 masterpiece, Triste fim de Policarpo Quaresma. The novel pits the ethical ideal of Policarpo Quaresma against the widespread corruption of Brazilian society under the First Republic. It suggests that individuals tend to act with more integrity when alone than when part of a group. The story reaches a dead end when Quaresma, with his naive idealism, tries to apply his values within society. His “sad end” raises key questions about the tension between personal ethics and collective action – questions that reveal Lima Barreto’s conservative perspectives, as the chapter demonstrates. This chapter deepens the conversation on ethics and praxis by interpreting the novel through the lens of ancient Stoicism contrasted with modern Marxism. The result is an ironic effect: Lima Barreto hopes to inspire social change through literature, yet his literary hero fails to bring that change to life.
What if the deepest resources for globalizing IR lie not in capitalist modernity, but in humanity's much older struggles against hierarchy? This Element argues that Global IR cannot become genuinely anti-Eurocentric unless it breaks decisively with 'methodological presentism': the tendency to read the past in terms of the present. Engaging Global IR debates, and drawing on Karl Polanyi, Political Marxism, and evolutionary anthropology, the Element offers a non-presentist macro-historical narrative. It mobilizes deep history to trace the millennia-old human capacities to refuse domination, pursue autonomy, and sustain cooperation, thereby inviting readers to fundamentally rethink the sources of human interconnectedness and solidarity. On this basis, it proposes 'radical modernity', rooted in the prehistoric legacy of 'radical egalitarianism', as an alternative to capitalist modernity. Radical modernity is not a Western achievement later diffused to the non-Western world, but an alternative foundation for rethinking universality, difference, and the 'international' from below.
The book offers a critical history of how international law governs information to entrench unequal distribution of wealth and power since the end of World War II. Mapping doctrinal and institutional developments of various subfields in international law that concern the organization of cross-border information flow, this book identifies a dual-sided framework consisting human rights and free trade as a hegemonic framework for the governance of information. Drawing on Marxist legal theory, Third World Approaches to International Law, critical media studies, and heterodox political economy, the book argues that this framework, despite persistent internal contradictions and external contestations, has evolved to facilitate the expansion of capital and reproduce hierarchy throughout three eras of capitalist transformations of the past eight decades.
The urban and rural collectivization campaign of the Great Leap coincided with a nation-wide debate on the law of value, bourgeois right, and the socialist economy. This chapter demonstrates how what appeared to be an abstract discussion among economists, social scientists, and party theoreticians was in fact intimately connected with and relevant to the praxis of urban collectivization. This was neither the case of a theoretical position or an ideological argument at the top fueling a policy change at the bottom, nor that of a political experiment at the street level which needed to be justified and rearticulated at the level of Marxist theory. Rather, the two aspects – as it often is for Marxist politics – were interdependent, co-determined, and yet always in a state of profound tension. Understanding the Great Leap Forward requires insights into both theoretical abstraction and the world of quotidian praxis.
Overshadowed by other international journeys, Ginsberg’s six months traveling alone through South America in 1960 have been relatively neglected by biographers and critics. However, recent editions and new research enable a better understanding of the literary and political significance of his geographic and drug trips in the region. The long-delayed publication of his South American Journals in 2019 reveals how prescient Ginsberg was to see the visionary value of ayahuasca (aka yagé), the indigenous psychedelic, set against the policing of reality by a materialistic world. His journals also show the full extent of his spiritual crisis in South America and his difficulties in finding a poetic form to express his experiences. Although The Yage Letters has been neglected by Ginsberg scholars, the complex backstory of the book of South American trips he coauthored with William S. Burroughs reveals a much greater role in its creation.