Wilder Penfield (1891–1976), founder of the Montreal Neurological Institute and pioneer of the Montreal Procedure, made landmark contributions to neurology and neurosurgery. However, his concurrent advancement of the ethical framework governing awake craniotomy is less examined. In an era when medical paternalism remained common, Penfield and his colleagues upheld patient-centered care, multidisciplinary collaboration, procedural standardization and rigorous boundaries between clinical practice and research. Through primary sources, including publications, case records, correspondences and biological accounts, this historical review traces how Penfield’s ethical commitments shaped the modern practice of awake craniotomy and established an enduring legacy relevant to contemporary neurosurgery.