The original Mitchell forcing was discovered by William Mitchell in 1974 and used by him to prove that it is consistent that there are no $\aleph _2$
-Aronszajn trees, i.e., trees of height $\aleph _2$
and width $\aleph _1$
without cofinal branches. In recent years, the technique underlying Mitchell forcing has been generalized by John Krueger and used to distinguish the variants of internal approachability which were introduced by Matthew Foreman and Stevo Todorcevic—given an elementary substructure $N\prec H(\Theta )$
of size $\mu ^+$
, we say that N is internally unbounded, internally stationary, or internally club depending on the largeness of $[N]^{<\mu }\cap N$
inside of $[N]^{<\mu }$
and that N is internally approachable if it can be written as the union of an increasing sequence which has all of its initial segments lying in N.
In this thesis, we generalize Mitchell’s forcing in a different way and construct variants of it to answer open questions due to Krueger himself and other authors.
In the first part of the thesis, we construct several useful tools: In Chapter 3, we introduce the concept of strong ${<\mu }$
-distributivity (asserting that every $\mu $
-sequence of open dense sets has a descending thread) and prove both a strengthening of Easton’s lemma concerning the interaction between the chain condition and distributivity as well as a variant of Foreman’s theorem concerning a connection between the completeness game and distributivity. In Chapter 4, we cast Mitchell forcing and its variants in an abstract way as partial orders on products of sets satisfying specific regularity properties and name a new sufficient condition for Hamkins’ approximation property. This is applied in Chapter 6, where we construct a general variant of Mitchell forcing and prove it to have various properties. In the intermediate Chapter 5, we prove the consistency of the existences of Laver guessing functions for various large cardinals.
In the second part of the thesis, we apply all of these tools to answer various open questions from the literature: In Chapter 7, we focus on the variants of internal approachability. Answering questions of Krueger, we prove that, consistently, the notions of internal stationarity and clubness as well as internal clubness and approachability can be distinct for structures of size $\aleph _n$
for all $n\geq 1$
simultaneously and, moreover, this distinction can be obtained from merely a countable sequence of Mahlo cardinals. Answering questions of Foreman and Todorcevic, we prove that it is consistent to have structures N such that, for some $\nu $
, $N\cap H(\nu )$
is internally approachable but N itself is not even internally club. Lastly, we answer a question of Levine by showing that the distinction between internal stationarity and internal approachability for $\mu ^+$
-sized elementary substructures of $H(\mu ^+)$
is not unconditionally equivalent to the existence of a disjoint stationary sequence on $\mu ^+$
—this statement, introduced by Krueger, asserts the existence of a sequence $(\mathcal {S}_{\alpha })_{\alpha \in S}$
where $S\subseteq \mu ^+\cap \operatorname {cof}(\mu )$
and every $\mathcal {S}_{\alpha }\subseteq [\alpha ]^{<\mu }$
is stationary and is equivalent to having a distinction between internal stationarity and internal approachability for $\mu $
-sized substructures of $H(\mu ^+)$
assuming $2^{\mu }=\mu ^+$
. In Chapter 8, we answer open questions due to Mohammadpour regarding the ineffable slender property, a strengthening of the tree property due to Weiß. For example, we prove that the ineffable slender property can consistently be indestructible under directed-closed forcing (similar to the Laver preparation for supercompact cardinals).
Abstract prepared by Hannes Jakob.
E-mail: hannes.jakob@unt.edu.
URL: https://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/262351.