More than 50 yr of research activities have documented efficacy of chemical controls for monoecious and dioecious biotypes of hydrilla [Hydrilla verticillata (L. f.) Royle] in the United States. Recently, a genetically dissimilar biotype of H. verticillata (“clade C”) was discovered in the northeastern United States. The response of three H. verticillata biotypes to eight aquatic herbicides with distinct active ingredients was simultaneously evaluated through a greenhouse-based herbicide trial. Planted apical fragments of monoecious, dioecious, and clade C H. verticillata biotypes were exposed to two concentrations of the following treatments: endothall, copper, diquat, florpyrauxifen-benzyl, and flumioxazin with 24 or 72 h of exposure, and penoxsulam, fluridone, and topramazone with 1,080 h (45 d) of static exposure. Posttreatment plant symptomology was visually evaluated and aboveground biomass was harvested 6 wk after the completed herbicide exposure period. Data were analyzed using mixed-effects models comparing response by treatment, biotype, and their interaction. Estimated visual injury of H. verticillata differed by treatment (P < 0.0001), and a significant treatment by biotype interaction (P < 0.0001) revealed some variation in visual treatment response among biotypes. Where differences in visual response to treatment by biotype occurred, clade C H. verticillata generally exhibited more injury than other biotypes. The reduction of H. verticillata biomass differed by treatment (P < 0.0001) but did not differ between biotype. Highly effective treatments (>90% reduction) against H. verticillata included endothall (2,500 µg ai L−1 [72 h]; 5,000 µg ai L−1 [24 and 72 h]), diquat (370 µg ai L−1 ppm [24 and 72 h]), and flumioxazin (200 µg ai L−1 [24 and 72 h]). This research demonstrates that all three U.S. H. verticillata biotypes respond similarly to herbicides when tested on a small scale with minimal environmental influence.