To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
This final chapter draws together the arguments established in the book and outlines further perspectives for our understanding of the role of weak ties and strangers in human societies in both the past and present. It explores the northern emporia in the context of a global, comparative frame to understand in what ways they compare and contrast to developments elsewhere in the Early Middle Ages, and to urban networks in other periods. I review how emporia compare with other trading institutions in a broader historical framework. To this end, I point to the central but widely misconstrued role of encounters with strangers as part of human sociality. The conclusion points to a reality that lies deep within the history of social networks, which have been widely disregarded in archaeological models and social theory, but which in fact make sense of historical trajectories and the path to the present world.
This chapter compares the evidence from emporia and other early medieval maritime trading sites in order to understand how interactions between these places were organized, asking what marked out emporia among various kinds of meeting places. I take a comparative approach, drawing inspiration from historical geography and maritime archaeology, and demonstrate how emporia were located in conspicuous boundary locations, able to connect different modes and zones of transport. The most consistent characteristic of their archaeology is the evidence for a resident population of mixed, non-local residents — in other words, for strangers. By analysing finds, activities, and the chronological development of sites in a comparative perspective, I outline how communication occurred in different locations, and what was special about people and encounters in certain emporia.
Health Technology Assessment (HTA) agencies often lay out the methods and processes for recommendations through guidelines. However, evidence suggests that the presence of guidelines does not necessarily lead to more systematic, evidence-based decisions. This article explores the differentiating features of HTA guidelines that have successfully promoted change in decision-making practice.
Methods
We compared the development and impact of HTA guidelines over time in eight countries through a multi-case study design. Data from interviews and literature review were analyzed qualitatively by pattern matching.
Results
In settings without a guideline owner, guidelines were most successful if the development process targeted key stakeholders who are able to influence change in an open process of joint learning, and an agency with relevant expertise was assigned to oversee future guideline implementation and revisions. In settings with a clear guideline owner, guidelines were most successful if stakeholders continued to be engaged after guideline publication, to incorporate interim updates and when there was continuous learning between stakeholders and the HTA agency. Enforcing guideline compliance through laws was not found to be a predictor of guideline success nor was the level of HTA institutionalization in a country.
Conclusions
At any stage of HTA institutionalization, HTA guideline success depends on whether the development and revision process successfully builds shared understanding and trust among stakeholders. Ensuring HTA guideline impact requires an open and inclusive approach to stakeholder engagement during and after guideline development, as well as effective accountability mechanisms for guideline ownership.
This introduction examines the widespread contemporary use of “fascism” as both a historical term and a lens for understanding current political movements. It argues that fascism is increasingly invoked to describe phenomena ranging from populist far-right parties to extremist groups, reflecting fears that its appeal is pervasive, emotionally resonant, and resistant to legal containment. Recent publications, often aimed at broad audiences, have popularised diagnostic approaches, such as Umberto Eco’s concept of “Ur-Fascism,” which identifies recurring ideological traits without offering a precise definition. The discussion extends these concerns into the realm of music, questioning simplistic assumptions about fascist aesthetics and highlighting the complexity of cultural participation under such regimes. It proposes that music’s role in fascism cannot be reduced to propaganda but must be understood across broader social practices and historical contexts. The text introduces a volume that adopts a comparative, flexible approach to analysing the multifaceted relationship between music and fascism across time and place.
Chapter 9 focuses on using the CERIC method to compare two research articles. This chapter first motivates this practice as an essential activity in placing research in context and understanding the broader scope of a research area. It then discusses how one finds similar papers for comparison, emphasizing references, citations, and “similar paper” searches to select suitable articles for comparison. This chapter then delves into using the CERIC elements to conduct a detailed comparative analysis across texts, highlighting case studies to demonstrate this approach. This chapter describes methods of visually comparing CERIC elements to aid in interpreting commonalities and differences. It guides readers through turning the original CERIC reviews and comparisons into a coherent summary illustrated with practical examples.
