Crossref Citations
This article has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by
Crossref.
Kleindienst, Nikolaus
Priebe, Kathlen
Görg, Nora
Dyer, Anne
Steil, Regina
Lyssenko, Lisa
Winter, Dorina
Schmahl, Christian
and
Bohus, Martin
2016.
State dissociation moderates response to dialectical behavior therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder in women with and without borderline personality disorder.
European Journal of Psychotraumatology,
Vol. 7,
Issue. 1,
Otgaar, Henry
Muris, Peter
Howe, Mark L.
and
Merckelbach, Harald
2017.
What Drives False Memories in Psychopathology? A Case for Associative Activation.
Clinical Psychological Science,
Vol. 5,
Issue. 6,
p.
1048.
Smeets, Tom
Merckelbach, Harald
Jelicic, Marko
and
Otgaar, Henry
2017.
Dangerously Neglecting Courtroom Realities.
Applied Cognitive Psychology,
Vol. 31,
Issue. 1,
p.
26.
Jurchiș, Răzvan
and
Opre, Adrian
2018.
A Dual Process Approach to Current Issues from Cognitive Behavior Therapies: an Integrative Perspective.
International Journal of Cognitive Therapy,
Vol. 11,
Issue. 4,
p.
374.
Dobbin, Alastair
and
Ross, Sheila
2019.
How Memory Structures Influence Distress and Recovery.
Frontiers in Psychiatry,
Vol. 10,
Issue. ,
Kredlow, M. Alexandra
de Voogd, Lycia D.
and
Phelps, Elizabeth A.
2022.
A Case for Translation From the Clinic to the Laboratory.
Perspectives on Psychological Science,
Vol. 17,
Issue. 4,
p.
1120.
Nijdam, Mirjam J.
and
Wittmann, Lutz
2022.
Evidence Based Treatments for Trauma-Related Psychological Disorders.
p.
41.
Cooper, David D.J.
Popovic, Gordana
and
Grisham, Jessica R.
2023.
A novel experimental investigation of online imagery rescripting for obsessive-compulsive prospective imagery.
Journal of Obsessive-Compulsive and Related Disorders,
Vol. 37,
Issue. ,
p.
100799.
Zhou, Y.
Pennesi, J. -L.
and
Wade, T. D.
2023.
Eating Disorders.
p.
1.
Zhou, Yiwen
Pennesi, Jamie-Lee
and
Wade, Tracey
2024.
Eating Disorders.
p.
1437.
Zhou, Yuan
Pennesi, Jamie-Lee
and
Wade, T. D.
2025.
Eating Disorders.
p.
1.
Winter, Halaina R.
Norton, Alice R.
and
Wootton, Bethany M.
2025.
Imagery rescripting for social anxiety disorder via internet videoconferencing: An open trial.
Behaviour Research and Therapy,
Vol. 195,
Issue. ,
p.
104914.
Illum, Dyveke B
Døssing, Sidsel CB
Quistgaard, Maria
Jørgensen, Mie S
Møller, Lise
Gillies, Donna
Tang Kristensen, Magnus T
Nestved, Sabrina
Schaug, Julie Perrine
Gluud, Christian
Jeppesen, Pia
and
Storebø, Ole Jakob
2025.
Psychological therapies for post-traumatic stress disorder in children and adolescents.
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews,
Vol. 2025,
Issue. 5,
Wood, Jeffrey J.
Storch, Eric A.
Sung, Katherine
Wood, Karen S.
and
Kendall, Philip C.
2026.
Social Responsiveness as a Mediator in Adapted Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Autistic Youth with Maladaptive and Interfering Anxiety.
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,
Vol. 56,
Issue. 10,
p.
3755.
Du, Zekai
Cheng, Chen
Liu, Mingfan
and
Niu, Juan
2026.
Imagery Rescripting induced transient forgetting of negative autobiographical memories.
Memory,
Vol. 34,
Issue. 5,
p.
522.
Two opposing views concerning memory change have held sway in cognitive science as in psychotherapy research (Brewin Reference Brewin1989; Reference Brewin2006). One states that interventions such as supplying misinformation or conducting psychological therapy can in principle result in a permanent change in the underlying memory representation: Here, Lane et al. argue for this position and that it is attributable to a process of reconsolidation. The alternative view is that representations cannot be permanently altered, and that such interventions create new memories that leave the original intact. Whether old or new memories then determine behaviour is decided through a process of retrieval competition, with the most accessible memory having the greatest influence (Brewin Reference Brewin2006).
Reconsolidation has not yet been extensively studied in humans, and there is controversy over whether it has been unambiguously established. A number of studies have used reconsolidation manipulations to reduce people's emotional response to a fear-inducing experience, an approach which leaves the declarative recollection of that experience intact. Other studies, such as those reported by the authors, have demonstrated changes in memory for one set of objects brought about by participants being given an indirect reminder of this set just before being exposed to a new set of objects. Using this design, in which there is no explicit retrieval of the original memory, it is hard to prove unambiguously that reconsolidation has taken place, although other recent research has addressed some of these issues (Chan & LaPaglia Reference Chan and LaPaglia2013; Kroes et al. Reference Kroes, Tendolkar, van Wingen, van Waarde, Strange and Fernandez2014).
Even if the manipulations in these studies are producing genuine reconsolidation effects on declarative memory, these are relatively small in absolute terms. They are also obtained with designs involving the memorisation of personally meaningless stimuli. Given apparent boundary conditions for reconsolidation effects (Alberini et al. Reference Alberini, Johnson, Ye and Alberini2013), such effects might not occur with memories of painful experiences that people have recalled and perhaps ruminated over dozens if not hundreds of times. Moreover, anxious individuals may be less likely to show fear-related reconsolidation effects (Soeter & Kindt Reference Soeter and Kindt2013). Finally, the claim that memories have been permanently changed can logically only be studied by thorough retesting and trying to elicit the original memory in another way, something that remains to be done.
Some predictions made by Lane et al. do not obviously favour a reconsolidation approach. For example, one suggestion was that propranolol is likely to be contra-indicated in post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) therapy because it may slow the reconsolidation of memories that incorporate a new sense of safety. Preliminary evidence appears to support the use of propranolol, however (Brunet et al. Reference Brunet, Poundja, Tremblay, Bui, Thomas, Orr, Azzoug, A, Birmes and Pitman2011). The authors also suggested that selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) are likely to impair the processes of change in psychotherapy because their adverse effects on REM sleep interferes with reconsolidation. However, most of the evidence suggests that psychotherapy in combination with SSRIs achieves better outcomes than alone (e.g., March et al. Reference March, Silva, Petrycki, Curry, Wells, Fairbank, Burns, Domino and McNulty2004; van Apeldoorn et al. Reference van Apeldoorn, van Hout, Mersch, Huisman, Slaap, Hale, Visser, van Dyck and den Boer2008).
The main alternative possibility is that psychotherapy creates new memories that compete with existing ones. Many contemporary theories of human and animal cognition (e.g, Kesner & Rogers Reference Kesner and Rogers2004; Poldrack & Packard Reference Poldrack and Packard2003) favour the idea that learning produces a variety of new representations that can collaborate or compete with existing memories for control of behavior. Lane et al. mention extinction, a well-established therapeutic process which is thought to operate in this way, but do not explain why they consider reconsolidation to be a more likely candidate for explaining therapeutic change.
Among the advantages of a retrieval competition approach are that it does not assume a very malleable memory system that is constantly subject to change. In evolutionary terms, it would seem better to have a memory system that was able to keep a permanent record of extremely stressful or threatening events, because this information could be critical for survival. In fact, although it is fashionable to emphasise the malleability of memory, there is also plenty of evidence for its stability and reliability (Brewin & Andrews, submitted). This is hard to explain if memories are constantly being updated, leaving no trace of the original behind.
Another advantage accrues from the fact that relapse is reasonably common even after successful psychotherapy. This is hard to explain if it is assumed the underlying memory has been permanently updated. It is much more consistent with the idea that recovery is brought about by the creation of stable alternative memory structures but that the original remains able to be reactivated under a specific set of circumstances. This is a helpful model when teaching relapse prevention procedures to patients nearing the end of a course of therapy. It emphasises that the return of negative feelings and cognitions is a continuing hazard but one that is not catastrophic and that probably reflects the presence of specific triggers. Patients can then be encouraged to re-institute the coping mechanisms they have been taught rather than interpret the relapse as a sign of treatment failure.
At present our understanding of therapeutic change is rudimentary, and proposals for new mechanisms grounded in cognitive neuroscience are extremely welcome. It is likely that the many varieties of transformation that patients undergo will never be explained by any one mechanism, whether reconsolidation or retrieval competition. Basic research on memory change does, however, constitute one of the most promising lines of enquiry presently available, and findings from both animal and human research have the capacity to deliver new insights into what makes therapy effective. Although I agree with the authors that different forms of memory, such as semantic and episodic memory, are strongly interlinked, this does not mean that they are all equally important in different types of psychopathology. There are also perceptual forms of memory that appear to be distinct from episodic memory and may become relatively disconnected within conditions such as posttraumatic stress disorder (Brewin Reference Brewin2014; Brewin et al. Reference Brewin, Gregory, Lipton and Burgess2010). It seems highly likely that our understanding of different change mechanisms needs to develop in tandem with a more differentiated view of human memory systems.