This article explores rhythm and the īqāʿ rhythmic system as outlined in Persian music-theoretical treatises written during the fifteenth century, a period referred to in this study as the late Systematist period. The study seeks to enhance our understanding of the evolution of this rhythmic system over time, thereby contributing to the broader study of the entire Systematist period (circa 1235–1500). To achieve this aim, six Persian treatises from the fifteenth century have been meticulously selected and analysed. These include treatises by ʿAbd al-Qādir b. Ghaybī al-Ḥāfiẓ al-Marāghī, an anonymous author, ʿAlīshāh ibn Ḥājī Būka Awbahī, and ʿAlī b. Muḥammad Miʿmār. Comparisons and analyses serve as essential methodological tools for achieving the study’s purposes.
Recent scholarship devotes considerable attention to how social identities influence vote choice. However, group sympathies or group affect constitute another, often overlooked subjective component of the relationship between social groups and vote choice. Based on reference group theory and drawing on ANES data as well as recent Danish and Austrian election surveys, we examine how voters’ sympathies with a range of groups are related to party choice across time and space. We find that group sympathies are related to vote choice in all three countries, even when controlling for objective group memberships and social identities. Across time, most relationships are stable or strengthening and comparable in strength to the relationship between group memberships and party choice. The relationship between group sympathies and vote choice is, furthermore, conditioned by perceived linkages between groups and parties. Hence, analyses of the role of social groups in voting also need to include group sympathies to grasp the full influence of social groups.
This chapter demonstrates the importance of comparative analysis of the choice, placing and treatment of illustrations in the text. Here I list the eight surviving sets of the Lancelot-Grail made in the same cultural contexts. I analyse a pair of copies of the Estoire del saint Graal attributable to Metz in the late thirteenth/early fourteenth century, comparing them with MS Royal 14 E.III, the most fully illustrated surviving copy. Both Metz manuscripts show special interest in the end of the story and the tomb of King Lancelot, ancestor of Lancelot du Lac, and one of them shows particular interest in depictions of the Grail. Perhaps it was commissioned by a member of the clergy or by a devout lay person. In this period we have few names of patrons or makers and conclusions must be based on what is in each manuscript and the pictorial choices made there.
During the last two decades, there have been various attempts at measuring and assessing the health of civil society. Some have focused almost exclusively on ‘counting’ the nonprofit, while others have assessed the strength of nongovernmental organizations. Yet, these sectors are just a small part of a much larger environment. Moreover, they are the result of Western conceptualizations of civil society, thus not very helpful for one to understand civic participation in non-Western settings. Taking stock of these fundamental issues, this article presents the conceptual framework and methodology of a new global index to measure the ‘enabling environment’ of civil society, rather than its forms and institutional contours. Given the inherent diversity of civil societies worldwide, which defies any attempt at developing predetermined definitions, understanding the conditions that support civic participation becomes the most important objective for those interested in promoting a strong civil society arena. The index was launched by CIVICUS in late 2013 with the name of enabling environment index and covers over 200 countries and territories, making it the most ambitious attempt ever made at measuring civil society worldwide.
In the literature on a possible decline of participation levels, several factors are invoked as alleged causes for this trend. Most prominent among these are generational replacement, the spread of television, rising geographic mobility, increasing time pressure, marital instability, and the decline of religious affiliations. In Bowling Alone, Robert Putnam (Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community, Simon and Schuster, New York, 2000) lends credibility to the claim that these factors are at least related to the decline of participation levels in the United States, and might even be regarded as an underlying cause. In this paper, the author assesses whether these variables also have a bearing on the participation level of the Belgian population. The analysis of a Belgian survey (N = 1341) shows that for most of the invoked causes, the relation is not significant, although the decline in religious affiliation does seem a likely candidate for further research. The paper closes with some suggestions for future research on civic engagement.
Guided by organizational and social movement theories, this study compares the structures, resource bases, ideologies, and strategies of nongovernmental organizations engaged in peace and conflict resolution (P/CROs) in three regions with extended violent conflicts: Northern Ireland, South Africa, and Israel/Palestine. Qualitative content analysis techniques are used to analyze 27 detailed case reports. We analyze the funding patterns and structural attributes of the P/CROs in our sample, with particular attention to how they obtain fiscal resources and membership in spite of the risks they may experience. We then explore the degree of formalization among P/CROs over time and, finally, we examine the ideological frames that P/CROs use and how these frames relate to their tactics. Throughout the analysis we pay attention to how the political context of each region influences P/CRO behavior.
The disciplinary focus on explanatory research designs leads researchers to concentrate on differences between political systems to maximise variation in independent and dependent variables. This causes a bias in comparative analysis towards cross-spatial differences and a neglect of similarities and change that occurs in most or all political systems invariably and simultaneously. The article identifies the main reason for this bias is the misled perception that a strong focus on explanation is necessary for a discipline to establish itself as scientific. The article debates the consequences of such a distortion towards differences in a world in which interdependence and diffusion create convergence. It thus proposes a stronger role for (1) descriptive analysis, (2) cross-temporal explanation, and (3) ‘Most Different Systems Designs’ as ways to address parallel change, re-establish the balance of focus between differences and similarities, and control for diffusion effects.
Given its ubiquitous nature, sport events are one of the most popular venues for episodic volunteering around the world. This article explores the rare dataset of volunteering in sport events in seven countries—Finland, Ghana, India, Japan, Switzerland, Tanzania, United States—to overview the differences and similarities identified in demography, volunteers’ reactions to hosts’ management strategies, satisfaction, and intention to volunteer again. Key findings include differences in the level of satisfaction, where responses among American volunteers were the highest. We also find that although well-organized management strategies such as quality training, communication, and proper appreciation led to higher satisfaction, these factors did not contribute to volunteers’ intent to volunteer again. Such management style might be too impersonal with less autonomy on the part of volunteers that they may not feel needed in future events. Somewhat messy management might motivate volunteers to participate again.
According to the ‘social origin theory’ of civil society studies (Salamon and Anheier, Voluntas, 9(3): 213–248 (1998)), the nonprofit sector of today constitutes a ‘repository of former societal struggles and conflicts’. Correspondingly, nonprofits are embedded in administrative and organizational settings, which in many cases date as far back as the latter half of the 19th century—a time when industrialisation and urbanisation started to exert influence in the western world. France and Germany stand for very different societal traditions, political legacies and administrative structures. Traditionally, France is a highly centralized country in which local governments do not enjoy much autonomy. In contrast, Germany is a federalized country where self-government of local communities was introduced as early as at the beginning of the 19th century. Against this background, it comes as a surprise that, aside from few exceptions, the nonprofit sectors in the two countries are very similar. How does this come? We argue that the reason why the French nonprofit sector of today is very similar to the German nonprofit sector is closely linked to the growth of the welfare state in the two countries.
This chapter summarizes the empirical findings by comparing the three international courts. It shows that the EACJ has been the most deferential of the three courts, followed by the CCJ, and the African Court has been the least deferential. At the same time, the EACJ has the narrowest strategic space, the African Court the broadest and the CCJ lies between. The comparative analysis corroborates the theoretical argument of the book as each court’s deference closely aligns with its degree of formal independence and the extent of political fragmentation among its member states. The chapter revisits the book’s core argument by discussing the scope of the argument and considering its generalizability. It concludes with a discussion of the book’s implications for interdisciplinary research on international courts and IR literature on IOs in contemporary world politics.
This article argues that environmental justice extends beyond planning and decision-making to include enforcement as a critical, yet often overlooked, dimension. It advances the claim that incorporating environmental justice into enforcement law and policy is essential for addressing structural inequalities and promoting accountability in environmental governance. The primary objective of the article is to identify environmental justice guidelines embedded in enforcement frameworks, with the aim of strengthening the role of justice in regulatory practice and enhancing the equity and effectiveness of enforcement outcomes. The analysis focuses on three enforcement tools that reflect a flexible and responsive approach: (i) the United States’ Supplemental Environmental Projects, (ii) the United Kingdom’s Environmental Enforcement Undertakings, and (iii) Chile’s Compliance Programmes. The article draws on three sources of data: case studies, the environmental justice guidelines applicable to them, and the existing state of enforcement. It begins by examining the regulatory design of enforcement systems in the three jurisdictions; it then analyzes each tool to identify how environmental justice dimensions are integrated – or could be integrated – into their design and implementation. Finally, it assesses the practical application of these instruments, arguing that the deliberate incorporation of environmental justice considerations can improve the responsiveness, transparency, and legitimacy of enforcement mechanisms, which ultimately benefits both the environment and affected communities.
Throughout the 21st century, many welfare states have expanded family policies. However, the COVID-19 pandemic spurred significant, though varied, adjustments in family benefits across countries. This study conducts a qualitative comparative policy analysis of ten high-income countries, selected on the basis welfare regime theory, to examine how family policy changed during the COVID-19 crisis and whether these changes marked the beginning of new policy paths. The analysis shows that most institutional responses for families with children were incremental and temporary in nature, serving to reinforce rather than overhaul existing welfare systems. These results align with historical institutionalist theory and its emphasis on path dependence. Despite some convergence in emergency measures, long-standing differences in areas such as childcare availability and benefit generosity persist across the studies welfare state regimes. While the pandemic acted as a catalyst for certain policy innovations, it did not fundamentally disrupt the institutional logic underpinning family policy.
This article analyses the role of comparative analysis in free movement judgments of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). It argues that comparative analysis plays an important role in how the CJEU decides the outcome of free movement cases and that free movement law should thus be characterised as a comparative law method. The argument is developed in three steps. First, comparative analysis takes place in all structural parts of free movement cases. It is not exclusively or even primarily limited to the proportionality test. Second, the role of comparative analysis is directly linked to the effective application of the free movement provisions. This means that comparative analysis is not only relied on to engage in standard-setting (‘calibration’) in free movement cases—it is also used to determine which cases should fall within the scope of application of the free movement provisions (‘demarcation’). Third, because of the close relationship between comparative analysis and the effective application of the free movement provisions, it is possible to characterise negative integration as a comparative law method. Although one component of this method is based on the traditional functional method in comparative law, the main comparative method in free movement law is closely linked to cosmopolitan pluralism, because negative integration provides a ‘frame’ or structure through which Member States are required to investigate and respond to the national laws of other Member States. This method can be described as ‘the law of differentiation’, because it identifies, analyses the extent and assesses the legitimacy of differences in national laws in the context of the internal market.
Populism in relation to constitutionalism is a widely discussed and critical, topic. In the literature on the phenomenon, there is a prevalence to identify populism as antithetical to constitutional democracy and as eroding the idea and fundamentals of constitutionalism. However, as this chapter will show, much depends on the definitions offered of populism and constitutionalism, and the analytical commitment to study both as historical phenomena with important contextual differences. As I will argue in this chapter, constitutionalism as such is a contested phenomenon, and populism frequently takes up different forms of critique on the predominant legal understanding of constitutionalism. Furthermore, populism is a phenomenon that manifests itself in different ways, displaying diverse guises depending on distinctive ideological position (left- or rightwing), but equally showing variety in terms of positioning regarding characteristic issues, such as sovereignty, the definition of the political community, or relations to constituent power.
This study quantified the relative vulnerability of 3,141 counties in the United States. We built a comprehensive community vulnerability index (CCVI) that considers household, business, and public levels. Eighteen variables related to household socioeconomic characteristics, business size and diversity, local government economic size, social capital, and net immigration were used. In the existing vulnerability indices (CRE, SVI, and SoVI), the indices were constructed by using socioeconomic characteristics of the household. In addition to socioeconomic variables, this study sought to expand the concept of “place-based” by considering the business structure within the community and the potential ability to maintain the existing order of the community to construct a comprehensive index. Additionally, by providing the relative vulnerability of the community at each level (private, business, public), each dimension can provide evidence on which areas are more vulnerable and need remediation than others. We expect that the CCVI can be broadly extended to be used in various forms. In this study, we extend the vulnerability index by including exogenous variables such as climate change. In particular, the extended climate-enhanced CCVI in this study shows that the existing vulnerability index can be strengthened by incorporating extreme climate events.